Results¶
This table lists the overall results of the 24 methods. Detailed scores per method can be found in the subsequent tables. The SKI10 Zenodo repository contains papers describing many of the submitted methods. Search for papers with the same dates as the submissions.
| Rank | Team | Submission Date | Avg Bone Score | Avg Cart Score | Avg Total Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ZIB | 2017-11-27 | 77.88 | 73.60 | 75.73 |
| 2 | AMC_MIRL | 2017-03-20 | 78.28 | 69.85 | 74.06 |
| 3 | Imorphics | 2011-01-27 | 77.01 | 67.35 | 72.17 |
| 4 | ZIB | 2010-11-09 | 72.42 | 65.99 | 69.22 |
| 5 | UPMC_IBML | 2013-12-17 | 68.25 | 64.32 | 66.29 |
| 6 | SNU_SPL | 2011-06-09 | 67.14 | 61.57 | 64.34 |
| 7 | Biomediq | 2015-23-03 | 62.49 | 66.10 | 64.29 |
| 8 | UPMC_IBML | 2013-05-17 | 67.11 | 60.15 | 63.63 |
| 9 | shan_unc | 2013-08-13 | 64.02 | 61.47 | 62.74 |
| 10 | AMC_MIRL | 2016-07-26 | 65.57 | 58.37 | 61.98 |
| 11 | UIiibiKnee | 2010-10-19 | 62.12 | 61.47 | 61.79 |
| 12 | shan_unc | 2012-08-03 | 61.23 | 61.14 | 61.19 |
| 13 | SRIB-HME | 2018-08-20 | 55.79 | 65.49 | 60.64 |
| 14 | BioMedIA | 2013-07-22 | 51.75 | 64.88 | 58.31 |
| 15 | UPMC_IBML | 2012-08-24 | 54.97 | 58.36 | 56.66 |
| 16 | BioMedIA | 2013-02-25 | 50.77 | 62.33 | 56.55 |
| 17 | shan_unc | 2012-04-28 | 48.13 | 62.03 | 55.09 |
| 18 | SNU_SPL | 2010-06-23 | 49.69 | 58.97 | 54.33 |
| 19 | UIiibiKnee | 2013-04-09 | 49.25 | 50.02 | 49.63 |
| 20 | Quan Wang | 2013-11-26 | 22.53 | 59.31 | 40.91 |
| 21 | fractal | 2016-09-27 | 2.46 | 59.94 | 31.20 |
| 22 | sas_twente | 2012-02-09 | 16.26 | 30.61 | 23.44 |
| 23 | Local Regressors | 2010-11-24 | 23.60 | 22.90 | 23.25 |
| 24 | Dept. of Photogrammetry | 2010-10-19 | 10.54 | 30.39 | 20.46 |
Detailed Results for Rank 1¶
Team: ZIB
Affiliation: Zuse Institute Berlin, Germany
Submitted on: 2017-11-27
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.32
0.55
85.2
0.37
0.57
76.4
15.7
-2.5
86.8
11.2
-2.7
89.7
84.5
2
0.40
0.62
82.6
0.52
0.80
66.8
14.9
-5.7
79.8
15.4
0.8
91.7
80.2
3
0.40
0.65
82.3
0.36
0.53
77.6
21.1
9.3
68.5
21.7
1.2
88.0
79.1
4
0.63
0.90
73.6
0.44
0.72
70.8
20.2
-1.1
88.0
21.5
-11.9
66.9
74.8
5
0.35
0.60
83.9
0.29
0.48
80.7
12.6
3.0
87.2
18.6
-9.5
72.9
81.2
6
0.40
0.68
81.9
0.34
0.54
77.9
17.0
12.1
64.0
20.6
-2.9
85.2
77.2
7
0.51
0.84
77.0
0.44
0.70
71.3
16.6
-6.5
77.2
12.8
10.8
72.9
74.6
8
0.44
0.75
79.8
0.30
0.52
79.6
12.9
-8.6
73.9
12.5
-9.4
75.8
77.3
9
0.48
0.83
77.9
0.33
0.57
77.4
18.4
-11.9
63.8
22.4
-5.6
79.1
74.5
10
0.58
1.05
72.6
0.38
0.66
74.0
16.4
-12.6
63.1
14.5
-11.3
71.1
70.2
11
0.42
0.76
80.1
0.43
0.77
70.2
14.2
0.1
93.0
14.6
1.7
90.3
83.4
12
0.29
0.54
86.1
0.28
0.45
81.8
16.0
1.0
90.2
14.7
4.0
85.5
85.9
13
0.57
0.96
74.1
0.45
0.73
70.5
21.2
13.5
58.7
21.2
11.7
67.5
67.7
14
0.38
0.64
82.8
0.31
0.50
79.8
19.9
15.7
54.4
15.7
13.7
65.8
70.7
15
0.28
0.46
87.5
0.35
0.61
76.0
18.0
4.5
81.1
20.9
-2.4
86.0
82.6
16
0.28
0.45
87.5
0.28
0.45
81.6
13.3
1.2
91.0
15.4
3.7
85.9
86.5
17
0.48
0.81
78.2
0.32
0.51
79.1
19.2
15.2
55.9
36.0
-28.2
34.2
61.9
18
0.28
0.48
87.1
0.29
0.49
80.6
13.2
-5.5
81.2
17.1
6.6
79.3
82.1
19
0.30
0.51
86.3
0.39
0.62
74.4
15.1
1.1
90.5
22.9
-12.3
65.5
79.2
20
0.45
0.74
79.9
0.33
0.55
78.0
17.6
-0.1
91.5
18.1
-13.5
65.2
78.6
21
0.28
0.48
87.2
0.28
0.46
81.6
15.5
-2.1
87.9
13.8
-11.4
71.3
82.0
22
0.41
0.62
82.5
0.38
0.62
75.1
18.2
1.0
89.0
11.9
-9.1
76.8
80.8
23
0.40
0.68
81.6
0.44
0.68
71.7
18.8
-2.1
86.3
29.3
18.8
49.9
72.4
24
0.36
0.61
83.6
0.31
0.51
79.6
15.7
-3.9
83.5
16.4
-12.5
68.1
78.7
25
0.43
0.72
80.7
0.42
0.69
72.2
20.8
2.5
84.5
29.4
14.7
57.8
73.8
26
0.39
0.63
82.6
0.29
0.52
79.9
11.3
-1.0
92.4
22.2
-16.9
56.7
77.9
27
0.37
0.60
83.5
0.40
0.68
73.2
27.3
-5.0
75.7
11.5
-1.3
92.4
81.2
28
0.82
1.75
57.4
0.43
0.65
72.7
26.2
0.8
85.9
18.5
-13.4
65.3
70.3
29
0.35
0.57
84.4
0.39
0.60
74.9
16.9
-6.7
76.6
17.3
3.6
85.2
80.3
30
0.36
0.57
84.2
0.31
0.51
79.4
22.1
-7.9
71.4
27.3
-10.8
66.5
75.4
31
0.67
1.08
70.1
0.47
0.73
69.5
23.1
-1.4
86.0
26.6
16.7
55.2
70.2
32
0.38
0.62
83.0
0.28
0.45
81.7
19.2
6.3
76.5
22.0
12.1
66.3
76.9
33
0.29
0.51
86.5
0.31
0.58
77.9
17.1
-3.8
83.1
18.8
-16.4
59.2
76.7
34
0.41
0.98
77.2
0.28
0.50
80.6
31.0
39.9
35.4
14.5
-2.4
88.8
70.5
35
0.41
0.72
81.0
0.37
0.62
75.2
18.8
13.0
61.0
19.5
-16.0
59.7
69.2
36
0.27
0.47
87.6
0.33
0.52
78.7
12.8
-4.7
83.2
12.1
5.7
83.4
83.2
37
0.81
1.63
59.3
0.58
0.93
61.9
22.9
16.7
50.5
32.8
34.1
35.6
51.8
38
0.29
0.50
86.7
0.33
0.55
77.9
10.5
2.0
90.4
15.2
5.0
83.4
84.6
39
0.42
0.73
80.4
0.89
1.85
32.8
21.6
11.9
62.3
35.4
-0.1
84.2
64.9
40
0.34
0.54
85.1
0.34
0.56
77.3
16.1
1.7
88.4
16.5
7.3
78.3
82.3
41
0.44
0.70
80.5
0.42
0.70
72.0
18.5
-17.3
51.4
10.0
2.7
90.3
73.5
42
0.51
0.81
77.5
0.43
0.69
71.7
24.1
14.1
56.1
30.8
5.9
74.8
70.0
43
0.42
0.65
81.7
0.30
0.49
80.0
22.1
-1.5
86.2
11.4
-8.7
77.6
81.4
44
0.44
0.68
81.0
0.43
0.69
71.9
37.2
-9.0
61.8
30.5
-29.8
36.6
62.8
45
0.25
0.44
88.3
0.21
0.37
85.6
22.0
12.2
61.4
18.0
7.6
77.1
78.1
46
0.38
0.59
83.5
0.26
0.44
82.5
23.9
9.6
66.4
17.4
-7.8
76.9
77.3
47
1.29
1.62
49.2
0.65
0.86
61.5
65.8
4.8
58.0
32.7
-4.1
77.4
61.5
48
0.32
0.53
85.7
0.35
0.58
76.6
16.9
-4.9
80.8
16.0
-7.2
78.7
80.5
49
0.43
0.69
80.9
0.34
0.56
77.2
21.9
20.2
42.9
23.1
20.3
49.6
62.6
50
0.28
0.48
87.0
0.24
0.42
83.5
14.0
2.6
87.3
18.9
-7.7
76.4
83.6
Avg
0.43
0.72
80.5
0.37
0.62
75.2
19.7
2.2
74.8
19.8
-1.5
72.4
75.7
Detailed Results for Rank 2¶
Team: AMC_MIRL
Affiliation: Biomedical Engineering Center / Asan Medical Center, Korea
Republic of
Submitted on: 2017-03-20
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.33
0.69
83.0
0.36
0.56
76.8
19.4
0.7
89.2
18.3
-3.5
85.0
83.5
2
0.39
0.57
83.5
0.49
0.74
68.8
22.5
-19.5
44.3
18.4
-13.8
64.5
65.3
3
0.32
0.53
85.5
0.28
0.44
81.8
19.9
5.0
79.1
27.9
8.9
70.1
79.1
4
0.37
0.58
83.9
0.28
0.46
81.4
22.2
-8.6
69.6
17.2
-10.0
72.7
76.9
5
0.38
0.60
83.3
0.27
0.45
82.1
16.8
-9.0
71.2
21.7
-9.3
72.0
77.1
6
0.32
0.51
86.0
0.29
0.51
80.1
19.7
8.7
70.6
17.9
2.6
86.9
80.9
7
0.42
0.68
81.4
0.44
0.71
71.2
23.5
-14.7
55.0
15.2
9.3
74.9
70.6
8
0.42
0.69
81.1
0.27
0.45
82.0
22.9
-17.6
48.4
16.9
-13.5
65.8
69.3
9
0.46
1.50
68.9
0.34
0.69
74.8
22.9
-17.7
48.2
20.7
-3.7
83.6
68.9
10
0.49
0.87
77.2
0.31
0.56
78.5
21.7
-15.0
55.1
17.4
-15.1
62.4
68.3
11
0.43
0.89
78.0
0.31
0.58
77.9
20.7
8.6
70.3
21.9
-3.3
83.9
77.5
12
0.29
0.50
86.6
0.24
0.39
84.4
19.2
-3.6
82.7
21.6
13.9
62.8
79.1
13
0.55
0.91
75.3
0.43
0.67
72.2
30.5
21.6
35.6
34.1
7.0
71.1
63.6
14
0.32
0.51
85.8
0.27
0.43
82.4
25.0
21.2
39.3
16.3
12.8
67.5
68.8
15
0.24
0.41
89.2
0.28
0.52
80.1
20.8
7.3
73.3
18.6
10.5
71.1
78.4
16
0.30
0.47
86.8
0.20
0.33
86.9
24.1
2.1
83.7
21.9
1.7
87.0
86.1
17
0.58
0.90
74.6
0.36
0.55
77.1
26.9
5.5
74.5
30.2
-11.3
64.3
72.6
18
0.26
0.42
88.6
0.27
0.44
82.2
17.0
-4.9
80.5
21.0
10.0
70.9
80.6
19
0.28
0.47
87.4
0.36
0.59
76.1
18.4
3.5
83.3
22.6
-5.2
79.7
81.6
20
0.52
1.25
71.1
0.27
0.44
82.1
20.7
-0.7
88.7
22.3
-6.8
76.7
79.6
21
0.28
0.45
87.5
0.30
0.50
80.0
23.7
-9.7
66.3
20.3
-17.9
55.6
72.4
22
0.49
0.74
79.0
0.29
0.49
80.6
20.7
-0.5
89.2
15.7
-10.7
71.7
80.1
23
0.41
0.82
79.5
0.41
0.65
73.3
20.0
-3.5
82.5
34.4
40.9
34.9
67.5
24
0.34
0.54
85.1
0.29
0.47
80.8
19.9
7.8
72.7
16.5
-1.6
89.6
82.0
25
0.43
0.68
81.0
0.41
0.64
73.6
25.7
4.2
78.1
37.0
22.5
39.0
67.9
26
0.36
0.57
84.1
0.29
0.50
80.2
18.0
-12.1
63.6
23.9
-18.9
51.9
69.9
27
0.31
0.49
86.3
0.34
0.58
77.0
27.1
-5.1
75.5
24.3
-9.8
69.9
77.2
28
0.81
2.21
51.1
0.31
0.51
79.3
28.5
4.6
75.9
18.6
-8.9
74.1
70.1
29
0.34
0.52
85.4
0.34
0.54
77.9
23.0
-16.6
50.7
21.3
-0.4
89.9
76.0
30
0.31
0.49
86.4
0.29
0.49
80.4
24.2
-10.7
63.8
26.5
5.0
78.3
77.2
31
0.58
0.87
75.1
0.75
1.57
43.3
29.3
-6.3
71.6
29.4
2.1
82.9
68.2
32
0.35
0.55
84.6
0.28
0.43
82.0
20.4
10.1
67.1
21.5
9.1
72.5
76.5
33
0.37
0.54
84.4
0.36
0.55
77.2
22.5
-3.9
80.4
23.4
-18.4
53.2
73.8
34
0.41
0.98
77.1
0.21
0.37
85.5
29.1
29.4
36.3
17.3
5.0
82.4
70.3
35
0.35
0.56
84.6
0.32
0.55
78.3
20.8
0.1
90.0
21.6
-6.9
76.7
82.4
36
0.27
0.45
87.9
0.26
0.45
82.3
12.1
-4.5
83.9
13.7
1.9
90.2
86.1
37
0.91
2.04
51.4
1.09
2.53
15.1
20.5
15.3
55.0
33.9
33.7
35.1
39.2
38
0.26
0.42
88.3
0.26
0.42
82.9
15.1
-0.4
91.9
18.3
-1.4
89.2
88.1
39
0.42
0.68
81.3
1.64
3.59
0.0
33.6
-6.4
69.3
29.0
15.3
56.8
51.9
40
0.31
0.48
86.6
0.31
0.52
79.1
17.3
4.5
81.4
25.9
23.3
42.4
72.4
41
0.51
0.74
78.5
0.35
0.55
77.2
27.2
-26.3
37.2
21.2
6.0
78.8
67.9
42
0.45
0.66
81.0
0.40
0.63
74.2
29.0
2.4
80.8
23.0
15.3
59.6
73.9
43
0.34
0.52
85.3
0.27
0.41
82.9
26.1
1.4
84.5
19.6
-17.8
56.0
77.2
44
0.44
0.63
81.6
0.41
0.67
72.8
37.4
-0.3
81.7
19.5
-13.6
64.4
75.1
45
0.24
0.40
89.2
0.20
0.34
86.6
22.6
16.2
52.0
27.0
20.6
47.2
68.7
46
0.33
0.49
86.0
0.26
0.44
82.3
26.6
6.4
72.8
17.5
-1.7
89.0
82.5
47
1.07
1.34
57.8
0.57
0.75
66.1
62.3
-3.9
61.6
26.6
1.1
86.1
67.9
48
0.27
0.46
87.7
0.34
0.53
78.2
16.9
0.1
91.8
19.5
-8.3
75.0
83.2
49
0.43
0.65
81.6
0.31
0.69
75.7
25.7
11.2
62.0
22.7
15.6
59.0
69.6
50
0.28
0.46
87.4
0.23
0.39
84.6
20.0
-13.6
59.2
20.4
-1.0
89.1
80.1
Avg
0.41
0.71
81.2
0.37
0.64
75.4
23.6
-0.7
69.4
22.2
1.2
70.3
74.1
Detailed Results for Rank 3¶
Team: Imorphics
Affiliation: Imorphics Ltd, United Kingdom
Submitted on: 2011-01-27
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.30
0.53
86.0
0.30
0.51
79.9
11.7
-6.0
80.6
13.8
-5.6
82.8
82.3
2
0.44
0.68
80.9
0.35
0.58
76.7
22.9
-16.8
50.3
18.9
-15.3
61.4
67.3
3
0.33
0.55
85.1
0.23
0.39
84.4
18.4
7.5
73.9
23.6
5.2
79.2
80.6
4
0.46
0.71
80.1
0.38
0.59
75.5
33.3
-13.3
53.6
45.9
-35.1
29.8
59.8
5
0.33
0.61
84.1
0.33
0.62
76.6
15.7
0.6
91.2
19.1
-5.4
80.9
83.2
6
0.51
1.03
74.5
0.36
0.71
73.6
24.2
-1.4
85.5
19.6
-4.4
82.6
79.0
7
0.44
0.73
80.1
0.52
0.98
62.9
23.6
-17.9
47.5
15.9
0.9
91.3
70.4
8
0.51
0.94
75.6
0.34
0.65
75.6
27.0
-21.4
37.7
21.2
-15.3
60.3
62.3
9
0.50
0.92
76.1
0.38
0.65
74.1
31.0
-15.3
50.0
35.8
-17.5
49.6
62.5
10
0.60
1.08
71.8
0.39
0.71
72.9
27.5
-23.1
37.1
34.3
-28.3
34.9
54.2
11
0.42
0.81
79.3
0.36
0.74
72.9
16.1
-6.0
78.6
17.4
1.4
89.5
80.1
12
0.24
0.46
88.2
0.23
0.42
83.8
19.3
-8.7
70.7
18.8
3.2
85.3
82.0
13
0.68
1.30
67.0
0.61
1.25
54.6
31.9
21.5
35.3
30.5
17.1
52.6
52.4
14
0.34
0.54
85.1
0.32
0.59
77.3
25.6
10.3
64.2
17.1
6.3
80.0
76.6
15
0.23
0.41
89.2
0.27
0.50
81.1
18.2
3.6
83.0
18.0
-5.9
80.4
83.4
16
0.28
0.53
86.4
0.26
0.50
81.3
16.8
-9.4
70.3
14.8
2.2
89.1
81.8
17
0.74
1.23
66.6
0.36
0.67
74.4
33.0
-0.7
82.8
38.6
-29.7
33.0
64.2
18
0.30
0.54
85.9
0.43
0.78
69.9
18.3
-9.0
70.6
19.0
5.0
81.8
77.0
19
0.26
0.49
87.4
0.32
0.59
77.4
15.3
-2.6
86.8
24.6
-12.5
64.3
79.0
20
0.41
0.71
81.1
0.33
0.64
76.0
17.7
-2.4
86.0
21.1
-6.8
77.2
80.1
21
0.28
0.46
87.5
0.32
0.54
78.4
25.4
-15.9
51.2
21.2
-20.0
50.9
67.0
22
0.38
0.59
83.4
0.44
0.77
69.8
24.4
-12.8
58.9
16.6
-13.2
66.4
69.6
23
0.42
0.67
81.5
0.62
1.11
56.9
23.0
-3.7
80.6
39.8
43.3
32.5
62.9
24
0.42
0.74
80.4
0.35
0.62
75.9
20.8
-10.4
66.2
18.1
-10.0
72.1
73.6
25
0.63
1.40
66.5
0.66
1.25
52.9
24.5
-1.5
85.1
28.1
-2.7
82.2
71.7
26
0.41
0.73
80.9
0.30
0.60
77.9
17.4
-11.6
64.9
19.8
-15.2
61.0
71.2
27
0.41
0.65
81.8
0.38
0.70
73.3
44.4
-18.3
36.8
24.1
-12.9
63.8
63.9
28
0.59
1.63
64.1
0.37
0.58
76.0
21.8
0.8
87.9
30.7
-25.3
36.5
66.1
29
0.37
0.62
83.3
0.34
0.57
77.1
24.6
-17.4
48.1
31.0
-13.1
60.4
67.2
30
0.36
0.63
83.3
0.52
1.14
59.8
22.9
-13.1
58.9
30.7
-6.7
73.3
68.8
31
0.55
0.88
75.7
0.43
0.71
71.4
29.1
-3.3
78.7
37.0
14.7
54.6
70.1
32
0.40
0.67
81.9
0.28
0.47
81.0
27.6
0.4
86.2
23.4
15.7
58.5
76.9
33
0.28
0.51
86.6
0.29
0.55
79.1
21.3
-12.3
61.4
19.0
-12.6
66.7
73.5
34
0.36
0.99
78.3
0.24
0.44
83.1
31.3
30.3
35.3
13.8
6.0
82.1
69.7
35
0.39
0.70
81.6
0.38
0.78
71.5
