This challenge is closed. You can no longer submit results. You can no longer download the data.

Results

This table lists the overall results of the 24 methods. Detailed scores per method can be found in the subsequent tables. The SKI10 Zenodo repository contains papers describing many of the submitted methods. Search for papers with the same dates as the submissions.

Rank	Team	Submission Date	Avg Bone Score	Avg Cart Score	Avg Total Score
1	ZIB	2017-11-27	77.88	73.60	75.73
2	AMC_MIRL	2017-03-20	78.28	69.85	74.06
3	Imorphics	2011-01-27	77.01	67.35	72.17
4	ZIB	2010-11-09	72.42	65.99	69.22
5	UPMC_IBML	2013-12-17	68.25	64.32	66.29
6	SNU_SPL	2011-06-09	67.14	61.57	64.34
7	Biomediq	2015-23-03	62.49	66.10	64.29
8	UPMC_IBML	2013-05-17	67.11	60.15	63.63
9	shan_unc	2013-08-13	64.02	61.47	62.74
10	AMC_MIRL	2016-07-26	65.57	58.37	61.98
11	UIiibiKnee	2010-10-19	62.12	61.47	61.79
12	shan_unc	2012-08-03	61.23	61.14	61.19
13	SRIB-HME	2018-08-20	55.79	65.49	60.64
14	BioMedIA	2013-07-22	51.75	64.88	58.31
15	UPMC_IBML	2012-08-24	54.97	58.36	56.66
16	BioMedIA	2013-02-25