19.9
6.4
75.7
19.5
-11.8
68.0
74.2
36
0.27
0.47
87.6
0.28
0.50
80.7
14.7
-7.8
75.0
10.7
-5.0
85.3
82.1
37
0.62
1.07
71.5
0.77
1.39
46.3
23.2
4.5
78.7
40.6
34.1
32.1
57.1
38
0.36
0.67
82.7
0.28
0.50
80.5
15.1
-5.4
80.4
16.2
0.7
91.4
83.8
39
0.49
0.93
76.1
0.77
1.32
48.0
26.5
0.7
85.9
26.0
20.7
47.5
64.4
40
0.27
0.48
87.3
0.36
0.73
73.3
14.3
-7.7
75.5
16.6
-4.0
84.7
80.2
41
0.48
0.77
78.9
0.37
0.64
74.7
23.0
-21.6
39.2
16.7
-2.3
88.1
70.2
42
0.43
0.66
81.3
0.30
0.47
80.4
24.9
11.7
61.1
25.8
11.3
66.1
72.3
43
0.36
0.59
84.0
0.33
0.54
78.2
27.9
-0.7
85.2
18.9
-16.0
60.0
76.8
44
0.38
0.59
83.5
0.42
0.75
71.0
26.5
-4.4
77.5
20.5
-2.6
85.9
79.4
45
0.24
0.48
87.9
0.21
0.40
84.8
26.8
-5.2
75.4
23.9
16.7
56.4
76.1
46
0.39
0.66
82.3
0.30
0.51
80.0
26.2
-4.3
77.7
24.8
-19.0
51.4
72.8
47
1.20
1.47
53.3
0.58
0.77
65.3
66.8
-4.3
58.7
34.4
-14.8
55.5
58.2
48
0.31
0.55
85.6
0.43
0.81
69.4
17.6
-6.2
77.5
18.0
-6.7
78.9
77.8
49
0.36
0.59
83.8
0.24
0.40
84.0
21.4
11.4
63.7
17.6
17.1
58.4
72.5
50
0.25
0.46
88.0
0.30
0.57
78.6
16.2
-9.1
71.2
19.7
-3.7
83.9
80.4
Avg
0.42
0.74
80.4
0.38
0.68
73.6
23.9
-4.8
67.9
23.4
-3.6
66.8
72.2
Detailed Results for Rank 4¶
Team: ZIB
Affiliation: Zuse Institute Berlin, Germany
Submitted on: 2010-11-09
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.53
0.79
77.3
0.52
0.81
66.6
18.5
-4.6
80.7
22.8
-13.1
63.9
72.1
2
0.46
0.67
80.6
0.47
0.65
71.5
26.4
-17.9
46.1
18.4
-12.1
67.9
66.5
3
0.63
0.90
73.7
0.42
0.65
73.1
25.1
14.2
55.3
19.9
-4.0
83.3
71.4
4
0.53
0.76
77.7
0.42
0.59
74.3
32.9
0.3
83.8
20.9
-11.0
69.0
76.2
5
0.48
0.73
79.3
0.39
0.59
75.2
20.8
16.9
51.1
22.9
-12.6
64.9
67.6
6
0.69
1.07
69.9
0.41
0.67
72.8
33.4
36.5
34.3
27.5
-10.3
67.6
61.1
7
0.49
0.79
78.0
0.52
0.75
67.7
21.7
-3.1
82.6
18.5
13.3
65.5
73.5
8
0.75
1.27
65.7
0.46
0.70
70.8
21.9
-13.3
58.9
26.7
-18.0
52.6
62.0
9
0.59
0.89
74.7
0.44
0.69
71.4
27.4
-13.7
55.3
27.0
-15.0
58.3
65.0
10
0.59
0.95
73.7
0.43
0.68
72.2
19.4
-13.2
60.4
30.2
-28.9
36.7
60.7
11
0.53
0.84
76.6
0.44
0.76
70.1
19.5
-2.6
84.7
29.1
-7.4
72.5
76.0
12
0.41
0.68
81.4
0.36
0.52
77.7
17.7
3.6
83.5
22.4
16.5
57.4
75.0
13
0.75
1.21
66.7
0.58
0.91
62.4
36.3
12.5
54.1
36.2
44.4
34.1
54.3
14
0.58
0.89
74.8
0.45
0.70
71.2
26.1
9.3
66.3
14.9
7.0
79.6
73.0
15
0.48
0.70
79.8
0.46
0.74
69.8
20.5
5.4
77.8
25.4
7.2
74.5
75.5
16
0.47
0.74
79.4
0.35
0.51
78.2
20.2
8.4
71.1
23.3
-3.0
83.7
78.1
17
0.54
0.89
75.7
0.41
0.61
74.0
27.9
21.0
38.2
24.8
-16.8
55.8
60.9
18
0.50
0.75
78.6
0.37
0.56
76.6
22.5
4.0
80.1
24.6
1.3
86.7
80.5
19
0.53
0.83
76.8
0.53
0.86
65.0
22.8
14.9
54.8
25.7
-14.4
60.1
64.2
20
0.66
0.92
72.7
0.47
0.72
69.9
26.7
7.2
70.9
38.4
-35.0
33.1
61.6
21
0.45
0.71
80.1
0.36
0.59
76.1
24.3
4.6
77.9
18.2
-4.9
82.3
79.1
22
0.51
0.82
77.4
0.37
0.60
75.7
25.2
6.1
73.9
13.2
-2.7
88.9
79.0
23
0.58
0.85
75.5
0.62
0.97
59.9
28.8
17.8
45.3
36.6
3.8
76.4
64.3
24
0.49
0.75
78.8
0.43
0.68
72.1
24.0
1.5
85.3
16.3
-1.4
90.1
81.6
25
0.59
0.87
74.9
0.60
1.05
58.8
20.7
0.6
88.8
20.0
5.7
79.8
75.6
26
0.61
0.92
73.8
0.42
0.68
72.5
18.3
-3.5
83.4
23.0
14.4
61.3
72.8
27
0.59
0.84
75.4
0.50
0.73
68.8
36.4
-8.9
62.3
31.9
-14.6
57.1
65.9
28
0.68
1.15
69.0
0.43
0.70
71.6
27.4
3.9
78.1
16.3
-6.9
79.1
74.5
29
0.53
0.83
76.8
0.43
0.67
72.3
17.6
-1.1
89.2
26.5
10.4
67.7
76.5
30
0.65
0.96
72.3
0.45
0.73
70.3
27.1
13.5
55.9
38.1
-22.2
39.1
59.4
31
0.62
0.94
73.4
0.43
0.66
72.3
32.4
7.7
67.0
27.9
0.8
86.1
74.7
32
0.48
0.71
79.6
0.44
0.63
72.7
31.9
7.0
68.8
30.0
18.9
49.3
67.6
33
0.47
0.74
79.4
0.43
0.69
72.1
20.9
-9.2
68.8
25.0
0.5
88.0
77.1
34
0.65
1.27
68.0
0.35
0.53
77.5
39.4
56.8
31.5
17.4
9.5
73.5
62.6
35
0.57
0.92
74.6
0.61
1.06
58.2
25.6
7.8
69.9
29.3
-25.2
37.2
60.0
36
0.51
0.76
78.2
0.38
0.58
75.6
15.2
-2.7
86.7
21.8
-12.0
66.6
76.8
37
0.79
1.43
62.7
0.58
0.99
60.8
25.2
6.5
73.1
30.8
17.5
51.7
62.1
38
0.48
0.73
79.3
0.36
0.58
76.3
17.6
4.4
81.7
19.4
8.6
74.3
77.9
39
0.64
1.01
72.0
0.97
1.79
31.7
37.5
4.0
73.2
45.3
-15.4
49.5
56.6
40
0.47
0.71
79.9
0.44
0.67
71.8
18.1
1.3
88.4
24.8
16.3
56.8
74.2
41
0.65
0.97
72.3
0.49
0.77
68.2
23.7
-14.5
55.2
20.8
-8.8
73.3
67.3
42
0.53
0.76
77.8
0.55
0.77
66.4
33.3
33.3
34.3
41.4
9.6
62.7
60.3
43
0.56
0.85
75.8
0.51
0.76
67.8
28.4
2.0
81.9
19.9
-9.3
72.9
74.6
44
0.71
1.19
67.9
0.63
1.01
58.9
32.4
-7.8
66.6
39.2
-38.0
32.8
56.5
45
0.46
0.69
80.4
0.34
0.52
78.3
26.5
6.5
72.6
23.5
17.6
54.7
71.5
46
0.53
0.82
76.9
0.46
0.76
69.4
33.6
4.2
74.5
27.3
-15.8
56.7
69.4
47
1.08
1.36
57.5
0.73
0.98
56.2
62.2
9.3
49.2
33.0
-0.9
83.8
61.7
48
0.55
0.80
76.8
0.49
0.78
68.2
23.3
7.0
72.9
27.8
-15.2
57.6
68.9
49
0.47
0.73
79.5
0.39
0.55
76.0
34.4
33.5
33.8
27.3
17.7
52.9
60.6
50
0.52
0.79
77.6
0.33
0.51
79.0
19.5
13.5
59.6
17.3
-1.3
89.8
76.5
Avg
0.57
0.88
75.1
0.47
0.73
69.7
26.4
5.8
66.8
25.8
-3.1
65.2
69.2
Detailed Results for Rank 5¶
Team: UPMC_IBML
Affiliation: UPMC, United States
Submitted on: 2013-12-17
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.45
0.76
79.5
0.41
0.68
72.7
21.8
-3.6
81.4
22.7
-13.0
64.2
74.5
2
0.71
1.06
69.6
0.77
1.43
45.6
31.7
-28.2
35.1
26.3
-22.5
43.8
48.5
3
0.58
0.89
74.9
0.48
0.94
65.1
25.0
-4.1
78.8
27.9
12.1
63.7
70.7
4
0.57
0.88
75.3
0.41
0.65
73.1
25.5
-3.6
79.6
17.9
-7.0
78.3
76.6
5
0.59
0.98
73.5
0.48
0.83
67.2
25.3
-14.3
54.9
26.5
-14.0
60.5
64.0
6
0.68
1.16
68.8
0.54
0.90
63.8
27.0
2.9
80.5
22.4
-4.4
81.5
73.6
7
0.60
0.89
74.4
0.66
1.06
56.8
24.9
-12.5
59.3
21.6
7.7
75.2
66.4
8
0.77
1.14
67.1
0.45
0.71
70.7
30.6
-26.1
35.6
28.7
-20.8
46.1
54.9
9
0.59
0.91
74.4
0.49
0.84
66.9
27.4
-17.1
47.6
25.4
5.3
78.3
66.8
10
0.69
1.11
69.3
0.47
0.84
67.6
25.6
-20.3
40.9
19.1
-15.2
61.4
59.8
11
0.66
1.11
70.1
0.50
0.91
65.1
18.6
-4.0
82.0
25.4
-2.9
83.1
75.1
12
0.39
0.67
82.0
0.37
0.60
75.6
23.5
-4.8
77.8
41.9
0.4
80.9
79.1
13
0.67
1.14
69.4
0.61
1.07
58.2
35.9
18.6
40.1
28.8
10.6
66.2
58.5
14
0.59
0.98
73.3
0.49
0.76
68.7
27.7
14.1
54.4
17.2
5.5
81.5
69.5
15
0.38
0.60
83.3
0.41
0.71
72.1
23.3
8.7
68.8
25.1
6.0
77.0
75.3
16
0.37
0.58
83.7
0.38
0.65
74.4
23.9
11.3
62.6
26.9
12.0
64.3
71.2
17
0.82
1.23
64.8
0.54
0.83
65.3
33.3
-1.2
81.6
32.0
-18.5
49.3
65.3
18
0.48
0.74
79.3
0.43
0.67
72.2
25.3
-14.3
54.9
21.6
-3.8
83.0
72.3
19
0.68
1.53
63.7
0.45
0.81
68.5
22.0
4.5
79.2
22.7
-12.6
65.0
69.1
20
0.70
1.11
69.1
0.41
0.70
72.1
20.2
3.1
83.4
32.8
-12.0
61.8
71.6
21
0.36
0.59
83.8
0.36
0.60
75.8
25.9
-11.5
61.2
29.4
-26.6
37.1
64.5
22
0.86
1.72
57.1
0.46
0.82
68.2
21.3
-0.9
87.9
20.8
-14.5
62.1
68.8
23
0.62
0.99
72.6
0.62
0.99
59.5
28.5
-4.6
75.9
45.6
26.9
29.9
59.5
24
0.75
1.67
60.0
0.58
0.92
62.4
23.4
-0.5
87.9
28.2
-6.7
74.3
71.1
25
0.57
0.86
75.4
0.55
0.90
63.6
25.5
-0.8
86.1
37.5
16.4
51.0
69.0
26
0.95
1.88
52.8
0.35
0.55
77.4
23.9
-18.4
46.2
26.4
-22.9
43.0
54.8
27
0.55
0.92
75.1
0.55
0.88
64.0
29.8
-11.3
59.9
25.4
-19.1
51.0
62.5
28
0.80
1.77
57.6
0.47
0.72
69.8
26.7
5.5
74.8
28.9
-20.6
46.5
62.2
29
0.68
1.08
70.0
0.50
0.78
67.6
35.8
-31.0
33.2
34.8
-10.1
64.7
58.9
30
0.59
1.02
72.8
0.48
0.88
66.2
28.8
-17.6
45.8
41.3
-10.0
62.0
61.7
31
1.02
1.47
57.1
0.76
1.19
50.8
39.0
-32.1
31.7
29.5
3.2
80.7
55.1
32
0.62
0.96
73.1
0.39
0.58
75.5
25.6
7.1
71.6
29.7
4.2
78.6
74.7
33
0.48
0.79
78.4
0.43
0.72
71.1
22.5
-6.2
75.1
31.8
-9.8
66.5
72.8
34
0.71
1.38
65.1
0.45
0.74
70.2
36.8
44.6
32.7
24.2
-1.5
86.4
63.6
35
0.59
0.95
73.8
0.55
0.95
62.5
26.5
-3.9
78.5
21.5
-11.9
66.9
70.4
36
0.40
0.65
82.1
0.44
0.79
69.4
20.0
-12.6
61.4
20.3
-9.3
72.5
71.4
37
0.91
1.51
59.0
1.18
2.54
12.0
30.8
0.3
84.8
39.8
26.8
32.5
47.1
38
0.52
0.98
74.9
0.34
0.59
76.8
17.0
-8.0
73.4
20.7
-2.1
86.7
78.0
39
0.60
0.97
73.2
1.97
3.50
0.0
31.9
1.3
81.9
29.0
15.8
55.9
52.8
40
0.51
0.80
77.6
0.53
0.84
65.6
27.0
-11.8
60.0
39.3
23.2
36.7
60.0
41
0.84
1.28
63.8
0.54
0.85
65.0
33.0
-31.9
34.5
13.2
-6.3
81.7
61.2
42
0.73
1.15
67.9
0.51
0.86
65.8
47.9
-20.4
30.3
30.9
1.8
82.9
61.7
43
0.76
1.21
66.4
0.52
0.82
66.4
29.6
-0.6
84.7
20.5
-14.9
61.4
69.7
44
0.64
1.02
71.7
0.53
0.83
65.7
35.7
5.9
69.6
25.6
-21.0
47.1
63.5
45
0.37
0.63
83.0
0.35
0.55
77.2
29.1
6.0
72.5
38.5
12.6
58.0
72.7
46
0.53
0.90
75.8
0.35
0.56
77.2
28.5
-1.1
84.0
25.1
-1.5
86.1
80.8
47
1.15
1.48
54.3
0.67
0.93
59.3
68.0
-10.5
43.7
33.6
-10.2
65.0
55.6
48
0.38
0.59
83.4
0.57
0.99
61.1
24.2
-12.7
59.2
24.0
-13.1
63.4
66.8
49
0.58
0.94
74.2
0.37
0.59
75.8
25.1
12.1
60.2
26.8
3.1
82.0
73.0
50
0.54
0.95
74.8
0.43
0.83
68.9
28.0
-20.1
40.2
22.6
1.8
86.5
67.6
Avg
0.63
1.05
71.4
0.53
0.90
65.1
28.3
-5.5
63.3
27.6
-3.7
65.3
66.3
Detailed Results for Rank 6¶
Team: SNU_SPL
Affiliation: Seoul National University, Korea Republic of
Submitted on: 2011-06-09
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.40
0.67
81.8
0.52
0.81
66.5
20.9
-0.9
88.1
27.4
4.1
79.8
79.0
2
0.65
0.91
73.0
0.51
0.77
67.8
23.7
-15.4
53.1
17.1
-7.8
77.0
67.7
3
0.65
1.02
71.6
0.45
0.70
71.1
33.7
17.9
42.8
38.4
26.5
33.1
54.7
4
0.59
0.87
74.8
0.38
0.61
75.1
27.8
3.2
79.5
22.1
-17.3
55.9
71.3
5
1.25
1.96
45.2
0.43
0.66
72.6
33.3
2.1
79.5
21.6
9.0
72.7
67.5
6
0.84
1.43
61.7
0.55
0.90
63.8
31.8
14.5
51.4
22.8
12.9
64.3
60.3
7
0.70
1.00
70.7
0.61
1.08
57.9
22.8
-8.4
69.7
21.8
0.1
90.2
72.1
8
0.74
1.03
69.5
0.49
0.79
67.9
26.0
-20.0
41.5
31.7
5.0
76.2
63.8
9
0.83
1.20
65.1
0.62
0.88
61.7
25.9
-18.3
45.5
42.5
19.9
41.9
53.5
10
0.83
1.31
63.5
0.52
0.86
65.6
31.2
-22.6
35.4
26.3
15.7
57.3
55.4
11
0.72
1.22
67.2
0.53
0.98
62.6
24.6
-0.0
88.3
31.6
7.4
71.4
72.4
12
0.48
0.81
78.2
0.39
0.63
74.4
31.9
-2.7
78.7
35.5
27.1
34.4
66.4
13
0.93
1.48
59.0
0.61
1.06
58.4
42.8
30.7
29.9
30.4
34.2
36.6
46.0
14
0.62
0.98
72.7
0.57
0.83
64.4
31.5
1.7
81.3
24.2
24.8
40.2
64.6
15
0.45
0.66
81.0
0.41
0.71
72.2
26.7
12.7
58.1
22.5
4.6
80.9
73.1
16
0.56
0.86
75.7
0.39
0.65
73.8
27.2
10.3
63.4
32.8
27.0
35.6
62.1
17
0.82
1.22
65.0
0.52
0.83
66.1
31.8
24.8
35.1
24.4
18.7
52.1
54.5
18
0.48
0.76
78.8
0.46
0.72
70.4
26.9
3.5
79.3
21.4
9.6
71.4
75.0
19
0.49
0.80
78.2
0.43
0.75
70.5
27.7
10.5
62.8
28.9
15.7
56.1
66.9
20
0.69
1.09
69.6
0.56
0.90
63.3
28.1
-11.7
59.8
32.2
5.4
75.1
66.9
21
0.51
0.86
76.9
0.45
0.77
69.4
23.7
0.4
87.8
27.5
0.4
87.1
80.3
22
1.07
1.97
49.1
0.47
0.71
70.1
24.5
-9.3
66.9
24.9
3.0
83.1
67.3
23
0.57
0.91
74.8
0.71
1.18
52.7
27.3
-2.4
81.6
44.9
55.3
30.2
59.8
24
0.71
1.22
67.4
0.47
0.76
69.2
23.8
10.3
64.9
24.4
7.6
74.2
68.9
25
0.74
1.28
65.9
0.69
1.13
54.3
30.6
3.7
77.0
42.3
19.2
43.2
60.1
26
0.89
1.26
62.8
0.46
0.76
69.5
22.0
9.0
68.8
26.4
2.8
82.9
71.0
27
0.63
0.97
72.6
0.49
0.79
68.0
31.7
-4.6
74.5
20.1
-1.1
89.0
76.0
28
0.96
1.79
53.8
0.53
0.83
65.7
32.3
14.7
50.7
22.6
-8.5
73.2
60.9
29
0.58
0.82
75.8
0.43
0.71
71.4
25.0
-8.0
69.7
29.0
19.4
48.8
66.4
30
0.54
0.88
75.9
0.66
1.27
52.2
33.4
2.6
78.4
53.7
-27.4
26.4
58.2
31
1.18
1.82
48.7
0.58
0.88
63.1
35.4
8.5
63.6
25.5
23.9
41.3
54.2
32
0.80
1.27
64.7
0.44
0.66
71.9
26.3
18.0
45.8
28.9
37.5
37.3
54.9
33
0.59
0.89
74.8
0.54
0.83
65.3
37.8
1.1
79.7
35.1
-1.1
82.3
75.5
34
0.56
1.02
73.4
0.46
0.74
69.8
33.6
36.7
34.2
27.5
25.9
37.9
53.8
35
0.65
0.94
72.7
0.56
0.99
61.3
29.0
16.3
48.6
23.6
2.9
83.8
66.6
36
0.44
0.72
80.2
0.52
0.96
63.2
25.7
-5.4
75.4
18.6
-0.2
91.4
77.5
37
0.98
1.52
57.3
0.85
1.46
42.2
31.0
9.3
64.0
41.2
45.6
31.9
48.8
38
0.55
0.95
74.7
0.42
0.71
71.7
24.7
10.4
64.3
27.2
12.5
63.2
68.5
39
0.89
1.33
61.9
1.27
2.39
9.6
33.3
9.1
63.4
46.7
1.0
77.6
53.1
40
0.45
0.72
80.0
0.51
0.81
66.9
25.2
9.8
65.5
38.1
46.5
33.2
61.4
41
0.78
1.14
66.9
0.59
0.90
62.5
23.3
-17.5
48.4
24.3
8.9
71.6
62.4
42
0.69
0.94
71.7
0.53
0.84
65.5
41.7
19.4
35.6
28.5
23.3
41.2
53.5
43
0.55
0.82
76.4
0.63
0.96
59.6
30.5
13.7
53.9
29.1
-12.0
63.3
63.3
44
0.73
1.10
68.8
0.64
1.02
58.3
42.6
-1.9
75.5
44.6
-25.5
30.4
58.2
45
0.46
0.67
80.6
0.34
0.54
78.0
27.2
13.7
55.6
38.4
35.5
33.1
61.8
46
0.54
0.84
76.5
0.43
0.72
71.2
33.5
6.8
68.4
26.1
0.7
87.1
75.8
47
1.32
1.63
48.5
0.67
0.94
59.0
67.4
0.9
66.3
27.0
4.3
79.5
63.3
48
0.43
0.69
81.0
0.52
0.98
62.8
23.7
-1.0
86.5
19.3
9.8
72.1
75.6
49
0.79
1.14
66.9
0.38
0.59
75.3
30.3
24.6
35.7
27.2
29.5
38.0
54.0
50
0.68
1.11
69.5
0.36
0.57
76.5
25.3
-0.9
86.1
31.5
13.5
59.3
72.8
Avg
0.70
1.09
69.4
0.53
0.87
64.8
30.0
4.4
63.2
29.6
11.9
59.9
64.3
Detailed Results for Rank 7¶
Team: Biomediq
Affiliation: Biomediq, Denmark
Submitted on: 2015-23-03
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.70
1.47
63.9
0.43
0.80
69.5
16.9
-0.3
91.4
18.4
-12.9
66.4
72.8
2
0.62
1.00
72.4
0.71
1.20
52.1
30.8
-25.8
35.5
20.8
-6.4
78.2
59.5
3
0.58
1.06
72.5
0.50
1.12
60.6
20.9
5.7
76.9
27.8
1.6
84.5
73.6
4
0.72
1.22
67.2
0.62
0.93
60.8
33.5
-21.0
35.7
32.5
-25.4
35.7
49.8
5
0.59
1.07
72.1
0.39
0.70
72.9
18.5
-7.9
73.0
25.8
-13.6
61.6
69.9
6
0.68
1.26
67.5
0.50
0.95
64.2
21.0
0.4
89.3
22.1
-8.8
72.7
73.4
7
0.83
1.43
61.7
0.56
0.92
62.9
20.7
-9.6
68.1
19.7
10.4
70.7
65.9
8
0.71
1.22
67.3
0.37
0.66
74.4
25.4
-16.4
50.2
22.4
-16.1
58.2
62.5
9
0.59
1.00
73.1
0.51
1.15
59.7
28.7
-21.0
37.9
32.5
-25.3
35.7
51.6
10
0.69
1.14
69.0
0.53
1.01
61.8
25.5
-17.6
47.3
25.5
-9.0
70.9
62.2
11
0.86
1.61
58.5
0.56
1.09
59.3
16.5
-1.5
88.9
22.3
-9.5
71.3
69.5
12
0.62
1.15
70.4
0.34
0.62
76.0
27.2
-9.8
64.5
28.8
-7.2
73.0
71.0
13
0.90
1.91
53.5
0.60
0.95
60.9
31.6
25.4
35.1
29.9
2.9
81.0
57.6
14
0.59
1.04
72.5
0.46
0.80
68.6
22.3
9.6
67.2
16.5
4.1
84.5
73.2
15
0.49
0.97
75.8
0.63
1.20
54.9
23.8
-4.0
79.6
19.7
-4.8
81.7
73.0
16
1.05
2.34
44.0
0.32
0.54
78.7
29.9
-5.7
72.8
28.3
3.8
79.9
68.9
17
1.28
2.04
43.5
0.77
1.29
48.5
31.8
0.8
83.2
30.7
-8.8
69.0
61.0
18
0.41
0.78
80.2
0.40
0.66
73.4
19.4
-1.6
87.3
18.6
10.9
70.2
77.7
19
0.60
1.24
69.4
0.36
0.67
74.5
16.8
3.9
83.0
23.3
-12.3
65.4
73.1
20
0.61
1.01
72.5
0.56
1.05
60.2
21.6
-4.8
78.8
22.2
-19.8
51.0
65.6
21
0.73
1.58
61.9
0.47
0.94
65.3
26.1
-15.7
51.4
26.4
-13.2
62.1
60.2
22
1.48
2.82
28.1
0.45
0.82
68.5
22.5
-10.4
65.3
16.6
-12.9
67.1
57.3
23
1.04
2.20
46.3
0.59
0.94
61.5
26.2
1.5
84.1
40.2
23.1
36.4
57.1
24
1.08
2.03
47.8
0.37
0.64
74.7
19.3
0.7
89.3
21.8
3.4
83.6
73.8
25
0.63
1.14
70.2
0.57
1.03
60.4
24.7
9.6
66.2
36.2
14.4
55.6
63.1
26
0.80
1.43
62.4
0.59
1.35
53.0
17.6
-9.9
68.8
24.7
-14.7
59.9
61.0
27
0.61
1.06
71.8
0.74
1.28
49.4
33.6
-14.4
50.8
20.7
-6.6
77.9
62.5
28
0.97
1.86
52.7
0.53
0.92
64.0
30.3
13.2
55.1
36.3
-29.9
34.0
51.5
29
0.53
0.86
76.3
0.55
0.90
63.8
31.0
-18.5
42.5
29.5
-3.8
79.5
65.5
30
0.45
0.85
78.1
0.50
1.01
63.1
26.5
-11.3
61.3
35.9
-6.6
71.1
68.4
31
1.20
1.90
47.2
1.07
2.27
18.5
28.7
1.9
82.1
29.8
9.4
68.2
54.0
32
0.66
1.08
70.3
0.40
0.61
74.3
24.6
11.5
61.9
23.1
9.5
70.9
69.4
33
0.60
1.36
67.7
0.35
0.69
74.3
27.0
-11.9
59.8
29.1
-24.7
38.1
60.0
34
0.61
1.27
68.7
0.43
0.73
71.1
30.7
31.8
35.6
22.8
-6.8
76.5
63.0
35
0.55
0.98
74.2
0.69
1.40
48.7
24.7
-6.6
73.0
28.5
-25.6
37.5
58.4
36
0.55
1.13
72.0
0.36
0.66
74.5
17.2
-11.4
65.6
14.6
-1.3
90.9
75.8
37
1.82
3.54
10.7
1.33
2.82
7.3
26.5
16.9
48.4
31.4
31.5
36.2
25.7
38
0.45
0.75
79.6
0.33
0.60
77.0
14.9
2.1
88.1
19.7
1.5
88.3
83.2
39
1.18
2.43
40.0
1.58
3.20
0.0
27.3
4.3
77.3
27.1
12.7
62.8
45.0
40
0.58
1.19
70.5
0.41
0.71
71.9
21.1
-4.8
78.9
29.4
18.4
50.5
67.9
41
1.11
1.91
49.0
0.50
0.85
66.3
24.7
-23.0
38.4
20.4
-8.6
74.0
56.9
42
0.68
1.09
69.9
0.53
0.86
65.1
29.7
13.8
54.1
29.0
-0.5
86.3
68.8
43
0.81
1.59
59.9
0.64
1.42
49.7
25.8
1.5
84.3
20.5
-15.2
60.7
63.6
44
0.85
1.64
58.5
0.54
0.91
63.6
39.5
-10.9
56.3
27.4
-16.6
55.1
58.4
45
0.58
1.37
68.1
0.32
0.63
76.6
27.2
14.8
53.1
22.0
1.5
87.4
71.3
46
0.68
1.36
66.1
0.34
0.62
76.1
30.0
1.7
81.9
33.4
-1.8
81.7
76.5
47
1.31
1.70
47.7
0.77
1.01
54.2
67.9
-5.1
56.3
30.1
-8.6
69.7
57.0
48
0.65
1.34
66.9
0.58
1.06
59.1
17.9
-3.0
84.5
17.3
-9.0
74.5
71.3
49
0.59
1.00
73.2
0.41
0.71
72.1
25.2
16.7
49.4
20.7
12.9
65.4
65.0
50
0.52
0.94
75.4
0.39
0.70
72.9
21.6
-12.0
62.0
33.2
5.8
73.9
71.1
Avg
0.77
1.43
63.2
0.55
1.01
61.8
25.9
-2.6
65.4
25.7
-4.2
66.7
64.3
Detailed Results for Rank 8¶
Team: UPMC_IBML
Affiliation: UPMC, United States
Submitted on: 2013-05-17
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.46
0.76
79.2
0.45
0.74
70.1
23.6
-1.6
85.3
28.1
-11.6
64.6
74.8
2
0.81
1.18
65.7
0.81
1.43
44.1
36.8
-34.6
32.7
29.5
-23.9
39.6
45.5
3
0.61
0.92
73.7
0.53
1.02
62.0
29.4
-7.3
69.4
37.5
7.6
68.5
68.4
4
0.60
0.92
74.0
0.46
0.71
70.5
27.5
-14.6
53.2
15.8
-2.6
87.9
71.4
5
0.67
1.08
70.3
0.54
0.89
64.2
30.3
-16.3
48.1
36.8
-23.5
37.1
54.9
6
0.67
1.09
70.0
0.59
0.94
61.6
27.9
-2.5
81.1
25.7
-6.4
76.0
72.2
7
0.68
1.00
71.1
0.66
1.01
57.9
28.0
-19.9
40.8
27.3
6.6
74.9
61.2
8
0.81
1.17
66.1
0.46
0.73
69.9
33.3
-29.7
34.4
26.6
-13.2
62.1
58.1
9
0.63
0.96
72.9
0.49
0.80
67.8
31.1
-24.0
35.4
33.9
-1.0
83.2
64.8
10
0.74
1.16
67.7
0.48
0.85
67.1
29.2
-22.3
36.3
18.6
-8.9
74.2
61.3
11
0.67
1.09
70.1
0.52
0.93
63.9
21.6
-4.1
80.4
28.3
-7.2
73.2
71.9
12
0.43
0.72
80.4
0.41
0.65
73.3
24.9
-2.9
81.5
51.0
-22.2
33.5
67.2
13
0.68
1.10
69.6
0.60
1.04
59.1
37.6
13.0
52.3
32.4
2.2
81.3
65.6
14
0.63
1.03
71.8
0.53
0.81
66.2
27.5
10.1
63.8
21.7
3.4
83.6
71.4
15
0.40
0.62
82.5
0.47
0.76
69.1
25.6
5.4
75.4
36.1
-6.3
71.7
74.7
16
0.37
0.59
83.6
0.39
0.64
74.1
25.1
-2.6
82.2
33.6
5.4
74.5
78.6
17
0.86
1.25
63.7
0.57
0.88
63.6
32.1
-9.8
62.3
41.0
-28.6
32.0
55.4
18
0.50
0.77
78.2
0.46
0.70
70.8
29.3
-18.8
42.8
29.7
-7.3
72.4
66.1
19
0.70
1.52
63.3
0.48
0.84
67.3
25.3
0.8
86.2
34.6
-17.5
50.0
66.7
20
0.72
1.11
68.8
0.43
0.72
71.3
22.1
0.8
87.8
31.7
-11.1
64.1
73.0
21
0.39
0.61
83.0
0.38
0.62
75.0
28.8
-16.2
49.1
38.2
-30.7
33.2
60.1
22
0.80
1.46
62.0
0.48
0.81
67.8
23.0
-4.8
78.1
27.0
-11.6
65.1
68.3
23
0.65
1.03
71.4
0.63
1.01
58.7
31.0
-10.5
61.2
45.9
24.0
32.1
55.9
24
0.72
1.53
62.8
0.58
0.91
62.4
24.5
3.0
81.5
33.9
-8.6
68.0
68.7
25
0.59
0.91
74.3
0.59
0.95
61.2
26.9
-4.1
77.9
42.6
15.8
49.9
65.8
26
1.08
2.04
47.7
0.39
0.60
75.1
29.1
-21.9
36.3
28.8
-22.2
43.3
50.6
27
0.54
0.84
76.4
0.57
0.91
62.6
32.3
-14.8
50.5
23.2
-20.8
48.4
59.5
28
0.83
1.80
56.5
0.48
0.74
69.3
26.0
1.8
83.7
27.2
-23.2
42.1
62.9
29
0.70
1.09
69.4
0.75
1.42
46.4
42.1
-39.8
30.2
51.9
-22.1
33.2
44.8
30
0.61
1.03
72.2
0.42
0.67
72.3
34.5
-23.2
33.8
53.0
-22.6
31.8
52.5
31
1.10
1.67
52.5
0.68
1.01
57.3
40.7
-33.0
30.9
33.3
16.2
53.2
48.5
32
0.64
0.99
72.1
0.43
0.62
73.5
26.2
9.4
65.9
32.5
-5.3
75.2
71.7
33
0.49
0.80
78.0
0.46
0.76
69.4
26.9
-8.0
68.8
38.2
-19.3
44.9
65.3
34
0.69
1.34
66.1
0.46
0.72
70.4
33.3
34.6
34.4
30.7
2.5
81.5
63.1
35
0.63
0.98
72.5
0.57
0.98
61.3
30.7
-12.8
56.0
27.5
-16.5
55.1
61.2
36
0.40
0.64
82.3
0.49
0.83
67.1
24.5
-16.0
51.5
32.4
-12.8
60.4
65.3
37
0.87
1.42
61.2
1.34
2.83
7.1
31.9
-2.6
78.9
44.7
15.1
50.3
49.4
38
0.50
0.84
77.2
0.38
0.65
74.2
18.1
-5.3
79.3
26.3
-5.2
78.1
77.2
39
0.66
1.02
71.2
1.86
3.15
0.0
33.5
-15.5
48.5
31.4
22.4
41.8
40.4
40
0.49
0.78
78.4
0.52
0.80
66.6
26.9
-12.1
59.5
44.5
8.0
64.6
67.3
41
0.80
1.19
65.9
0.60
0.92
61.5
34.4
-31.3
33.9
20.5
-1.7
87.6
62.2
42
0.73
1.09
68.7
0.53
0.84
65.5
46.4
-20.4
30.9
37.8
-7.5
68.5
58.4
43
0.78
1.21
66.0
0.55
0.86
64.3
30.9
-4.3
75.5
26.0
-9.4
69.9
68.9
44
0.67
1.05
70.7
0.56
0.88
63.5
37.3
-4.3
72.6
31.5
-24.5
37.4
61.1
45
0.41
0.69
81.5
0.41
0.64
73.5
30.5
0.8
83.7
49.7
5.5
67.1
76.5
46
0.60
1.02
72.6
0.36
0.56
76.7
29.5
-9.1
65.1
32.6
1.6
82.6
74.2
47
1.18
1.52
52.9
0.70
0.96
57.7
69.4
-10.7
42.6
34.5
-13.1
58.9
53.0
48
0.40
0.61
82.6
0.61
1.04
58.9
26.9
-11.7
60.3
27.7
-8.4
71.2
68.2
49
0.63
0.99
72.3
0.41
0.63
73.8
26.3
9.2
66.4
29.1
3.9
79.4
73.0
50
0.59
0.95
73.9
0.48
0.89
66.1
34.5
-25.3
33.8
34.2
0.4
84.2
64.5
Avg
0.66
1.06
70.7
0.56
0.93
63.5
30.5
-9.6
59.0
33.1
-6.7
61.3
63.6
Detailed Results for Rank 9
Team: shan_unc
Affiliation: UNC Chapel Hill, United States
Submitted on: 2013-08-13
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.69
1.06
70.2
0.56
0.80
65.5
17.1
1.0
89.7
19.7
-4.3
82.9
77.0
2
0.68
0.99
71.4
0.73
1.07
54.4
27.7
-24.9
37.0
28.8
-26.1
37.3
50.0
3
0.64
1.01
71.8
0.69
0.96
58.1
21.5
20.0
43.5
28.6
35.7
37.4
52.7
4
0.47
0.75
79.3
0.49
0.71
69.6
25.8
-0.3
87.1
26.8
-8.4
71.6
76.9
5
0.95
1.50
58.1
0.52
0.79
66.8
22.3
0.2
89.0
17.4
1.9
88.6
75.7
6
0.66
1.04
71.0
0.51
0.93
64.2
21.2
16.7
51.4
19.4
14.0
63.8
62.6
7
0.71
1.09
69.2
0.73
1.26
50.3
24.1
-16.0
51.6
18.8
11.7
68.6
59.9
8
0.73
1.15
68.0
0.51
0.85
65.9
23.8
-16.4
50.8
20.6
-6.2
78.6
65.8
9
0.59
0.92
74.3
0.63
0.97
59.4
25.5
-13.9
55.8
26.2
18.0
52.7
60.6
10
0.67
1.11
69.8
0.44
0.74
70.6
27.7
-22.6
37.0
20.6
-15.6
60.1
59.4
11
0.93
1.52
58.4
0.53
0.89
64.3
16.3
7.6
74.7
25.4
10.0
69.0
66.6
12
0.47
0.88
77.4
0.46
0.67
71.4
21.2
-0.3
89.3
26.4
29.4
38.4
69.1
13
0.85
1.32
63.0
0.94
1.54
37.8
32.9
37.8
34.5
34.1
35.5
35.0
42.6
14
0.67
1.05
70.6
0.47
0.66
71.2
24.6
12.9
58.5
18.4
6.6
78.8
69.8
15
0.58
0.88
74.8
0.49
0.75
68.7
22.1
15.1
54.7
21.4
24.1
42.7
60.2
16
0.78
1.36
63.8
0.38
0.55
76.4
22.7
-6.0
75.6
21.8
7.4
75.7
72.9
17
0.99
1.46
57.9
0.64
0.99
59.0
27.9
2.5
81.1
23.9
7.2
75.2
68.3
18
0.60
0.93
73.8
0.48
0.74
69.2
18.7
9.5
69.3
24.4
27.8
39.3
62.9
19
0.64
1.12
70.4
0.55
0.84
64.9
22.7
20.3
42.4
19.5
6.1
79.3
64.3
20
0.72
1.07
69.3
0.60
0.96
60.8
18.6
5.4
78.8
25.6
-9.4
70.0
69.7
21
0.55
0.89
75.4
0.47
0.70
70.4
21.5
-5.3
77.6
14.1
4.4
85.1
77.1
22
1.61
3.05
22.0
0.48
0.71
69.9
24.7
-6.4
73.6
15.9
-6.6
79.8
61.3
23
1.03
1.61
55.0
0.84
1.30
46.0
21.7
9.7
67.3
43.4
70.0
30.9
49.8
24
1.21
2.18
43.0
0.57
0.83
64.5
21.6
16.4
51.8
19.3
20.4
51.0
52.6
25
0.71
1.14
68.5
0.73
1.23
51.0
22.8
9.2
67.9
28.7
33.9
37.4
56.2
26
0.83
1.25
64.5
0.63
1.10
56.8
24.5
-19.1
44.2
21.9
3.6
83.1
62.2
27
0.66
1.05
70.9
0.69
1.05
56.0
33.7
-7.1
67.7
27.9
-18.5
51.0
61.4
28
0.94
1.85
53.4
0.55
0.81
65.4
28.2
14.4
53.5
29.5
-21.8
43.7
54.0
29
0.58
0.89
74.8
0.72
1.00
56.2
27.6
-17.4
46.9
26.4
11.8
65.0
60.7
30
0.55
0.89
75.5
0.69
1.24
52.0
23.2
-2.8
82.6
29.5
20.2
47.0
64.3
31
1.36
2.20
39.4
0.61
1.01
59.4
24.8
7.5
70.9
34.5
35.1
34.8
51.1
32
0.64
1.10
70.4
0.47
0.68
70.6
25.6
25.5
38.0
26.0
27.7
38.5
54.4
33
0.51
0.77
78.0
0.58
0.83
64.1
22.3
3.3
81.9
23.2
18.4
53.3
69.3
34
0.56
1.11
72.2
0.48
0.73
69.6
30.5
34.6
35.7
24.4
31.4
39.3
54.2
35
0.60
0.92
74.0
0.76
1.28
49.1
21.0
1.7
86.2
20.8
-3.3
84.3
73.4
36
0.50
0.76
78.4
0.54
0.80
66.1
12.1
1.4
91.1
12.6
5.8
82.9
79.6
37
1.11
1.73
51.5
1.01
1.73
31.5
25.6
18.1
46.1
42.0
59.8
31.5
40.2
38
0.49
0.77
78.6
0.38
0.62
74.9
14.6
3.6
84.9
18.5
12.4
67.3
76.4
39
0.95
1.56
57.3
1.09
1.80
27.4
33.5
-14.0
51.8
31.6
17.8
50.7
46.8
40
0.79
1.16
66.6
0.61
0.81
63.6
20.4
8.9
69.9
39.4
61.5
32.7
58.2
41
1.32
2.17
40.7
0.62
0.94
60.7
29.5
-28.2
36.1
13.7
-1.1
91.8
57.3
42
0.77
1.15
67.2
0.57
0.85
64.0
25.3
13.2
57.5
27.8
30.3
37.8
56.6
43
0.80
1.23
65.3
0.61
0.89
62.0
24.7
11.2
62.5
11.9
-0.5
93.9
70.9
44
0.75
1.13
67.7
0.60
0.93
61.5
28.8
-2.3
81.2
16.8
-6.8
79.2
72.4
45
0.52
0.83
77.0
0.49
0.70
69.9
26.5
19.0
43.7
32.7
44.2
35.6
56.5
46
0.63
0.91
73.5
0.47
0.71
70.2
27.3
-3.1
80.0
18.7
4.4
83.1
76.7
47
1.25
1.63
49.9
0.82
1.08
51.2
65.9
-3.9
60.0
30.4
-1.4
83.8
61.2
48
0.49
0.75
78.9
0.51
0.82
66.5
21.0
9.7
67.6
18.1
4.4
83.2
74.1
49
0.74
1.11
68.4
0.39
0.57
75.7
24.8
22.2
38.4
28.4
32.2
37.5
55.0
50
0.59
0.89
74.7
0.43
0.66
72.3
18.8
-9.0
70.4
25.8
20.6
47.8
66.3
Avg
0.76
1.22
66.3
0.59
0.92
61.7
24.7
3.2
62.8
24.4
13.5
60.2
62.7
Detailed Results for Rank 10¶
Team: AMC_MIRL
Affiliation: Biomedical Engineering Center / Asan Medical Center, Korea
Republic of
Submitted on: 2016-07-26. See paper
here.
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.45
0.72
79.9
0.43
0.69
71.7
24.9
-10.4
64.3
31.4
-25.1
36.4
63.1
2
0.71
1.04
69.9
1.49
3.48
2.3
33.6
-30.0
34.2
22.8
-12.8
64.5
42.7
3
0.59
0.89
74.6
0.52
0.99
62.8
29.0
-0.5
85.2
38.3
-0.3
82.5
76.3
4
0.59
0.88
74.9
0.43
0.66
72.4
30.2
-11.1
60.2
16.4
-0.2
92.3
74.9
5
0.80
1.57
60.5
0.55
1.08
59.9
29.7
-16.5
47.9
31.8
-22.7
41.0
52.3
6
0.87
1.63
58.0
0.55
0.87
64.1
29.2
4.0
77.0
29.3
-13.0
61.3
65.1
7
0.72
1.08
69.1
0.59
0.87
62.9
26.5
-6.0
73.7
20.4
2.8
85.6
72.8
8
0.92
1.64
56.9
0.39
0.60
75.1
32.7
-27.1
34.6
22.2
-6.0
78.4
61.2
9
0.62
0.94
73.3
0.46
0.75
69.6
26.7
-12.5
58.5
31.6
-4.2
77.8
69.8
10
0.67
1.05
70.7
0.61
1.56
47.7
27.9
-20.4
39.6
25.1
-18.9
51.5
52.4
11
0.68
1.10
69.8
0.52
0.91
64.5
24.3
-7.7
70.7
35.3
-25.8
34.5
59.9
12
0.46
0.76
79.4
0.41
0.65
73.2
29.1
-13.7
54.6
48.0
8.3
62.5
67.4
13
0.65
1.07
70.7
0.83
1.61
39.7
35.8
13.1
52.9
38.8
-5.1
72.8
59.0
14
0.54
0.86
76.1
0.49
0.74
68.7
27.8
9.6
64.7
17.3
-1.5
89.4
74.7
15
0.44
0.68
80.8
0.85
1.63
38.8
29.3
-4.1
76.9
49.4
-42.4
28.2
56.2
16
0.39
0.59
83.2
0.35
0.54
77.4
26.0
-3.2
80.3
27.7
7.0
73.8
78.7
17
0.81
1.19
65.8
0.54
0.83
65.3
32.2
-5.4
72.4
41.3
-27.3
31.8
58.8
18
0.51
0.77
78.1
0.47
0.72
70.0
28.0
-13.6
55.3
26.9
-9.1
70.1
68.4
19
0.58
1.13
71.4
0.45
0.76
69.9
28.0
-2.3
81.4
36.6
-21.4
41.4
66.0
20
0.73
1.09
68.8
0.43
0.73
70.9
27.0
0.4
86.3
33.3
-12.9
59.7
71.4
21
0.41
0.63
82.0
0.40
0.67
73.1
32.8
-22.2
34.6
35.9
-28.8
34.2
56.0
22
0.52
0.80
77.6
0.42
0.67
72.6
23.3
2.2
84.0
31.7
-24.8
36.8
67.8
23
0.71
1.30
66.3
0.59
0.93
61.6
32.1
-15.5
49.1
45.1
20.4
39.7
54.2
24
0.53
0.86
76.3
0.52
0.80
66.6
26.4
-6.1
73.5
47.6
-38.1
29.0
61.4
25
0.65
0.96
72.4
0.55
0.86
64.4
32.8
-14.7
50.6
45.4
17.3
45.6
58.3
26
1.29
2.74
33.3
0.38
0.59
75.6
24.6
-13.6
57.0
32.7
-28.0
35.6
50.4
27
0.51
0.79
77.9
0.55
0.90
63.8
32.9
-13.5
53.3
19.5
-2.5
86.4
70.4
28
0.91
1.94
52.7
0.45
0.69
71.3
32.9
19.3
39.9
22.2
-15.6
59.2
55.8
29
0.67
1.06
70.6
0.90
1.92
31.2
33.9
-26.8
34.1
40.3
-4.2
74.0
52.4
30
0.89
1.74
56.1
0.39
0.61
74.8
35.2
-17.3
43.5
55.9
-38.9
25.4
49.9
31
0.96
1.59
56.6
2.41
4.42
0.0
27.5
-13.8
55.2
33.7
11.8
61.8
43.4
32
0.67
0.99
71.6
0.41
0.59
74.4
28.9
7.1
69.9
37.7
-8.4
66.7
70.7
33
0.54
0.88
75.8
0.45
0.72
70.6
30.3
-16.3
48.0
46.1
-17.1
45.9
60.1
34
0.94
1.88
53.1
0.44
0.68
71.8
37.0
23.5
32.6
32.4
-4.5
76.8
58.6
35
0.63
0.95
72.9
0.53
0.89
64.7
33.8
-1.0
81.8
32.8
-12.5
60.7
70.1
36
0.43
0.67
81.3
0.48
0.81
67.6
24.6
-12.6
59.2
28.3
-12.1
63.6
68.0
37
0.85
1.43
61.3
0.82
1.43
44.1
34.5
15.8
47.1
41.8
16.7
48.5
50.2
38
0.57
1.19
70.8
0.37
0.61
75.4
18.9
-5.0
79.5
28.6
-7.8
71.9
74.4
39
0.74
1.35
64.8
1.97
4.00
0.0
31.8
-19.7
39.5
40.6
-0.5
81.2
46.4
40
0.47
0.72
79.7
0.52
0.79
66.6
27.3
-9.3
65.6
47.9
-9.5
60.1
68.0
41
0.92
1.57
57.9
0.55
0.84
64.8
31.0
-26.2
35.4
19.4
-2.7
86.0
61.0
42
0.82
1.27
64.4
0.52
0.84
65.9
47.3
-32.1
27.8
32.9
10.0
65.7
56.0
43
0.75
1.28
65.6
0.50
0.78
67.8
27.4
5.1
75.3
28.4
-23.3
41.3
62.5
44
0.69
1.04
70.5
0.56
0.89
63.5
41.3
-10.0
57.4
41.6
-33.6
31.7
55.7
45
0.44
0.73
80.1
0.42
0.64
73.2
37.4
-1.9
78.1
60.0
-30.5
23.6
63.7
46
0.50
0.80
77.8
0.38
0.59
75.6
28.9
-3.8
77.6
30.8
7.9
70.9
75.5
47
1.13
1.46
54.9
0.67
0.92
59.4
69.5
-14.9
32.9
32.5
-11.1
63.6
52.7
48
0.62
1.41
66.7
0.59
0.98
60.7
27.5
-11.1
61.3
28.7
-16.6
54.4
60.8
49
0.65
0.98
72.1
0.41
0.64
73.4
27.2
-4.4
77.1
36.1
-24.5
35.5
64.5
50
0.59
0.94
74.0
0.46
0.86
67.3
29.1
-12.9
56.4
38.5
2.3
78.5
69.0
Avg
0.67
1.13
69.4
0.60
1.04
61.8
30.9
-8.2
59.0
34.4
-10.8
57.8
62.0
Detailed Results for Rank 11¶
Team: UIiibiKnee
Affiliation: University of Iowa, United States
Submitted on: 2010-10-19
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.54
0.81
76.9
0.56
0.95
62.3
21.8
2.1
84.9
26.6
-12.0
64.4
72.1
2
0.68
0.97
71.5
0.78
1.25
49.0
37.9
-36.7
32.2
20.2
-14.0
63.4
54.0
3
0.65
1.07
70.7
0.55
0.87
64.3
25.0
12.3
59.8
37.6
14.7
54.2
62.2
4
0.67
1.34
66.5
0.56
0.96
62.2
24.4
-5.6
75.6
24.2
-21.7
46.2
62.6
5
0.66
1.03
71.2
0.59
0.95
61.4
23.7
-3.1
81.8
33.5
-5.1
75.1
72.4
6
0.63
1.09
71.0
0.69
1.22
52.4
25.9
4.7
77.0
17.9
2.2
87.8
72.0
7
0.60
0.96
73.5
0.79
1.32
47.1
25.7
-15.7
51.6
24.8
16.2
57.0
57.3
8
0.67
1.01
71.4
0.80
1.28
47.8
29.5
-25.5
36.1
34.8
-23.8
37.5
48.2
9
0.68
1.04
70.7
0.81
1.42
44.6
30.8
-24.4
35.5
35.5
-4.3
75.9
56.7
10
0.78
1.20
66.2
0.65
1.06
57.1
35.4
-31.7
33.4
22.0
-17.5
55.5
53.1
11
0.62
1.01
72.2
0.74
1.17
51.7
20.2
6.8
74.8
32.7
-2.3
81.0
69.9
12
0.77
1.44
62.9
0.56
0.91
63.3
24.1
-3.1
81.4
37.7
16.1
51.5
64.8
13
0.76
1.19
66.8
0.98
1.61
35.0
34.7
20.4
36.5
28.8
23.6
40.5
44.7
14
0.53
0.82
76.9
0.58
1.12
58.0
26.6
3.2
80.1
17.9
15.1
62.1
69.3
15
0.46
0.66
80.7
0.60
0.93
61.5
24.1
18.5
45.8
26.3
0.8
86.8
68.7
16
0.50
0.79
78.0
0.48
0.73
69.2
32.0
-4.2
75.2
41.5
11.7
58.5
70.2
17
0.97
1.66
55.4
0.72
1.09
54.2
30.4
18.6
42.6
22.9
6.0
78.0
57.6
18
0.43
0.65
81.5
0.41
0.57
74.9
22.4
6.9
73.6
21.2
18.1
54.8
71.2
19
0.48
0.72
79.6
0.56
1.00
61.3
22.5
10.8
64.5
28.4
-3.8
80.0
71.3
20
0.65
0.98
72.1
0.58
0.89
62.9
26.4
-5.3
75.4
24.7
-2.4
84.3
73.7
21
0.53
0.75
77.9
0.61
1.01
59.4
28.9
-15.8
49.9
30.0
-14.3
58.4
61.4
22
0.67
1.21
68.4
0.49
0.77
68.2
22.4
-0.9
87.3
24.2
-6.7
76.0
75.0
23
0.66
0.96
72.1
0.96
1.40
40.1
23.4
2.4
83.5
42.7
42.3
31.2
56.7
24
0.51
0.79
77.7
0.45
0.68
71.5
23.2
16.9
50.0
28.4
1.8
83.9
70.7
25
0.68
1.10
69.8
0.82
1.35
45.6
21.1
-0.7
88.4
40.2
28.6
32.3
59.0
26
0.86
1.30
63.0
0.58
0.94
61.9
20.0
-6.2
76.2
26.4
-10.1
68.4
67.4
27
0.70
1.00
70.7
0.67
1.07
56.1
40.5
-19.3
36.3
18.4
-12.0
68.0
57.8
28
1.31
2.78
32.2
0.72
1.31
49.5
33.8
-9.5
62.0
26.1
-21.5
45.8
47.4
29
0.67
0.99
71.5
0.82
1.28
47.1
36.0
-29.4
33.1
41.2
9.2
63.6
53.8
30
0.71
1.07
69.5
0.66
1.17
54.4
29.1
1.0
83.9
49.0
-5.0
68.4
69.1
31
1.03
1.56
55.6
0.76
1.08
53.2
35.8
-12.0
55.4
30.6
13.3
60.0
56.1
32
0.61
1.21
69.7
0.61
0.87
62.4
26.2
21.7
37.7
24.0
16.1
57.5
56.8
33
1.08
2.16
46.1
0.43
0.69
71.8
32.9
-9.4
62.8
33.4
-10.4
64.7
61.3
34
0.71
1.31
66.0
0.65
1.08
56.7
34.4
33.1
33.8
25.9
3.9
80.9
59.3
35
0.60
0.87
74.7
0.82
1.34
45.9
39.6
-22.9
31.4
29.9
-19.4
48.3
50.1
36
0.50
0.74
78.7
0.49
0.80
67.6
18.8
-7.4
74.1
18.1
-3.4
85.4
76.4
37
1.00
1.67
54.6
1.07
1.73
29.6
26.6
10.0
64.4
37.3
38.8
33.6
45.5
38
0.73
1.15
67.9
0.51
0.79
67.3
16.9
4.9
80.7
21.0
8.7
73.5
72.3
39
0.93
1.50
58.7
1.53
2.62
1.0
33.6
-5.1
72.4
28.6
7.0
73.5
51.4
40
0.64
1.05
71.3
0.54
0.79
66.4
24.2
6.4
73.8
48.6
48.6
28.6
60.0
41
0.82
1.17
65.6
0.67
1.05
56.8
32.3
-30.1
34.8
22.8
-1.6
86.9
61.0
42
1.00
1.62
55.5
0.69
1.06
55.7
40.3
-23.2
31.1
27.4
13.2
61.8
51.0
43
0.62
0.94
73.4
0.49
0.73
69.1
26.5
2.1
82.6
17.1
-9.6
73.4
74.6
44
0.68
1.02
71.0
0.92
1.73
34.6
41.1
-9.8
58.0
30.3
-17.2
52.6
54.0
45
0.51
0.74
78.5
0.48
0.80
67.9
30.4
17.7
44.7
35.2
21.9
41.1
58.0
46
0.68
1.07
70.3
0.53
0.81
66.1
36.6
2.6
76.8
37.1
6.2
71.4
71.1
47
1.41
1.87
43.0
0.76
1.02
54.4
69.8
-20.1
20.7
30.0
-12.9
61.2
44.8
48
0.61
1.01
72.6
0.62
0.93
60.9
22.2
2.5
83.7
21.6
-2.1
86.2
75.9
49
0.97
1.57
56.9
0.47
0.67
70.8
34.1
31.0
34.0
27.8
16.5
55.0
54.2
50
1.05
2.00
48.9
0.45
0.63
72.5
28.1
-8.8
66.4
40.4
4.7
72.8
65.2
Avg
0.72
1.17
67.7
0.66
1.07
56.5
29.5
-2.6
59.7
29.5
3.0
63.2
61.8
Detailed Results for Rank 12¶
Team: shan_unc
Affiliation: UNC Chapel Hill, United States
Submitted on: 2012-08-03
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.72
1.10
68.8
0.57
0.83
64.5
18.5
-7.0
75.0
29.4
-20.1
47.2
63.9
2
0.75
1.07
68.7
0.88
1.58
38.8
37.0
-34.0
32.6
43.6
-42.0
30.8
42.7
3
0.75
1.27
65.8
0.75
1.27
49.4
24.4
19.1
44.4
31.3
16.5
53.4
53.3
4
0.63
0.97
72.7
0.50
0.73
68.7
31.1
-16.3
47.7
42.5
-42.2
31.3
55.1
5
0.88
1.32
62.3
0.52
0.81
66.4
23.9
0.2
88.4
32.8
-17.3
51.2
67.1
6
0.75
1.17
67.3
0.52
0.90
64.6
25.7
0.5
86.7
17.0
0.6
91.3
77.5
7
0.68
1.02
70.8
0.77
1.30
48.5
27.9
-20.8
38.7
25.4
-3.6
81.6
59.9
8
0.75
1.12
68.0
0.55
0.98
61.9
31.4
-26.9
35.2
34.4
-25.1
35.0
50.0
9
0.69
1.05
70.1
0.62
0.96
60.2
39.8
-30.6
31.3
37.3
-6.0
71.7
58.3
10
0.77
1.23
65.9
0.48
0.82
67.6
37.1
-33.5
32.6
34.1
-31.2
35.0
50.3
11
0.92
1.46
59.3
0.58
1.00
60.4
19.4
-1.6
87.3
28.4
2.3
83.0
72.5
12
0.52
0.97
75.0
0.44
0.66
72.0
22.5
-3.6
81.1
36.0
7.0
70.3
74.6
13
0.96
1.44
58.7
0.95
1.60
36.2
32.3
24.1
34.8
32.1
20.8
44.5
43.6
14
0.76
1.26
65.8
0.50
0.72
69.1
24.9
-0.8
86.4
22.1
-14.1
62.3
70.9
15
0.58
0.91
74.4
2.33
6.48
0.0
22.1
14.4
56.3
21.0
17.6
55.8
46.6
16
0.58
0.97
73.8
0.37
0.57
76.2
29.0
-9.1
65.3
32.4
-8.4
69.1
71.1
17
1.10
1.58
53.9
0.70
1.14
53.9
31.7
11.9
57.5
27.4
-2.4
83.2
62.1
18
0.69
1.22
67.8
0.58
1.05
59.5
24.2
-2.0
83.9
23.2
2.9
84.0
73.8
19
0.61
1.04
72.1
0.55
0.84
65.0
24.6
11.9
60.9
20.2
-5.1
80.9
69.7
20
0.74
1.09
68.5
0.64
1.06
57.4
23.6
-5.9
75.3
33.2
-15.4
54.9
64.0
21
0.54
0.88
75.9
0.47
1.00
64.2
29.0
-11.6
59.5
20.7
-5.4
80.2
69.9
22
1.60
3.00
22.9
0.48
0.72
69.7
29.8
-14.8
51.8
25.1
-20.7
47.8
48.1
23
0.92
1.34
61.0
0.91
1.43
41.2
24.5
-0.8
86.7
43.3
48.5
31.0
55.0
24
1.21
2.10
44.0
0.58
0.85
63.8
22.9
10.4
65.3
20.4
2.8
85.5
64.7
25
0.77
1.20
66.3
0.77
1.30
48.4
32.4
-7.4
67.7
35.0
8.6
67.6
62.5
26
0.87
1.47
60.3
0.62
1.13
56.7
25.7
-15.5
52.1
26.1
-2.6
83.3
63.1
27
0.67
1.06
70.4
1.31
2.12
14.0
36.4
-15.0
48.2
38.9
-34.9
32.9
41.4
28
1.13
2.36
42.1
0.57
0.84
64.3
35.8
-5.7
70.1
40.6
-38.2
32.1
52.1
29
0.62
0.93
73.4
0.68
1.24
52.4
36.4
-29.1
32.9
33.3
1.5
82.4
60.3
30
0.61
1.01
72.5
0.71
1.26
50.9
27.9
-9.5
64.9
34.1
5.5
74.1
65.6
31
1.39
2.09
40.3
0.64
1.00
58.7
30.3
2.6
79.8
31.7
8.1
69.9
62.2
32
0.77
1.30
64.9
0.47
0.68
70.7
28.6
28.0
36.6
24.6
18.6
52.3
56.1
33
0.50
0.74
78.6
0.55
0.78
66.1
29.1
-13.0
56.2
28.4
-0.8
86.0
71.7
34
0.50
0.93
76.0
0.53
0.82
66.1
30.6
29.3
35.6
26.5
19.0
50.5
57.1
35
0.66
1.04
70.9
0.80
1.39
45.3
26.6
-2.1
82.7
26.9
-9.9
68.6
66.9
36
0.51
0.83
77.1
0.52
0.78
67.1
20.3
-3.0
83.5
26.0
-15.8
57.2
71.2
37
1.32
2.21
40.1
1.25
2.13
15.5
32.0
-0.1
84.8
36.4
29.4
34.0
43.6
38
0.55
0.98
74.1
0.37
0.62
75.2
16.3
-0.3
91.6
19.5
-4.3
82.9
80.9
39
0.70
1.09
69.4
1.11
1.85
25.9
37.7
-20.4
35.1
34.7
18.4
48.2
44.7
40
0.80
1.20
65.8
0.61
0.82
63.3
25.2
-2.3
82.7
49.4
20.5
37.6
62.4
41
1.14
1.70
51.3
0.60
0.94
61.3
30.6
-28.6
35.6
18.2
-7.9
76.2
56.1
42
0.73
1.04
69.5
0.68
1.00
57.5
27.3
3.4
79.4
34.0
8.5
68.1
68.6
43
0.80
1.25
64.9
0.65
0.97
58.9
27.3
-1.8
83.0
23.0
-18.4
53.4
65.1
44
0.83
1.26
64.3
0.64
1.03
57.8
33.6
-13.8
52.1
28.9
-20.7
46.2
55.1
45
0.51
0.83
77.2
0.46
0.68
71.1
29.0
11.0
60.9
34.2
18.1
49.0
64.6
46
0.63
0.96
72.8
0.45
0.71
70.9
31.2
-7.1
68.8
27.4
-14.1
59.9
68.1
47
1.25
1.59
50.5
0.79
1.04
52.9
67.4
-12.9
38.4
36.8
-10.2
63.5
51.3
48
0.56
1.05
72.9
0.56
0.92
62.9
20.2
4.0
81.3
22.3
-11.3
67.8
71.2
49
0.69
1.07
69.9
0.39
0.60
75.1
25.3
20.7
40.2
28.8
8.4
70.7
63.9
50
0.58
0.88
75.1
0.45
0.68
71.3
24.8
-11.1
62.7
30.0
9.8
67.4
69.1
Avg
0.78
1.25
65.3
0.67
1.13
57.2
28.9
-4.5
61.4
30.2
-3.1
60.9
61.2
Detailed Results for Rank 13¶
Team: SRIB-HME
Affiliation: Samsung RnD Institute Bangalore, India
Submitted on: 2018-08-20
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.48
1.14
73.4
0.69
1.70
42.4
20.2
4.0
81.3
17.1
-3.0
86.5
70.9
2
0.76
1.63
60.4
1.08
2.53
15.3
21.0
-10.3
66.3
18.6
-5.8
80.4
55.6
3
0.51
0.97
75.3
0.49
1.20
59.2
20.9
9.1
69.1
31.1
34.3
36.3
60.0
4
0.55
1.21
70.8
0.65
1.63
45.1
24.3
12.5
59.7
15.3
8.4
76.7
63.1
5
0.62
1.12
70.7
0.46
1.01
64.1
20.6
-9.8
67.5
20.8
4.5
81.9
71.1
6
0.44
0.69
80.8
0.37
0.63
74.8
21.5
12.4
61.2
24.1
20.7
48.3
66.3
7
0.66
1.29
67.4
0.92
2.50
20.4
24.9
-2.0
83.8
25.5
27.1
38.8
52.6
8
0.63
1.29
68.1
0.74
1.72
40.5
22.8
-13.4
58.3
24.8
-8.8
71.7
59.7
9
0.66
1.36
66.3
0.76
1.88
36.4
25.8
-13.6
56.3
26.4
21.3
46.1
51.3
10
0.90
1.81
55.0
0.97
2.45
18.9
22.7
-12.0
61.4
13.6
-1.0
92.0
56.8
11
0.82
1.64
58.9
0.98
2.45
18.5
20.1
5.0
78.9
24.9
10.2
68.9
56.3
12
0.49
0.90
76.5
0.44
1.02
64.5
22.6
-11.7
62.4
25.1
1.9
85.3
72.2
13
0.75
1.34
64.8
0.71
1.37
48.7
29.6
13.2
55.5
30.6
26.7
36.5
51.4
14
0.51
1.06
74.0
0.57
1.27
55.5
26.5
18.4
44.9
27.4
37.3
38.0
53.1
15
0.48
1.02
75.1
0.75
1.72
40.1
27.9
15.3
51.6
26.0
15.6
57.6
56.1
16
0.55
1.21
71.0
0.65
1.76
42.5
26.2
19.9
41.5
24.1
20.7
48.3
50.8
17
0.88
1.46
60.3
0.64
1.25
53.4
29.5
11.0
60.6
32.7
1.6
82.5
64.2
18
0.53
0.96
75.0
0.50
1.17
59.5
25.5
-6.5
72.9
26.0
25.5
38.5
61.5
19
0.47
1.11
74.1
0.63
1.49
48.8
19.5
0.7
89.1
23.9
-5.7
78.1
72.5
20
0.86
1.82
55.6
0.68
1.72
42.4
20.9
4.1
80.8
20.9
2.5
85.9
66.2
21
0.58
1.41
67.5
0.81
2.07
30.7
25.5
-7.3
71.2
20.0
-11.7
68.0
59.3
22
0.71
1.26
66.9
0.53
1.24
57.1
27.0
2.7
81.0
16.7
-2.6
87.6
73.1
23
0.58
1.23
70.0
0.74
1.59
43.4
27.1
-3.8
78.4
36.6
37.6
33.9
56.4
24
0.57
1.06
72.6
0.53
1.23
57.5
20.7
8.7
70.1
20.6
9.4
72.4
68.1
25
0.58
1.25
69.8
0.71
1.62
43.5
23.0
1.8
85.0
32.9
26.6
35.5
58.4
26
0.92
2.07
50.7
0.68
1.56
45.7
19.0
-5.4
78.5
21.7
8.7
73.2
62.0
27
0.51
0.75
78.3
0.75
1.37
47.6
33.2
6.3
69.8
26.4
-3.6
81.2
69.2
28
1.34
2.98
28.8
0.72
1.80
39.4
32.7
17.0
45.3
19.5
2.2
87.0
50.1
29
0.74
1.57
61.7
0.77
1.84
37.1
24.8
-8.4
68.9
23.8
3.9
81.7
62.4
30
0.50
0.92
76.1
0.50
0.99
63.4
25.7
-14.5
54.3
31.6
-0.1
85.9
69.9
31
1.27
2.14
42.3
0.81
1.56
41.4
29.0
-1.9
82.1
30.9
18.9
48.8
53.6
32
0.64
1.16
69.7
0.55
1.21
57.2
28.1
4.6
76.2
31.3
21.3
43.9
61.8
33
0.53
1.00
74.3
0.50
0.96
64.0
27.3
-15.6
51.1
24.6
-15.9
57.6
61.8
34
0.51
0.86
76.8
0.59
1.44
51.2
35.2
39.3
33.4
22.1
18.1
54.5
54.0
35
0.53
1.21
71.3
0.61
1.48
49.8
20.7
5.0
78.6
21.0
0.4
89.9
72.4
36
0.51
1.32
70.3
0.76
1.93
35.5
19.2
-7.0
74.8
17.1
6.8
78.9
64.9
37
1.31
3.35
24.2
1.39
3.02
5.6
22.9
4.5
78.9
33.1
40.7
35.4
36.0
38
0.59
1.39
67.6
0.81
2.12
29.9
19.7
0.9
88.7
19.9
16.4
58.8
61.2
39
0.85
2.17
50.9
2.33
4.70
0.0
32.5
2.5
78.9
39.7
11.1
60.4
47.6
40
0.46
0.83
78.3
0.55
0.99
61.9
20.3
5.0
78.8
31.6
37.9
36.1
63.8
41
0.82
1.38
62.7
0.70
1.61
44.1
25.3
-22.4
38.1
19.8
17.0
57.6
50.6
42
0.63
1.12
70.6
0.76
1.64
41.6
31.6
9.4
63.3
31.0
30.5
36.4
53.0
43
0.60
1.04
72.3
0.53
1.23
57.3
25.7
-0.2
87.4
13.2
-4.9
84.5
75.4
44
0.62
1.33
67.8
0.64
1.54
47.4
26.8
-4.8
76.4
17.2
2.1
88.3
70.0
45
0.43
0.92
77.7
0.46
1.13
61.8
28.2
16.2
49.3
30.3
33.5
36.7
56.4
46
0.47
0.90
77.0
0.42
0.96
66.5
27.1
13.2
56.6
20.0
14.6
62.3
65.6
47
1.36
1.81
45.1
0.93
1.64
35.9
65.5
1.9
64.9
31.2
6.3
73.8
54.9
48
0.53
1.25
70.7
0.71
1.64
43.1
20.8
-4.9
78.9
21.1
1.7
87.4
70.0
49
0.65
1.31
67.4
0.63
1.45
49.5
27.5
9.6
64.9
33.6
36.2
35.2
54.3
50
0.55
1.10
72.5
0.58
1.39
52.6
22.5
-9.7
67.0
24.3
12.2
65.1
64.3
Avg
0.67
1.34
66.5
0.71
1.63
45.1
25.8
1.8
67.5
24.8
12.2
63.5
60.6
Detailed Results for Rank 14¶
Team: BioMedIA
Affiliation: Imperial College London, United Kingdom
Submitted on: 2013-07-22
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.75
1.56
61.7
0.73
1.40
47.5
21.9
-4.0
80.3
23.2
-15.8
58.4
62.0
2
0.68
1.31
66.9
1.29
2.59
8.7
24.0
-16.8
49.9
24.9
-17.7
53.9
44.8
3
1.00
2.05
49.2
2.80
5.46
0.0
23.1
6.4
74.4
32.8
23.8
38.3
40.5
4
0.69
1.44
64.7
0.54
1.29
55.8
31.5
-4.2
75.4
33.5
-25.2
35.3
57.8
5
0.95
1.74
54.7
0.44
0.93
66.5
21.0
-3.1
82.8
23.7
-15.4
59.0
65.8
6
0.77
1.48
62.4
0.77
1.78
38.2
28.7
12.0
58.6
20.2
0.5
90.0
62.3
7
0.71
1.34
65.6
0.68
1.38
49.3
24.4
-10.9
63.3
20.0
-0.2
90.8
67.2
8
0.61
1.18
70.1
0.48
1.24
58.9
22.3
-16.3
51.7
32.3
-27.0
35.8
54.1
9
0.73
1.44
63.7
0.80
1.72
38.5
35.8
-29.5
33.2
39.3
-14.2
54.5
47.5
10
0.86
1.58
59.0
0.60
1.50
49.5
31.8
-26.7
35.0
39.5
-33.6
32.6
44.0
11
1.09
2.29
43.9
0.52
1.26
57.0
20.8
-2.6
84.2
25.4
-11.3
66.4
62.9
12
0.63
1.23
69.1
0.43
0.95
66.3
20.1
-6.9
74.5
26.9
3.5
81.2
72.8
13
0.75
1.29
65.6
1.12
2.17
18.9
32.4
30.1
34.8
39.2
22.6
37.9
39.3
14
0.56
1.09
72.4
0.52
1.16
59.2
25.1
8.5
68.5
16.2
8.8
75.4
68.9
15
1.28
2.48
37.2
2.02
4.74
0.0
29.7
-6.3
71.4
17.8
-6.5
79.3
47.0
16
0.76
1.87
57.0
0.61
1.58
47.7
19.8
6.7
75.1
27.4
2.3
83.4
65.8
17
1.09
1.85
50.2
0.74
1.42
46.6
35.8
11.6
56.3
32.0
0.3
85.2
59.6
18
0.41
0.81
79.7
0.36
0.70
73.7
19.2
4.3
80.9
33.0
1.7
82.1
79.1
19
0.85
1.76
56.6
0.51
1.03
62.0
22.4
11.3
63.2
22.5
-12.2
65.9
61.9
20
0.76
1.79
58.3
0.73
1.85
38.1
24.9
-11.0
62.8
25.2
-10.0
69.0
57.0
21
0.51
1.02
74.4
0.64
1.49
48.5
21.0
-6.0
76.2
24.9
-13.9
61.5
65.1
22
1.84
3.71
10.3
0.45
0.96
65.7
25.9
-7.0
71.5
17.7
-13.9
64.7
53.1
23
1.35
2.60
34.1
0.61
1.26
54.2
26.8
-10.4
63.3
35.7
33.3
34.3
46.5
24
0.96
1.99
51.1
0.41
0.89
68.3
21.7
8.4
70.3
17.3
2.9
86.7
69.1
25
0.81
1.52
61.0
0.73
1.52
44.9
28.9
-10.4
62.4
29.2
-0.7
85.7
63.5
26
3.07
6.50
0.0
0.93
2.11
26.3
21.4
-7.9
71.7
22.7
-7.6
74.9
43.2
27
0.61
1.18
70.1
2.61
5.32
0.0
37.5
-2.9
75.7
29.3
-15.8
55.7
50.4
28
0.80
1.60
60.1
0.68
1.44
48.2
33.7
5.3
72.0
32.4
-28.7
35.7
54.0
29
0.84
1.72
57.5
0.71
1.51
46.0
23.3
-2.2
84.0
25.5
8.0
73.0
65.1
30
0.73
1.41
64.2
0.85
2.10
29.1
33.7
-4.9
72.9
33.9
-8.8
67.7
58.5
31
1.43
2.54
33.3
5.09
8.82
0.0
31.4
-2.3
79.9
36.9
3.9
76.0
47.3
32
0.86
1.81
55.7
0.44
1.00
65.0
23.1
11.0
63.6
32.5
7.5
70.8
63.8
33
0.67
1.25
67.8
0.57
1.05
59.8
21.4
-5.4
77.5
28.5
-14.2
59.3
66.1
34
0.55
1.24
70.5
0.50
1.31
56.7
33.4
34.4
34.3
22.5
-2.3
85.5
61.7
35
0.64
1.28
68.0
0.75
1.53
44.0
29.8
-7.9
67.7
28.8
-21.5
44.6
56.0
36
0.57
1.27
69.8
0.47
0.94
65.3
17.8
-4.1
82.1
19.5
-9.5
72.6
72.4
37
1.34
2.48
35.9
0.87
1.87
33.3
25.6
1.7
84.0
32.4
16.9
52.2
51.3
38
0.56
1.24
70.4
0.43
1.09
63.5
16.6
-1.6
88.4
22.0
-2.0
86.4
77.2
39
0.98
1.95
51.3
2.00
4.20
0.0
30.9
-2.3
80.1
41.3
-3.6
74.8
51.5
40
0.55
1.04
73.4
0.62
1.21
54.8
23.1
16.2
51.7
32.1
37.3
35.9
53.9
41
1.46
2.77
29.2
0.60
1.34
52.9
25.3
-22.7
38.1
20.0
0.0
91.2
52.8
42
0.61
1.15
70.5
0.65
1.57
46.5
30.7
15.3
50.2
38.7
-1.9
79.2
61.6
43
0.78
1.51
61.7
0.56
1.14
58.2
25.7
8.3
68.7
18.7
-10.2
71.5
65.0
44
0.73
1.42
64.1
0.69
1.39
49.1
37.6
-23.3
32.3
38.8
-33.4
32.9
44.6
45
0.51
1.02
74.5
0.41
0.96
67.0
32.8
24.2
34.6
27.8
18.8
50.5
56.6
46
0.51
1.03
74.4
0.42
0.96
66.3
29.6
-3.5
77.9
27.5
-15.7
56.8
68.9
47
1.35
1.86
44.5
0.86
1.55
40.1
67.9
-7.3
51.3
39.2
-18.6
45.8
45.4
48
0.63
1.38
66.9
0.71
1.46
46.8
18.6
-2.7
85.0
22.3
-10.3
69.8
67.1
49
1.03
2.22
46.2
0.63
1.64
45.8
25.9
17.4
47.5
26.4
12.7
63.2
50.7
50
0.55
1.03
73.6
0.52
1.44
53.2
23.5
-4.7
78.1
18.3
-2.6
86.7
72.9
Avg
0.88
1.73
57.8
0.86
1.82
45.6
27.2
-0.9
65.4
28.0
-4.4
64.4
58.3
Detailed Results for Rank 15¶
Team: UPMC_IBML
Affiliation: UPMC, United States
Submitted on: 2012-08-24
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.74
1.12
68.2
0.61
0.88
62.3
26.5
-5.6
74.6
24.9
-12.8
63.6
67.2
2
0.89
1.20
63.8
1.41
2.49
5.0
33.0
-20.9
36.2
29.1
-20.0
47.6
38.1
3
0.68
0.99
71.3
0.69
1.25
51.8
32.8
-7.8
66.4
31.0
14.1
58.4
62.0
4
0.87
1.30
62.8
0.69
0.99
57.2
39.2
3.3
74.0
29.7
-7.9
71.2
66.3
5
0.85
1.37
62.2
0.67
1.02
57.0
28.4
-13.7
55.0
34.4
-24.0
37.2
52.8
6
0.83
1.32
63.3
0.60
1.08
58.2
39.6
9.6
59.2
30.5
-3.7
79.4
65.0
7
1.07
1.63
53.7
0.97
1.59
35.9
34.0
-12.3
55.7
33.4
-8.1
69.2
53.6
8
0.90
1.40
60.8
1.48
2.06
9.6
36.6
-16.7
44.1
33.9
-12.3
60.8
43.8
9
0.93
1.36
60.6
0.87
1.23
46.5
36.9
-9.1
61.6
35.8
1.6
81.2
62.5
10
0.77
1.13
67.3
0.65
0.97
58.9
29.9
-12.5
56.9
20.7
-2.7
85.5
67.2
11
1.12
1.81
50.2
0.67
1.05
56.8
29.0
1.2
83.7
32.1
19.5
47.2
59.5
12
0.65
0.94
72.6
0.48
0.67
70.5
46.1
-11.6
51.5
49.5
-7.9
62.6
64.3
13
1.04
1.52
56.1
0.94
1.47
39.4
43.4
26.5
29.6
39.3
7.6
67.6
48.2
14
0.65
1.02
71.6
0.63
0.87
61.8
36.0
10.5
58.7
28.4
4.1
79.4
67.9
15
0.77
1.20
66.3
0.72
1.29
49.9
37.3
9.5
60.6
36.6
10.9
62.2
59.7
16
0.49
0.71
79.4
0.57
1.08
59.0
34.1
13.4
53.0
31.5
4.6
77.1
67.1
17
1.10
1.53
54.5
0.77
1.23
49.6
51.0
6.9
60.0
42.5
-16.6
48.3
53.1
18
0.51
0.74
78.4
0.64
0.92
60.4
33.9
-22.4
34.1
27.2
-8.6
70.9
60.9
19
0.91
1.63
57.3
0.51
0.80
67.2
36.0
-8.3
63.9
28.6
-8.7
70.2
64.6
20
0.73
1.05
69.3
0.69
1.03
56.4
34.4
11.9
56.2
38.0
6.6
70.2
63.0
21
0.76
1.11
67.8
0.56
1.04
60.2
36.1
-12.3
54.6
29.6
-12.8
61.7
61.1
22
1.38
2.36
36.7
0.79
1.19
49.7
34.6
2.2
78.7
29.0
-12.8
61.8
56.7
23
1.22
1.88
47.0
1.18
1.68
27.2
49.3
-2.9
70.1
55.7
37.3
25.5
42.4
24
1.45
2.27
36.5
0.86
1.27
46.1
40.5
-5.1
69.2
35.3
-7.6
69.5
55.3
25
0.84
1.24
64.2
0.93
1.47
39.5
45.4
-11.2
52.8
44.5
38.1
30.4
46.7
26
1.11
1.77
50.8
0.81
1.25
47.9
29.9
-10.1
62.6
36.7
-24.8
34.6
49.0
27
0.79
1.19
66.1
1.07
1.54
33.5
44.8
-4.8
67.8
32.4
-25.1
35.9
50.8
28
0.95
1.98
51.4
0.55
0.81
65.4
41.5
21.1
31.7
28.9
-10.8
65.9
53.6
29
0.92
1.31
61.5
0.88
1.52
40.0
48.4
-38.8
27.3
41.1
-15.1
51.9
45.2
30
0.73
1.23
66.8
0.88
1.40
42.7
39.9
-20.4
34.1
45.8
-9.6
60.8
51.1
31
1.29
1.79
46.9
0.92
1.32
43.1
45.9
-26.0
28.4
33.3
7.8
69.8
47.1
32
0.70
1.06
69.9
0.57
0.80
65.1
35.3
7.2
66.8
32.5
13.0
59.9
65.4
33
0.56
0.80
76.7
0.54
0.83
65.4
39.4
-2.0
77.0
30.6
-7.4
71.9
72.7
34
1.10
1.62
53.1
1.82
2.76
0.0
49.5
53.5
26.7
59.4
-6.6
60.8
35.2
35
0.63
0.94
73.1
0.88
1.55
39.6
37.2
-1.4
79.3
29.8
-0.2
86.4
69.6
36
0.58
0.78
76.5
0.64
0.87
61.2
33.4
-11.6
57.6
29.2
-12.3
62.7
64.5
37
1.72
2.30
30.4
2.30
3.27
0.0
67.4
-36.4
18.3
51.8
1.5
74.2
30.7
38
0.73
1.28
66.0
0.52
0.77
67.3
36.6
-10.9
57.5
23.6
7.4
75.0
66.5
39
1.08
1.62
53.9
2.24
3.31
0.0
47.6
17.2
37.7
46.4
9.6
60.4
38.0
40
1.09
1.60
53.9
1.02
1.33
39.7
55.6
-25.4
23.9
55.8
6.9
61.7
44.8
41
0.99
1.52
57.1
0.62
0.93
60.7
33.1
-25.5
34.4
22.8
-0.6
88.7
60.2
42
0.97
1.48
58.0
1.01
1.47
37.0
58.1
-15.3
37.2
31.9
6.4
73.2
51.4
43
1.09
1.66
53.0
0.80
1.11
51.2
37.2
-1.2
79.8
33.2
-25.0
35.9
55.0
44
0.79
1.16
66.5
0.93
1.55
37.9
44.5
2.1
74.3
35.5
-5.5
73.4
63.0
45
0.52
0.77
77.9
0.48
0.69
70.1
38.9
20.5
34.3
51.0
2.1
73.4
63.9
46
0.65
1.12
70.0
0.55
0.83
65.1
39.2
11.5
54.9
33.8
-10.2
64.9
63.7
47
1.20
1.52
52.4
0.87
1.42
42.6
65.1
-1.1
67.0
34.4
-6.5
71.9
58.5
48
0.56
1.03
73.2
0.64
0.98
59.2
36.8
-15.9
45.8
30.3
-17.3
52.3
57.6
49
0.57
0.87
75.3
0.52
0.71
68.6
28.7
19.2
42.1
36.8
15.8
52.4
59.6
50
0.53
0.77
77.6
0.69
0.99
57.2
31.6
-8.6
65.2
33.7
8.8
67.6
66.9
Avg
0.88
1.34
62.0
0.85
1.29
47.9
39.8
-3.6
53.8
35.4
-2.4
62.9
56.7
Detailed Results for Rank 16¶
Team: BioMedIA
Affiliation: Imperial College London, United Kingdom
Submitted on: 2013-02-25
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.78
1.58
60.8
0.72
1.39
47.8
32.6
-3.2
77.3
25.6
-10.8
67.3
63.3
2
0.70
1.33
65.9
1.24
2.39
10.4
26.7
-14.9
53.1
24.6
-11.3
66.9
49.1
3
1.04
2.08
48.0
2.89
5.56
0.0
32.1
5.8
71.5
41.2
18.1
45.9
41.3
4
0.72
1.49
63.3
0.59
1.38
52.4
35.2
-3.1
76.3
32.3
-19.8
46.4
59.6
5
1.11
2.00
47.7
0.47
0.97
64.5
28.8
-2.0
81.9
30.7
-15.0
56.8
62.7
6
0.80
1.50
61.5
0.79
1.75
38.1
34.6
10.4
59.7
26.0
-0.2
88.3
61.9
7
0.72
1.29
66.1
0.74
1.48
45.5
36.9
-15.2
47.4
28.1
8.7
70.3
57.3
8
0.64
1.21
69.0
0.49
1.20
59.3
26.9
-16.4
49.3
34.6
-22.0
41.2
54.7
9
0.75
1.50
62.5
0.81
1.79
36.6
38.4
-30.3
32.0
40.1
-9.4
63.8
48.7
10
0.87
1.59
58.6
0.60
1.50
49.3
35.3
-24.0
33.4
40.6
-30.6
32.1
43.4
11
1.14
2.33
42.4
0.58
1.33
53.7
26.7
-1.6
83.8
34.9
-10.2
64.4
61.1
12
0.65
1.27
67.8
0.46
0.99
64.6
29.0
-6.4
71.7
38.5
10.0
63.1
66.8
13
0.79
1.32
64.3
1.19
2.26
15.0
36.9
24.3
32.7
40.3
29.8
32.2
36.0
14
0.59
1.11
71.4
0.57
1.20
56.7
31.8
12.2
56.7
30.5
11.3
64.2
62.3
15
1.30
2.51
36.3
2.07
4.84
0.0
34.1
0.1
83.7
30.9
-2.7
81.1
50.3
16
0.79
1.91
55.8
0.70
1.80
40.1
30.7
6.3
71.0
36.4
11.8
60.6
56.9
17
1.17
1.95
47.1
0.80
1.50
43.2
42.0
8.7
60.1
33.4
-2.2
81.0
57.9
18
0.44
0.84
78.7
0.40
0.74
72.0
27.6
-1.8
82.9
37.4
-0.9
81.8
78.9
19
0.91
1.82
54.7
0.50
1.02
62.7
35.6
6.7
67.7
31.0
-14.7
57.1
60.6
20
0.80
1.85
56.6
0.74
1.83
38.1
33.3
-14.5
50.8
34.1
-8.4
68.3
53.4
21
0.51
1.01
74.5
0.64
1.50
48.1
29.6
-7.0
69.9
30.7
-15.4
55.8
62.1
22
1.71
3.59
13.2
0.51
1.01
62.7
31.1
-8.7
65.2
26.9
-15.6
57.1
49.6
23
1.37
2.61
33.3
0.64
1.30
52.6
32.6
-6.0
70.8
49.8
32.1
28.1
46.2
24
0.91
1.85
54.2
0.43
0.90
67.3
29.5
5.7
72.9
28.7
6.7
74.1
67.1
25
0.82
1.53
60.5
0.75
1.52
44.4
34.9
-11.3
57.5
40.2
3.3
75.9
59.6
26
3.88
8.12
0.0
0.98
2.19
22.9
25.6
-3.2
80.5
31.5
-8.2
69.8
43.3
27
0.64
1.19
69.3
2.70
5.50
0.0
41.9
0.9
78.3
26.1
-10.0
68.6
54.1
28
0.79
1.56
60.8
0.68
1.44
48.1
39.7
3.9
72.2
36.9
-29.2
33.8
53.7
29
0.86
1.77
56.4
0.81
1.70
38.8
25.7
0.6
86.5
31.8
12.6
61.0
60.7
30
0.71
1.35
65.5
0.79
1.85
36.1
38.9
-5.0
70.1
45.3
-6.7
66.7
59.6
31
1.45
2.53
32.8
6.10
10.16
0.0
32.8
2.1
79.8
38.3
5.5
72.2
46.2
32
0.86
1.78
56.2
0.47
1.03
63.7
28.1
14.7
52.7
36.7
6.3
71.3
61.0
33
0.68
1.26
67.4
0.55
1.04
60.7
29.2
-2.3
80.8
37.7
-11.7
60.3
67.3
34
0.59
1.28
69.1
0.55
1.40
53.2
38.1
38.8
32.1
28.9
8.3
70.8
56.3
35
0.65
1.29
67.6
0.72
1.50
45.7
36.3
2.0
78.4
33.5
-20.9
43.8
58.9
36
0.59
1.29
69.0
0.45
0.86
67.5
28.0
-7.7
69.0
20.8
-3.6
83.7
72.3
37
1.32
2.41
37.4
0.80
1.57
41.6
32.6
3.6
76.5
42.0
23.0
36.0
47.9
38
0.58
1.29
69.1
0.48
1.11
61.5
26.2
-4.6
77.0
30.7
3.0
80.6
72.0
39
1.08
2.07
47.2
2.08
4.28
0.0
35.4
-5.5
70.7
42.8
-2.0
77.3
48.8
40
0.55
1.06
73.0
0.68
1.29
51.4
31.0
16.4
47.5
41.6
44.7
31.7
50.9
41
1.49
2.77
28.5
0.62
1.32
52.5
31.2
-23.3
35.3
31.3
-1.7
82.9
49.8
42
0.64
1.16
69.7
0.66
1.48
48.2
34.0
21.5
34.2
41.3
0.1
81.7
58.4
43
0.82
1.56
60.3
0.57
1.13
58.2
33.2
13.4
53.4
24.8
-11.9
65.4
59.3
44
0.76
1.48
62.6
0.69
1.38
49.0
39.6
-18.8
37.8
42.2
-30.0
31.4
45.2
45
0.52
1.02
74.3
0.45
1.02
64.5
38.0
26.9
32.2
44.9
24.3
32.1
50.8
46
0.53
1.05
73.6
0.45
1.01
64.7
33.4
5.7
71.2
29.7
-10.3
66.5
69.0
47
1.34
1.85
44.7
0.85
1.53
40.7
67.1
-2.8
62.0
39.9
-20.6
41.6
47.3
48
0.63
1.39
66.6
0.75
1.50
44.8
23.3
0.3
88.5
26.9
-8.3
71.7
67.9
49
1.18
2.58
37.9
0.69
1.78
40.7
32.2
14.2
52.0
31.6
16.6
53.2
45.9
50
0.57
1.05
72.8
0.57
1.50
50.5
34.7
-5.8
70.3
28.9
0.1
87.0
70.2
Avg
0.92
1.78
56.9
0.91
1.87
44.6
33.4
-0.0
63.4
34.3
-1.8
61.3
56.6
Detailed Results for Rank 17¶
Team: shan_unc
Affiliation: UNC Chapel Hill, United States
Submitted on: 2012-04-28
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
1.21
2.02
45.1
0.58
0.91
62.6
23.1
-4.2
79.5
27.9
-16.7
54.6
60.5
2
1.08
1.65
53.4
1.10
2.01
22.8
29.3
-20.4
39.1
36.3
-33.6
34.0
37.3
3
1.03
1.67
54.0
1.20
2.49
11.7
27.7
20.6
39.4
33.2
20.5
44.7
37.4
4
1.33
2.13
41.1
0.99
1.96
27.6
33.0
1.8
80.2
31.4
-30.9
36.2
46.3
5
1.31
1.87
45.1
0.74
1.28
49.6
26.1
2.3
82.4
30.3
-7.0
72.8
62.5
6
1.15
1.77
50.1
0.92
1.57
37.7
28.6
9.7
64.1
20.0
9.8
71.7
55.9
7
1.01
1.48
57.3
0.75
1.23
50.3
28.3
-13.4
55.7
19.1
-1.7
88.2
62.9
8
1.17
1.70
50.7
0.64
1.10
56.6
27.2
-19.2
42.7
27.8
-17.8
52.4
50.6
9
1.02
1.56
56.0
0.53
0.95
63.2
31.7
-12.2
56.8
35.4
2.7
79.1
63.8
10
1.09
1.70
52.3
0.62
1.05
58.1
36.7
-28.2
32.8
28.4
-23.9
40.1
45.8
11
1.28
1.95
44.7
0.63
1.07
57.4
25.0
-0.5
87.1
29.7
4.1
78.9
67.0
12
0.96
1.69
55.3
0.49
0.78
68.0
22.8
4.3
79.3
27.8
16.1
55.8
64.6
13
1.38
2.02
41.5
1.63
2.96
0.0
41.3
22.2
30.6
32.2
19.8
46.5
29.7
14
1.13
1.68
51.9
0.52
0.79
67.0
31.7
10.5
60.7
16.8
1.5
89.6
67.3
15
1.12
1.83
49.9
0.99
1.98
27.0
25.6
17.5
47.5
24.9
3.4
82.3
51.7
16
0.78
1.57
61.0
0.48
0.77
68.6
21.9
2.2
84.7
30.5
-7.6
71.4
71.5
17
1.49
2.13
37.7
0.69
1.09
55.2
37.1
23.2
32.6
26.5
6.3
75.9
50.3
18
1.04
1.71
53.3
0.58
0.99
60.8
24.8
8.4
69.0
20.5
10.0
71.2
63.6
19
0.87
1.44
60.9
0.76
1.37
47.2
26.3
20.1
41.1
26.2
-0.2
88.0
59.3
20
1.10
1.87
49.8
0.74
1.21
51.2
27.0
1.2
84.5
30.3
-16.6
53.7
59.8
21
0.80
1.57
60.4
0.47
0.96
64.8
26.6
-3.1
80.4
19.2
-2.1
87.4
73.2
22
2.25
3.72
1.5
0.73
1.62
42.9
27.4
-1.6
83.5
25.5
-19.7
49.6
44.4
23
1.26
1.97
44.8
0.99
1.43
38.3
26.7
-5.6
74.5
38.2
47.9
33.2
47.7
24
1.94
3.06
14.7
0.53
0.83
65.8
26.4
15.1
52.7
26.4
2.5
83.3
54.1
25
0.92
1.32
61.4
0.73
1.27
50.1
29.4
2.1
81.2
36.9
11.6
60.8
63.4
26
6.75
11.56
0.0
2.07
3.68
0.0
41.5
-16.8
41.5
53.1
-34.1
26.6
17.0
27
0.93
1.46
59.3
2.01
3.79
0.0
41.2
-1.9
76.3
27.1
-21.0
46.5
45.5
28
1.61
2.98
22.9
0.82
1.50
42.3
50.5
-17.4
36.0
33.9
-29.5
35.1
34.1
29
0.76
1.27
65.4
0.70
1.21
52.4
29.3
-22.8
36.2
34.0
14.0
57.2
52.8
30
0.95
1.55
57.4
0.83
1.52
41.6
27.7
-7.1
70.6
44.9
-0.3
79.5
62.3
31
1.97
2.72
18.9
3.21
5.79
0.0
39.4
-5.6
68.6
28.0
7.4
72.9
40.1
32
1.17
1.82
49.0
0.64
1.18
54.8
32.8
30.2
34.6
19.8
10.7
70.0
52.1
33
0.71
1.15
68.4
0.48
0.87
66.6
30.4
-4.0
76.5
26.9
5.1
78.1
72.4
34
0.76
1.22
66.1
0.80
1.33
46.5
38.4
35.9
32.0
26.5
15.6
57.4
50.5
35
0.89
1.43
60.6
0.80
1.47
43.7
20.4
7.4
73.3
29.1
-11.8
63.7
60.3
36
0.80
1.46
62.0
0.51
0.87
65.5
18.7
1.9
86.8
22.0
-5.2
80.0
73.6
37
1.74
2.98
20.2
1.79
3.22
0.0
30.8
15.8
49.0
36.6
41.8
33.9
25.8
38
0.91
1.61
57.6
0.45
0.80
68.9
19.5
4.7
80.1
19.1
3.1
85.4
73.0
39
1.20
1.94
46.6
1.89
3.43
0.0
39.3
-8.1
62.7
35.8
-16.0
52.6
40.5
40
0.86
1.29
63.0
0.65
0.90
60.5
26.9
-2.0
82.8
37.4
43.4
33.5
60.0
41
1.44
2.15
38.3
0.65
1.08
56.7
26.4
-20.5
40.2
24.6
-3.1
83.0
54.5
42
0.93
1.33
61.1
0.78
1.15
50.9
28.9
9.2
65.2
29.3
17.7
52.0
57.3
43
1.07
1.58
54.3
0.51
0.83
66.4
31.2
8.5
65.6
20.2
-7.6
76.0
65.6
44
0.98
1.54
57.0
0.59
1.04
59.4
26.9
0.7
85.9
34.6
-27.0
34.8
59.3
45
0.77
1.40
63.5
0.49
0.84
66.8
31.3
20.3
38.4
33.6
27.6
35.2
51.0
46
0.89
1.44
60.2
0.43
0.72
71.1
28.2
8.5
67.1
28.4
-2.8
82.0
70.1
47
1.30
1.72
47.4
0.73
1.00
56.0
64.3
-2.8
63.3
30.5
-3.4
79.9
61.6
48
0.97
1.81
53.3
0.66
1.08
56.5
20.7
9.3
68.8
20.8
-3.3
84.3
65.7
49
1.23
1.89
46.5
0.54
0.80
66.2
32.2
28.2
34.9
29.0
17.3
53.0
50.1
50
0.81
1.27
64.6
0.62
1.08
57.7
23.3
-5.1
77.4
36.9
4.8
74.3
68.5
Avg
1.24
1.99
49.2
0.85
1.50
47.1
30.2
2.4
61.5
29.3
0.4
62.6
55.1
Detailed Results for Rank 18
Team: SNU_SPL
Affiliation: Seoul National University, Korea Republic of
Submitted on: 2010-06-23
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.70
1.20
67.8
0.72
1.44
46.9
20.4
10.4
66.3
41.3
-12.2
57.6
59.6
2
0.86
1.71
57.2
1.22
2.41
10.8
28.8
-19.4
41.5
27.9
-23.7
40.8
37.6
3
0.72
1.11
68.7
0.46
0.70
70.6
26.1
13.3
56.9
44.5
26.3
30.4
56.6
4
0.86
1.65
57.9
0.46
0.68
71.1
27.2
14.8
52.9
21.3
-10.7
69.5
62.9
5
1.85
3.27
13.6
0.58
0.92
62.1
29.3
13.6
54.8
36.1
-1.8
80.5
52.8
6
1.00
1.60
55.8
0.52
0.80
66.7
28.6
19.0
42.6
26.3
4.0
80.5
61.4
7
1.46
5.51
18.5
0.67
1.06
56.2
30.0
-9.4
64.3
32.7
-1.6
82.5
55.4
8
1.28
4.95
22.5
0.57
1.00
61.1
29.8
-16.2
48.5
37.8
-21.2
41.2
43.3
9
1.36
3.57
20.6
0.52
0.82
66.3
30.1
-17.6
45.1
36.6
8.7
66.5
49.6
10
1.21
2.15
43.5
0.56
0.91
63.3
40.3
-18.6
38.0
28.8
-17.2
53.2
49.5
11
1.52
3.01
24.5
0.66
1.30
51.6
26.4
6.9
71.6
35.2
2.2
80.0
56.9
12
0.74
1.39
64.1
0.39
0.58
75.4
29.4
9.6
63.9
35.4
11.3
62.0
66.4
13
1.03
1.77
52.5
0.64
1.13
55.8
43.0
33.2
29.8
34.1
25.7
35.0
43.3
14
0.82
1.28
64.1
0.66
1.23
53.3
37.2
14.1
49.8
21.4
-1.5
87.6
63.7
15
0.63
1.14
70.4
0.48
0.79
68.1
26.5
24.3
37.5
29.1
6.8
73.7
62.4
16
1.16
3.07
31.4
0.72
1.56
44.4
34.9
21.7
33.6
39.6
6.6
69.5
44.7
17
1.58
2.49
30.6
0.58
0.86
63.7
34.5
32.6
33.8
25.3
1.2
86.4
53.6
18
1.35
2.47
35.8
0.47
0.72
70.0
30.6
12.7
56.2
26.6
6.2
76.0
59.5
19
0.85
1.54
59.8
0.47
0.82
67.9
29.0
19.5
41.3
29.2
-2.4
82.3
62.8
20
1.34
2.27
38.8
0.54
0.96
62.6
25.6
5.4
75.4
35.3
-6.1
72.4
62.3
21
0.48
0.74
79.2
0.97
2.34
20.0
30.3
2.6
79.7
31.9
-8.2
69.6
62.1
22
2.21
4.35
2.4
0.54
0.80
66.1
25.7
6.0
74.1
30.9
-3.6
79.2
55.4
23
1.11
2.30
43.4
0.61
0.94
60.9
29.5
4.1
76.8
48.7
52.2
28.6
52.4
24
0.78
1.52
61.5
0.51
0.76
67.7
30.2
17.6
45.1
34.5
5.7
73.6
62.0
25
0.66
1.04
70.9
0.63
1.10
56.7
26.3
0.0
87.6
34.5
0.5
83.9
74.8
26
1.59
4.87
15.6
0.65
1.22
53.5
23.9
12.0
61.0
34.4
-6.9
71.3
50.4
27
1.28
2.48
37.1
0.56
0.87
64.0
36.4
1.9
78.5
24.6
-10.7
68.0
61.9
28
1.91
4.28
8.9
0.62
1.09
57.3
38.5
11.9
54.4
38.0
-28.1
33.3
38.5
29
0.70
1.14
68.7
1.31
2.63
7.9
25.4
-6.4
73.2
39.2
0.8
81.1
57.7
30
1.42
2.38
35.6
0.50
0.87
65.7
30.5
5.0
74.1
51.8
-9.0
59.4
58.7
31
1.53
2.50
31.5
0.76
1.33
48.0
28.7
5.4
74.0
23.7
4.8
80.1
58.4
32
1.51
2.80
27.7
0.41
0.58
74.7
33.2
29.6
34.4
26.5
23.6
41.5
44.6
33
1.22
2.12
43.6
0.58
0.86
63.3
38.9
12.3
53.3
45.9
-2.9
74.1
58.6
34
1.13
4.52
25.6
0.54
1.04
60.9
39.6
50.0
31.4
33.1
28.4
35.4
38.3
35
0.84
1.36
62.7
0.50
0.73
68.6
35.2
7.5
66.1
37.4
-20.7
42.4
60.0
36
0.66
1.28
67.5
0.47
0.75
69.4
19.0
-0.2
90.6
24.1
-4.1
81.2
77.2
37
1.14
1.91
48.3
1.48
3.15
2.6
32.9
33.3
34.5
38.3
43.1
33.2
29.6
38
0.96
2.09
49.7
0.42
0.69
72.2
29.3
10.2
62.5
23.8
1.3
86.9
67.9
39
1.43
2.95
27.2
2.10
4.20
0.0
36.3
14.7
49.0
44.1
-9.9
61.0
34.3
40
0.78
1.45
62.7
0.61
0.91
61.5
26.6
13.5
56.1
50.8
36.2
27.6
52.0
41
1.21
1.95
46.3
0.84
1.58
40.1
33.7
-23.5
34.1
39.2
-28.7
32.7
38.3
42
1.21
2.44
39.4
0.78
1.62
41.2
39.8
10.0
58.2
34.8
5.8
73.2
53.0
43
0.89
1.40
60.9
0.73
1.24
50.6
32.8
16.0
47.6
26.0
-9.9
68.9
57.0
44
1.10
1.82
50.4
0.63
1.07
57.7
42.1
-12.5
51.4
41.9
-36.3
31.6
47.8
45
0.65
1.21
68.8
0.64
1.21
54.3
35.0
30.1
33.6
46.2
29.5
29.7
46.6
46
1.34
2.25
39.2
0.39
0.57
75.5
38.5
22.5
31.9
39.2
3.3
76.3
55.7
47
1.28
1.76
47.4
0.82
1.33
46.0
70.0
-4.5
56.6
29.2
-9.9
67.6
54.4
48
0.91
1.77
55.3
0.60
1.01
59.8
23.8
4.4
78.6
25.0
-9.8
69.6
65.8
49
1.56
2.94
24.6
0.97
2.32
20.5
33.5
34.9
34.2
36.9
4.9
74.0
38.3
50
1.30
2.33
38.7
0.62
1.23
54.6
27.4
7.4
70.1
42.5
1.7
78.0
60.3
Avg
1.14
2.30
44.8
0.67
1.22
54.6
32.0
9.7
55.1
34.4
0.9
62.8
54.3
Detailed Results for Rank 19¶
Team: UIiibiKnee
Affiliation: University of Iowa, United States
Submitted on: 2013-04-09
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
0.83
1.26
64.1
0.73
1.39
47.8
23.2
22.7
39.1
22.8
-13.1
63.9
53.7
2
0.87
1.32
62.5
1.33
2.05
14.6
28.5
-15.8
50.1
46.4
-46.0
29.6
39.2
3
0.80
1.18
66.1
0.86
1.46
42.1
32.4
38.8
34.8
20.5
8.7
73.8
54.2
4
1.08
1.76
51.7
1.10
1.84
26.4
74.0
-64.9
15.2
85.6
-84.3
12.3
26.4
5
0.65
1.04
71.3
0.56
0.94
62.4
31.7
15.2
49.8
25.1
-16.2
56.9
60.1
6
0.87
1.47
60.4
0.79
1.39
45.7
31.9
27.1
35.0
35.2
6.4
71.8
53.3
7
0.71
1.12
68.8
0.88
1.38
42.9
33.3
4.0
75.0
28.9
6.6
74.2
65.2
8
0.73
1.12
68.4
0.77
1.21
50.1
33.6
-13.0
54.2
30.7
-15.9
54.9
56.9
9
0.80
1.25
65.0
0.74
1.25
50.1
39.2
-13.5
50.4
36.8
-15.1
53.8
54.8
10
1.13
1.85
49.4
0.86
1.59
39.2
33.4
-11.0
58.9
34.8
-26.2
34.7
45.5
11
0.70
1.07
69.8
0.75
1.17
51.7
30.5
36.0
35.7
23.2
2.8
84.3
60.4
12
1.68
3.22
18.0
0.76
1.20
50.5
29.5
11.6
59.3
31.6
5.8
74.5
50.6
13
0.74
1.11
68.2
0.72
1.27
50.5
46.1
50.2
28.3
42.8
13.6
54.2
50.3
14
0.76
1.18
66.8
0.85
1.87
33.7
38.9
34.1
31.7
26.2
5.0
78.6
52.7
15
0.54
0.77
77.5
0.68
1.15
54.2
36.0
38.1
33.1
40.1
-23.9
35.0
49.9
16
1.10
2.06
46.9
0.98
1.54
36.5
33.0
15.0
49.8
29.4
-9.9
67.5
50.2
17
1.93
3.07
14.7
0.88
1.35
43.6
47.9
-16.1
40.3
47.8
-24.7
30.1
32.2
18
0.63
0.96
72.9
0.45
0.66
72.0
30.4
34.5
35.7
32.7
4.6
76.4
64.2
19
0.64
0.93
72.9
0.62
1.03
58.6
32.3
43.1
34.8
23.9
-13.2
63.3
57.4
20
4.92
8.37
0.0
0.66
1.01
57.7
64.2
-48.3
19.8
35.3
-2.2
80.1
39.4
21
0.90
1.63
57.3
1.17
1.76
26.0
28.1
9.4
64.9
22.9
-9.5
71.1
54.9
22
1.24
2.18
42.2
0.77
1.29
48.3
33.0
16.0
47.4
25.2
-22.2
44.8
45.7
23
0.78
1.17
66.6
0.87
1.38
43.4
35.5
31.3
33.3
40.4
37.5
32.2
43.9
24
0.88
1.48
60.0
0.60
0.96
60.9
33.6
36.9
34.2
21.0
-7.8
75.2
57.6
25
0.99
1.64
55.4
0.88
1.52
40.3
24.5
25.3
38.5
31.5
15.9
54.5
47.2
26
1.05
1.51
56.1
0.71
1.07
55.0
44.9
-40.9
28.9
78.1
-77.5
15.6
38.9
27
1.02
1.89
51.2
0.93
1.41
40.8
38.5
7.5
64.5
27.7
-19.2
49.7
51.5
28
2.12
4.55
4.3
1.09
1.80
27.6
37.5
18.6
39.4
34.2
-11.2
62.7
33.5
29
1.08
1.99
48.4
1.24
1.95
19.7
28.0
-9.3
65.4
39.6
-10.9
61.0
48.6
30
0.93
1.34
60.9
0.68
1.10
55.2
32.8
33.2
34.6
28.8
0.4
86.5
59.3
31
1.31
1.96
44.0
1.02
1.87
28.3
45.8
2.4
72.9
53.3
-9.7
57.4
50.6
32
0.74
1.34
65.0
0.48
0.74
69.2
36.8
46.5
32.7
39.9
6.2
70.1
59.2
33
1.72
3.56
12.8
0.80
1.14
50.7
28.7
31.1
36.5
23.5
-5.0
79.8
45.0
34
0.76
1.35
64.5
0.94
1.86
31.1
47.8
75.2
27.5
26.9
2.7
82.8
51.5
35
0.82
1.32
63.5
1.19
1.90
22.4
34.1
11.5
57.5
44.0
-33.3
30.6
43.5
36
0.97
1.67
55.4
0.76
1.41
46.5
23.1
24.3
39.1
23.1
-3.9
82.1
55.8
37
0.91
1.54
58.4
1.14
1.83
25.4
34.7
30.8
33.7
39.4
28.3
32.7
37.5
38
1.10
1.85
50.1
0.70
1.05
55.7
26.1
30.0
37.7
33.7
3.2
78.8
55.6
39
1.17
1.80
49.2
2.12
3.33
0.0
66.1
-57.8
18.9
75.5
-73.0
16.8
21.2
40
0.71
1.06
69.8
0.56
0.81
65.3
33.7
41.4
34.2
34.2
44.6
35.0
51.0
41
0.91
1.42
60.2
0.71
1.12
54.0
20.8
-9.3
68.8
21.4
-13.0
64.8
61.9
42
1.11
1.67
52.4
0.64
1.01
58.5
45.7
14.9
44.0
33.1
1.1
83.3
59.6
43
0.76
1.28
65.5
0.51
0.75
68.0
28.3
12.9
56.7
26.5
-17.6
53.4
60.9
44
0.89
1.33
62.0
0.94
1.37
41.3
38.7
26.8
31.8
41.4
-37.3
31.8
41.7
45
0.82
1.09
67.0
0.44
0.74
70.5
35.1
42.2
33.5
24.5
-2.9
83.3
63.6
46
1.29
2.24
40.3
0.91
1.33
43.2
49.4
-15.0
42.2
46.1
-41.6
29.7
38.8
47
1.56
1.94
38.9
1.08
1.58
32.2
63.8
33.7
20.0
35.7
-13.0
58.4
37.4
48
0.70
1.10
69.2
0.76
1.30
48.5
27.4
23.2
37.1
24.8
-10.3
68.7
55.9
49
1.71
3.20
17.6
0.82
1.30
46.8
33.8
35.7
34.1
29.4
13.9
59.5
39.5
50
1.30
2.41
37.8
0.96
1.48
38.5
32.5
2.2
79.6
31.1
-14.2
58.2
53.5
Avg
1.09
1.81
53.6
0.85
1.38
44.9
36.8
14.4
42.4
35.1
-10.3
57.6
49.6
Detailed Results for Rank 20¶
Team: Quan Wang
Affiliation: Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, United States
Submitted on: 2013-11-26
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
1.24
2.04
44.3
0.99
2.39
18.4
24.8
15.6
52.2
16.2
-0.5
91.9
51.7
2
1.43
2.71
30.7
1.72
3.12
0.0
27.0
-22.0
37.3
25.2
-19.4
50.4
29.6
3
1.55
2.92
25.0
1.91
3.45
0.0
21.8
12.4
61.1
29.2
-0.4
86.4
43.1
4
2.99
5.49
0.0
3.61
6.72
0.0
27.9
2.9
80.1
15.5
9.5
74.3
38.6
5
2.37
4.84
0.0
2.62
5.27
0.0
21.7
7.1
73.4
28.0
-2.5
82.8
39.0
6
0.96
1.54
57.5
2.13
4.00
0.0
24.5
5.6
75.5
26.4
-9.6
69.4
50.6
7
0.97
1.53
57.3
0.82
1.26
47.4
25.2
7.9
70.0
20.8
19.5
52.1
56.7
8
1.04
1.75
52.8
0.93
2.14
25.8
23.6
-16.7
50.3
19.2
-14.1
63.6
48.1
9
1.07
1.82
51.0
1.41
3.31
4.9
29.1
-20.0
40.1
29.2
13.9
59.6
38.9
10
1.57
2.92
24.8
0.56
0.91
63.2
31.0
-22.2
35.4
17.1
-8.1
76.4
49.9
11
2.24
3.95
1.8
1.44
2.86
3.8
25.5
10.4
64.0
22.4
5.2
79.8
37.3
12
3.25
6.87
0.0
2.24
4.25
0.0
24.1
-1.2
85.9
32.6
20.8
44.4
32.6
13
1.04
1.60
54.7
2.07
3.50
0.0
33.3
30.6
34.4
35.4
14.4
55.8
36.2
14
1.18
2.03
45.6
0.78
1.74
38.9
26.1
20.3
40.8
20.3
23.3
44.8
42.5
15
2.82
5.39
0.0
2.27
4.45
0.0
25.4
1.4
84.9
20.5
1.0
89.1
43.5
16
4.33
8.42
0.0
2.01
4.08
0.0
34.3
1.1
81.4
26.6
3.4
81.4
40.7
17
2.30
3.79
0.3
2.24
3.56
0.0
33.4
5.5
71.6
45.2
-23.7
33.1
26.3
18
1.10
2.19
45.2
1.06
1.87
27.0
19.8
1.7
86.8
22.5
12.0
66.2
56.3
19
2.44
4.97
0.0
1.37
3.09
6.0
28.6
28.4
36.6
22.2
1.6
87.1
32.4
20
1.73
3.01
19.8
0.74
1.21
50.9
33.7
-16.6
45.7
25.2
-21.1
47.1
40.9
21
0.73
2.46
49.3
0.38
0.69
73.4
22.9
-3.9
80.3
24.4
-10.8
67.7
67.7
22
3.55
5.91
0.0
1.64
3.21
0.0
26.2
-13.7
55.9
16.3
-4.8
83.3
34.8
23
1.63
2.76
25.8
1.98
3.79
0.0
34.7
-14.2
50.8
39.0
26.9
32.8
27.4
24
3.33
5.90
0.0
1.05
2.47
16.3
24.5
26.6
38.5
22.2
8.8
72.7
31.9
25
0.91
1.69
56.3
0.87
1.47
41.5
23.1
4.0
79.8
34.6
30.2
34.8
53.1
26
3.49
6.54
0.0
2.18
3.86
0.0
24.6
7.7
70.6
25.6
-4.0
80.8
37.8
27
1.99
4.20
7.2
2.63
4.76
0.0
41.3
-30.1
30.6
25.3
-21.0
47.1
21.2
28
1.91
2.97
16.7
0.87
1.39
43.3
44.4
-9.6
56.9
28.0
-17.5
53.0
42.5
29
1.18
2.06
45.3
1.25
2.44
10.0
31.7
-17.4
44.8
32.0
11.3
63.4
40.9
30
1.03
1.75
53.0
1.56
2.70
0.1
33.3
-18.2
42.3
41.4
-7.1
67.8
40.8
31
3.95
6.21
0.0
6.94
10.98
0.0
51.1
-44.4
26.0
34.1
0.1
84.8
27.7
32
1.37
2.38
36.8
1.08
1.90
25.7
26.7
19.7
41.9
31.0
20.6
45.6
37.5
33
1.09
2.47
41.4
0.73
3.64
26.6
33.3
-7.4
67.1
28.0
-21.0
46.0
45.3
34
0.70
1.28
66.7
1.04
1.91
26.8
35.0
38.7
33.6
21.6
18.0
54.8
45.5
35
0.94
1.48
58.8
0.75
1.28
49.2
40.4
-26.3
31.0
31.5
-28.8
36.1
43.8
36
1.81
3.93
11.1
1.26
2.68
9.5
16.6
-3.7
83.6
20.1
8.1
75.0
44.8
37
1.82
3.36
13.0
1.81
3.19
0.0
27.9
-7.5
69.4
36.0
31.5
34.2
29.1
38
2.81
6.60
0.0
0.86
1.53
40.5
17.7
9.7
69.2
20.4
14.9
61.5
42.8
39
1.41
2.35
36.3
3.40
5.66
0.0
36.4
-13.9
50.8
31.2
-1.4
83.6
42.6
40
1.93
3.71
8.4
1.87
3.34
0.0
26.3
6.0
73.8
35.9
51.2
34.2
29.1
41
1.92
3.35
10.9
0.94
2.18
24.3
27.5
-23.8
37.1
20.0
-3.3
84.6
39.2
42
1.37
2.35
37.1
1.39
2.17
10.2
55.5
-44.7
23.9
28.9
-13.3
60.9
33.0
43
1.62
2.66
27.3
1.43
2.22
8.0
37.3
-18.4
39.8
21.8
-16.9
56.8
33.0
44
1.14
1.91
48.2
1.07
2.52
15.7
48.3
-29.7
27.3
38.8
-37.5
32.9
31.0
45
1.07
2.66
39.1
0.53
1.00
62.1
28.8
13.5
55.3
35.4
40.0
34.4
47.7
46
1.96
4.91
7.9
0.35
0.61
76.2
32.7
7.2
67.9
31.0
-2.0
82.4
58.6
47
1.11
1.49
54.9
0.72
1.00
56.1
64.9
-17.5
29.1
26.5
-1.0
86.3
56.6
48
2.01
4.13
6.7
1.78
3.19
0.0
21.6
-0.8
87.9
20.5
-2.6
85.8
45.1
49
2.80
5.03
0.0
0.92
1.75
34.0
30.1
30.2
35.9
26.5
19.4
49.8
29.9
50
1.10
1.99
47.9
1.57
2.87
0.0
27.5
3.8
78.2
29.5
-5.9
75.3
50.4
Avg
1.83
3.41
26.3
1.56
2.91
18.7
30.7
-2.5
55.7
27.1
2.1
62.9
40.9
Detailed Results for Rank 21¶
Team: fractal
Affiliation: Fractal Analytics Inc, India
Submitted on: 2016-09-27
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
6.36
14.28
0.0
0.96
3.66
19.3
27.2
9.0
66.4
21.5
-2.9
84.8
42.6
2
6.20
13.84
0.0
2.36
5.47
0.0
28.5
-9.7
64.0
23.7
-3.3
83.1
36.8
3
6.79
15.07
0.0
1.87
7.29
0.0
25.5
13.1
57.6
35.0
17.7
49.6
26.8
4
11.35
19.41
0.0
8.75
16.42
0.0
32.1
17.1
45.3
19.4
7.2
77.1
30.6
5
12.05
20.21
0.0
5.70
12.76
0.0
29.2
5.7
73.1
29.1
-1.9
83.3
39.1
6
8.48
14.02
0.0
4.68
10.89
0.0
38.7
20.6
34.1
26.2
11.6
65.4
24.9
7
8.23
16.74
0.0
1.90
7.89
0.0
28.9
2.0
81.7
21.8
11.1
68.3
37.5
8
8.13
15.76
0.0
1.88
7.22
0.0
28.7
-2.3
81.2
18.3
-4.1
83.9
41.3
9
7.95
16.35
0.0
3.26
9.76
0.0
31.9
-1.5
81.5
31.8
16.4
53.5
33.8
10
7.51
16.90
0.0
1.41
4.58
4.8
29.3
-7.7
68.3
23.0
0.5
88.9
40.5
11
7.86
16.72
0.0
2.29
8.04
0.0
25.1
12.3
59.8
26.6
10.3
67.8
31.9
12
6.48
14.63
0.0
2.86
7.57
0.0
26.4
5.2
75.6
27.8
6.8
74.3
37.5
13
10.90
18.93
0.0
4.71
12.61
0.0
43.8
40.6
29.4
29.9
11.8
63.4
23.2
14
7.35
16.35
0.0
2.02
6.68
0.0
35.9
33.3
33.1
24.4
25.5
39.3
18.1
15
7.61
15.16
0.0
3.37
6.66
0.0
40.5
26.1
31.0
29.0
7.3
72.8
25.9
16
14.34
23.88
0.0
5.32
14.18
0.0
34.1
16.0
46.9
28.2
-1.8
84.1
32.7
17
11.52
19.95
0.0
7.02
15.30
0.0
37.3
22.9
32.5
33.7
2.1
80.9
28.3
18
7.61
16.34
0.0
1.24
5.98
10.3
28.2
5.7
73.7
27.6
20.7
46.7
32.7
19
9.21
16.05
0.0
4.09
11.11
0.0
28.0
18.4
44.2
29.7
-2.9
81.2
31.3
20
7.89
16.24
0.0
1.69
5.81
0.0
36.9
16.8
43.8
25.6
-6.1
76.7
30.1
21
13.05
23.47
0.0
4.70
11.37
0.0
34.8
-5.4
71.2
24.2
-15.8
58.0
32.3
22
9.36
16.86
0.0
11.50
21.32
0.0
32.7
10.9
59.5
21.5
-8.9
73.0
33.1
23
8.83
15.61
0.0
3.19
9.63
0.0
37.9
11.9
54.6
43.2
51.4
31.0
21.4
24
7.97
17.14
0.0
2.80
9.56
0.0
32.3
23.4
34.8
27.3
-1.1
85.9
30.2
25
6.02
13.93
0.0
0.62
1.82
42.5
24.0
13.5
57.5
44.9
40.6
30.2
32.5
26
10.93
18.21
0.0
5.62
12.16
0.0
29.9
-0.7
84.4
30.1
-4.1
78.7
40.8
27
9.80
17.60
0.0
2.83
8.66
0.0
41.5
3.6
72.2
18.8
2.4
86.9
39.8
28
6.78
14.86
0.0
0.59
1.28
54.6
39.8
28.4
31.3
24.3
-6.0
77.3
40.8
29
12.30
21.91
0.0
3.60
10.37
0.0
28.1
-6.4
72.0
31.5
15.3
55.9
32.0
30
5.98
13.30
0.0
1.05
5.75
16.2
26.6
7.4
70.4
32.1
-1.7
82.4
42.3
31
10.81
18.00
0.0
10.39
20.37
0.0
38.4
5.5
69.2
34.6
25.9
34.8
26.0
32
9.20
17.82
0.0
3.33
12.06
0.0
37.0
20.2
35.8
25.5
7.4
74.1
27.5
33
6.09
13.62
0.0
0.89
4.10
21.5
32.7
2.7
78.5
28.0
-16.8
54.3
38.6
34
8.28
16.69
0.0
1.45
5.29
3.5
46.1
64.0
28.3
32.9
17.4
50.9
20.7
35
6.56
14.43
0.0
1.15
2.96
13.0
29.1
16.9
47.3
24.5
-9.1
71.2
32.9
36
8.05
17.16
0.0
1.80
7.53
0.0
21.6
3.6
81.5
23.0
10.8
68.5
37.5
37
7.53
16.42
0.0
1.41
3.13
4.9
31.4
25.5
35.2
40.2
41.1
32.3
18.1
38
7.21
15.64
0.0
2.07
5.63
0.0
27.8
14.4
53.7
27.0
14.0
60.3
28.5
39
7.94
15.88
0.0
4.42
10.99
0.0
42.5
19.4
35.1
29.3
18.5
50.4
21.4
40
11.45
20.47
0.0
7.28
19.10
0.0
29.1
17.4
46.0
31.9
28.8
35.9
20.5
41
6.74
14.51
0.0
1.42
6.78
4.5
28.2
-13.5
55.5
26.9
8.9
70.5
32.6
42
7.98
15.48
0.0
5.42
12.16
0.0
35.8
30.2
33.2
33.8
16.8
51.7
21.2
43
6.51
14.64
0.0
0.59
1.44
51.0
35.7
22.7
33.2
16.2
-6.9
79.2
40.9
44
7.91
17.08
0.0
2.26
6.49
0.0
26.2
-2.0
83.1
24.8
-14.5
60.2
35.8
45
9.19
17.35
0.0
3.04
10.81
0.0
40.3
39.8
31.1
32.6
22.3
41.3
18.1
46
6.81
14.89
0.0
2.83
8.11
0.0
29.7
16.1
48.8
29.6
8.2
70.7
29.9
47
9.12
17.05
0.0
2.80
8.69
0.0
64.1
15.7
33.6
29.6
3.4
80.3
28.5
48
8.21
17.06
0.0
1.61
5.67
0.0
28.0
11.2
61.0
25.1
5.3
78.3
34.8
49
8.84
16.97
0.0
2.93
8.65
0.0
34.1
30.3
34.0
32.7
29.8
35.6
17.4
50
9.41
17.94
0.0
3.22
10.71
0.0
29.6
-2.3
80.8
30.0
7.0
72.9
38.4
Avg
8.57
16.78
0.0
3.28
8.85
4.9
33.0
13.4
54.7
28.2
8.3
65.2
31.2
Detailed Results for Rank 22¶
Team: sas_twente
Affiliation: University of Twente, Netherlands
Submitted on: 2012-02-09
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
1.54
2.21
35.5
2.50
3.48
0.0
49.8
42.3
26.6
46.0
-6.6
66.6
32.2
2
2.40
3.29
3.2
2.01
3.79
0.0
53.2
-8.2
56.0
37.0
34.4
33.7
23.2
3
2.88
4.37
0.0
1.23
1.86
21.7
63.4
34.4
20.2
48.0
34.1
28.9
17.7
4
1.04
1.43
57.3
1.05
1.69
31.2
36.3
26.1
33.0
33.3
2.6
80.1
50.4
5
0.85
1.19
64.8
2.22
3.46
0.0
46.1
24.4
28.3
52.0
20.6
36.2
32.3
6
2.69
3.82
0.0
2.46
3.79
0.0
59.5
38.9
22.0
55.5
46.2
25.6
11.9
7
1.21
1.76
49.0
2.05
3.05
0.0
43.9
32.5
29.4
46.3
53.3
29.6
27.0
8
1.04
1.42
57.3
4.56
6.35
0.0
39.5
-2.3
76.1
55.7
-20.0
35.8
42.3
9
5.60
7.62
0.0
7.12
8.90
0.0
77.7
-28.3
13.5
88.8
11.0
39.1
13.2
10
2.02
3.25
10.3
6.66
8.49
0.0
50.0
7.2
60.0
49.6
-11.3
55.7
31.5
11
1.75
2.63
24.9
7.65
9.68
0.0
57.1
55.7
23.2
57.1
42.2
24.9
18.3
12
2.55
3.64
0.0
2.76
4.24
0.0
62.3
55.0
20.7
60.4
95.9
23.4
11.0
13
1.99
2.65
19.6
4.90
6.67
0.0
63.3
127.4
20.2
69.3
27.1
19.5
14.8
14
1.51
2.15
37.1
1.16
1.71
27.3
56.9
45.1
23.3
44.0
23.0
35.0
30.7
15
1.28
1.74
47.8
4.93
6.70
0.0
63.4
36.0
20.2
70.2
68.2
19.1
21.8
16
1.86
2.74
21.0
3.53
5.09
0.0
56.6
71.5
23.4
62.7
3.4
65.7
27.5
17
2.11
2.94
12.8
4.85
6.61
0.0
57.9
54.8
22.8
88.7
42.8
11.0
11.6
18
1.29
1.76
47.3
1.67
2.40
0.0
59.2
49.4
22.2
52.3
59.3
27.0
24.1
19
1.42
1.99
41.1
3.75
5.07
0.0
53.7
62.3
24.8
59.0
26.6
24.0
22.5
20
2.36
3.56
0.0
5.42
7.38
0.0
60.8
40.8
21.4
54.7
15.1
46.0
16.8
21
2.47
3.38
1.9
2.52
4.09
0.0
49.0
25.8
27.0
43.5
24.6
32.0
15.2
22
1.01
1.35
59.2
4.34
5.88
0.0
42.7
49.3
29.9
52.7
-2.2
72.5
40.4
23
1.23
1.56
51.3
8.24
10.54
0.0
56.2
55.7
23.6
90.0
76.0
10.4
21.3
24
0.97
1.32
60.5
4.77
6.11
0.0
55.6
85.5
23.9
97.6
-22.4
12.6
24.2
25
1.32
1.72
47.1
3.80
5.71
0.0
51.0
28.3
26.0
75.3
56.5
16.9
22.5
26
1.14
1.50
54.2
2.34
3.94
0.0
51.1
27.8
26.0
57.5
21.0
33.0
28.3
27
3.05
4.12
0.0
3.35
5.18
0.0
60.2
27.8
21.7
66.1
-13.5
44.2
16.5
28
1.65
2.76
25.3
3.64
5.07
0.0
56.0
80.0
23.7
43.7
-14.1
52.7
25.4
29
3.33
4.68
0.0
2.06
4.01
0.0
51.7
14.1
43.1
52.4
42.0
26.9
17.5
30
1.86
2.59
23.1
2.73
3.91
0.0
60.1
41.0
21.8
59.6
76.5
23.8
17.2
31
2.30
3.62
0.5
2.11
3.49
0.0
54.9
32.9
24.2
63.1
76.0
22.2
11.7
32
0.95
1.25
61.8
1.12
1.76
27.4
52.3
86.9
25.4
49.9
60.4
28.1
35.7
33
1.96
2.83
17.6
4.97
6.39
0.0
60.4
47.7
21.6
67.9
13.3
43.7
20.7
34
1.16
1.69
51.1
5.71
7.84
0.0
65.2
131.1
19.3
79.0
76.7
15.2
21.4
35
1.19
1.77
49.1
1.34
2.00
15.2
46.8
37.2
28.0
45.5
27.1
30.0
30.6
36
1.50
1.97
39.6
4.09
6.45
0.0
45.6
43.7
28.6
67.4
31.0
20.3
22.1
37
1.53
2.08
37.6
6.74
8.64
0.0
58.5
38.3
22.5
78.6
83.3
15.4
18.9
38
2.37
3.63
0.0
4.87
6.89
0.0
54.4
33.1
24.4
59.4
53.1
23.8
12.1
39
0.97
1.38
59.5
5.68
7.84
0.0
51.2
71.0
25.9
80.1
-6.2
52.4
34.5
40
3.14
4.30
0.0
4.71
6.52
0.0
86.2
39.8
9.5
95.5
-14.2
29.8
9.8
41
0.99
1.62
55.7
2.79
3.88
0.0
35.5
-12.6
54.2
50.4
17.9
42.3
38.1
42
1.20
1.74
49.5
2.91
4.28
0.0
61.4
59.6
21.1
45.8
9.6
60.8
32.9
43
1.85
2.35
26.7
3.62
4.70
0.0
54.0
48.4
24.6
46.7
-10.3
59.0
27.6
44
2.16
3.35
5.8
4.50
6.26
0.0
59.9
37.8
21.8
65.0
56.9
21.4
12.3
45
2.95
4.15
0.0
5.42
7.02
0.0
66.5
45.6
18.8
75.4
120.2
16.8
8.9
46
1.36
1.88
44.0
2.15
3.21
0.0
57.8
52.0
22.8
50.1
64.2
27.9
23.7
47
2.22
2.97
9.9
2.41
3.50
0.0
64.8
31.5
19.5
38.2
20.6
42.3
17.9
48
1.46
2.02
39.8
5.93
8.22
0.0
48.6
62.5
27.1
83.2
4.7
54.0
30.2
49
1.14
1.49
54.3
5.15
6.66
0.0
53.5
67.7
24.8
58.5
18.2
38.1
29.3
50
1.27
1.67
49.0
2.11
3.24
0.0
53.4
26.4
24.9
61.8
50.0
22.8
24.2
Avg
1.82
2.58
30.1
3.77
5.27
2.5
55.5
43.6
26.9
60.6
31.3
34.4
23.4
Detailed Results for Rank 23¶
Team: Local Regressors
Affiliation: University of Basel, Switzerland
Submitted on: 2010-11-24
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
1.39
1.98
42.0
1.49
2.14
7.8
63.3
-34.9
20.2
73.0
-43.6
17.9
22.0
2
1.34
2.09
41.5
4.45
6.29
0.0
64.8
-51.8
19.5
83.8
-61.1
13.1
18.5
3
0.92
1.36
60.9
1.36
2.18
10.8
53.1
-24.4
25.0
51.4
-10.5
56.5
38.3
4
1.37
1.93
43.1
1.65
2.29
2.4
54.7
-27.7
24.3
97.5
-50.5
7.1
19.2
5
1.23
1.71
49.2
1.44
1.92
13.7
50.7
-26.3
26.2
91.3
-36.8
9.8
24.7
6
1.10
1.65
53.0
1.35
2.05
14.3
63.0
-21.4
20.8
74.8
-41.4
17.1
26.3
7
1.31
1.94
44.2
1.39
2.02
13.3
61.9
-34.6
20.9
76.8
-26.5
16.2
23.6
8
1.66
2.36
30.7
1.26
1.99
18.3
61.8
-43.3
21.0
79.4
-48.6
15.0
21.3
9
1.40
2.00
41.5
2.12
3.03
0.0
69.2
-43.6
17.5
88.2
-39.4
11.2
17.5
10
1.60
2.54
29.4
1.70
2.54
0.0
67.9
-47.8
18.1
74.3
-52.5
17.3
16.2
11
1.46
2.21
37.1
1.30
1.99
16.9
56.3
-22.8
23.5
75.0
-18.9
29.5
26.8
12
1.18
1.53
53.0
1.57
2.10
6.3
64.6
-24.1
19.6
88.7
-16.4
28.4
26.8
13
1.13
1.73
51.2
3.40
5.69
0.0
62.0
1.8
66.6
87.6
-16.9
27.9
36.4
14
1.20
1.71
49.9
1.54
2.26
3.6
68.8
-23.6
17.6
84.5
-47.9
12.8
21.0
15
1.50
1.94
40.0
2.02
2.69
0.0
62.2
-15.1
35.9
82.8
-11.5
40.8
29.2
16
2.33
3.01
7.3
2.03
2.69
0.0
85.1
-14.2
27.3
88.0
-38.8
11.3
11.4
17
1.22
1.78
48.5
2.14
2.83
0.0
64.4
-13.4
38.6
83.9
-53.0
13.1
25.1
18
0.82
1.14
66.2
1.81
2.50
0.0
54.4
-31.0
24.4
67.0
-18.2
34.5
31.3
19
0.83
1.28
63.8
1.23
1.67
25.8
56.8
-15.3
37.9
58.0
-26.9
24.5
38.0
20
1.85
2.77
20.8
1.73
2.61
0.0
75.0
-33.7
14.7
86.0
-37.3
12.2
11.9
21
1.32
1.94
44.1
1.80
2.48
0.0
62.6
-32.1
20.6
73.0
-44.9
17.9
20.6
22
1.96
2.65
20.0
1.46
2.17
8.0
73.0
-31.6
15.7
87.3
-45.6
11.6
13.8
23
2.03
2.81
16.4
1.53
2.27
3.9
64.9
-28.9
19.5
95.1
-22.1
14.3
13.5
24
1.18
1.65
51.0
1.19
1.79
24.8
53.0
-21.8
25.1
76.3
-24.0
18.9
30.0
25
1.44
2.20
37.9
1.69
2.48
0.0
58.1
-40.2
22.7
87.3
-28.7
11.6
18.0
26
2.03
3.41
7.7
1.62
2.24
3.4
61.0
-35.0
21.3
80.9
-34.0
14.4
11.7
27
1.31
1.79
46.4
2.49
3.31
0.0
77.5
-27.5
13.6
93.5
-67.8
8.9
17.2
28
2.52
3.57
0.0
1.95
2.62
0.0
67.3
-20.6
20.7
91.0
-62.3
9.9
7.7
29
1.43
2.10
39.4
2.93
4.29
0.0
60.2
-42.0
21.7
93.2
-44.1
9.0
17.5
30
1.08
1.61
53.8
1.27
1.91
19.5
49.8
-25.6
26.6
63.1
-6.4
59.5
39.9
31
1.55
2.30
33.9
3.72
5.98
0.0
54.9
-28.6
24.2
94.7
-31.6
8.3
16.6
32
0.88
1.30
62.5
1.31
1.79
20.9
53.8
-9.6
52.4
70.7
-17.6
34.0
42.5
33
0.83
1.29
63.8
1.35
1.84
18.2
62.3
-17.1
31.3
71.7
-36.0
18.4
32.9
34
1.71
2.15
32.7
1.05
1.67
31.5
66.5
19.4
23.8
73.7
-7.3
53.1
35.3
35
1.80
2.61
24.2
2.05
2.87
0.0
77.2
-19.5
18.5
87.5
-55.0
11.5
13.5
36
0.92
1.31
61.7
1.08
1.53
33.3
55.2
-36.2
24.1
88.9
-49.0
10.9
32.5
37
1.61
2.17
34.5
1.83
2.77
0.0
66.9
-24.7
18.6
80.7
-14.6
35.6
22.2
38
1.47
2.90
27.2
1.46
2.07
10.0
53.1
-31.4
25.0
76.4
-34.7
16.4
19.7
39
2.89
4.21
0.0
4.13
6.22
0.0
82.2
-25.9
11.4
93.8
-25.1
8.9
5.1
40
1.29
1.80
46.7
1.57
2.13
5.6
78.5
-23.6
13.1
77.4
-5.0
56.0
30.4
41
2.09
3.10
10.9
1.88
2.62
0.0
62.3
-52.1
20.7
84.7
-48.7
12.7
11.1
42
1.58
2.17
35.1
1.91
2.70
0.0
74.1
-19.3
20.6
88.1
-39.8
11.2
16.7
43
1.35
1.89
44.0
1.29
1.74
22.4
58.7
-20.0
26.2
69.1
-49.3
19.6
28.1
44
1.24
1.89
46.5
1.61
2.31
1.8
70.1
-25.5
17.1
78.4
-42.7
15.5
20.2
45
1.08
1.61
53.8
1.39
1.80
17.9
52.9
-6.4
60.4
78.8
-16.8
32.0
41.0
46
2.03
2.57
19.8
2.07
2.48
0.0
73.8
-13.7
33.5
98.2
-18.0
21.1
18.6
47
1.92
2.71
20.1
2.25
3.23
0.0
76.6
-29.9
14.0
89.4
-63.8
10.7
11.2
48
1.20
1.70
50.1
1.48
1.99
11.1
54.1
-29.6
24.6
82.2
-39.0
13.8
24.9
49
1.24
1.80
47.7
1.41
2.06
11.9
55.5
-13.7
42.3
85.3
-32.0
12.5
28.6
50
1.18
1.62
51.5
1.21
1.66
26.6
63.7
-22.6
20.1
69.7
-11.6
46.3
36.1
Avg
1.46
2.11
39.1
1.82
2.61
8.1
63.6
-25.6
25.0
81.4
-34.3
20.8
23.3
Detailed Results for Rank 24¶
Team: Dept. of
Photogrammetry
Affiliation: University of Bonn, Germany
Submitted on: 2010-10-19
Femur bone
Tibia bone
Femur cartilage
Tibia cartilage
Test case
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
AvgD [mm]
RMSD [mm]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
VOE [%]
VD [%]
Scr
Total Scr
1
1.65
2.22
32.9
1.28
1.84
20.7
40.5
45.9
31.0
42.2
-5.1
71.4
39.0
2
1.51
2.25
35.4
2.20
2.97
0.0
44.5
-19.1
34.9
37.4
26.1
33.5
25.9
3
1.99
2.92
15.5
3.06
4.40
0.0
43.9
13.7
47.7
63.6
116.2
22.0
21.3
4
1.57
2.21
34.8
1.64
2.62
0.0
56.2
17.2
33.7
30.9
3.4
79.7
37.1
5
1.77
2.35
28.4
2.68
4.34
0.0
43.2
4.7
68.8
48.8
21.2
36.5
33.4
6
1.60
2.22
34.0
1.37
2.01
14.4
45.3
34.8
28.7
45.0
25.1
30.4
26.9
7
2.23
3.27
5.5
2.28
3.27
0.0
48.4
18.5
34.4
54.9
85.5
25.8
16.4
8
1.80
2.49
25.8
2.03
2.99
0.0
69.4
-56.1
17.4
57.9
104.2
24.5
16.9
9
2.56
3.57
0.0
2.69
3.92
0.0
55.6
-11.1
48.2
64.0
60.0
21.8
17.5
10
1.87
2.55
23.4
2.19
2.89
0.0
39.8
-35.0
31.3
55.1
74.7
25.8
20.1
11
2.18
2.94
11.2
1.65
2.27
2.7
58.3
11.0
47.1
61.3
118.1
23.0
21.0
12
2.10
3.62
4.8
2.08
3.36
0.0
57.0
28.1
23.2
61.3
57.2
23.0
12.7
13
1.96
2.69
19.6
1.84
2.83
0.0
63.5
146.9
20.2
90.6
-39.0
10.1
12.5
14
1.71
2.44
28.5
1.58
2.31
1.9
54.5
101.4
24.4
67.8
-50.0
20.1
18.7
15
2.33
3.40
1.8
2.23
3.11
0.0
60.8
-34.1
21.4
64.1
123.2
21.8
11.2
16
2.64
3.82
0.0
2.47
4.42
0.0
79.6
-16.6
24.1
65.3
34.5
21.2
11.3
17
1.92
2.56
22.2
2.07
3.03
0.0
53.0
52.1
25.1
55.4
4.7
66.3
28.4
18
1.76
2.70
23.9
2.35
4.07
0.0
51.8
82.7
25.7
78.4
-71.2
15.5
16.2
19
1.51
2.16
36.9
0.97
1.53
36.9
46.4
43.2
28.2
46.9
54.7
29.3
32.8
20
2.27
3.34
3.5
1.99
2.85
0.0
60.9
-4.8
60.4
50.6
44.9
27.7
22.9
21
1.19
1.81
48.7
2.49
4.43
0.0
54.7
23.5
24.3
67.2
-28.8
20.4
23.3
22
1.93
2.86
17.7
2.48
3.67
0.0
55.2
66.8
24.1
84.6
-78.0
12.8
13.6
23
2.08
2.98
12.9
3.09
4.42
0.0
50.2
-17.3
36.4
66.3
72.5
20.8
17.5
24
2.34
3.30
3.1
2.32
3.46
0.0
45.5
35.7
28.6
52.7
18.2
40.7
18.1
25
2.04
2.99
13.6
2.20
3.11
0.0
34.0
28.5
34.0
56.5
50.3
25.1
18.2
26
1.86
2.53
24.1
1.93
3.22
0.0
44.3
9.3
57.7
46.1
45.6
29.7
27.9
27
1.59
2.33
32.7
2.07
3.07
0.0
60.4
-19.0
27.6
51.3
86.6
27.4
21.9
28
4.03
5.97
0.0
1.92
2.68
0.0
65.3
0.2
68.9
43.2
37.1
31.0
25.0
29
1.18
1.78
49.4
2.97
4.50
0.0
57.2
31.2
23.1
68.7
30.5
19.8
23.1
30
2.09
3.01
12.3
1.57
2.57
0.0
52.1
16.0
38.5
68.0
21.3
27.8
19.6
31
3.54
4.97
0.0
1.85
3.05
0.0
58.9
-13.5
41.2
51.8
40.5
27.2
17.1
32
1.38
2.00
41.9
1.08
1.56
33.1
44.6
51.1
29.0
58.0
47.4
24.5
32.1
33
2.09
3.25
8.9
1.54
2.83
0.7
59.3
-12.8
42.4
59.7
83.1
23.7
18.9
34
1.64
2.38
30.7
1.98
2.80
0.0
58.1
-25.7
22.7
59.7
118.9
23.7
19.3
35
1.76
2.45
27.3
1.71
2.52
0.0
66.4
-45.3
18.8
44.1
11.6
57.6
25.9
36
1.48
2.54
32.1
1.35
2.02
14.8
42.2
53.8
30.2
71.9
-63.8
18.4
23.9
37
4.33
6.16
0.0
5.44
7.62
0.0
77.1
33.1
13.7
100.0
-100.0
6.0
4.9
38
2.46
3.72
0.0
1.74
2.55
0.0
53.6
-9.9
52.0
61.6
144.1
22.9
18.7
39
2.56
3.42
1.4
3.46
4.82
0.0
59.6
2.0
67.3
60.5
109.7
23.4
23.0
40
3.64
5.56
0.0
4.25
6.88
0.0
52.2
28.9
25.5
66.8
94.8
20.6
11.5
41
2.80
3.60
0.0
1.97
2.65
0.0
64.0
-57.6
19.9
61.4
102.5
23.0
10.7
42
2.40
3.41
1.5
2.99
4.14
0.0
74.2
-46.6
15.2
65.9
118.8
21.0
9.4
43
2.12
3.00
11.7
2.14
2.87
0.0
62.4
-18.3
28.4
50.4
12.5
52.9
23.3
44
1.73
2.54
26.5
1.95
2.98
0.0
61.4
62.4
21.2
86.4
-86.4
12.0
14.9
45
1.63
2.46
30.0
1.40
2.23
8.7
59.6
15.1
37.0
68.3
71.9
19.9
23.9
46
2.48
3.44
1.1
1.92
3.59
0.0
61.2
18.8
27.6
61.1
75.6
23.1
13.0
47
1.87
2.44
24.9
1.72
2.27
2.6
78.9
-56.2
12.9
60.2
102.4
23.5
16.0
48
1.60
2.37
31.8
1.11
1.65
30.0
44.3
13.3
48.5
49.5
17.8
42.8
38.3
49
2.42
3.42
1.5
3.50
5.17
0.0
57.6
30.5
22.9
78.0
14.0
38.0
15.6
50
2.07
2.90
14.2
3.16
4.73
0.0
55.3
53.9
24.0
91.3
-82.1
9.8
12.0
Avg
2.11
3.03
17.8
2.20
3.30
3.3
55.7
13.5
32.8
61.1
37.5
28.0
20.5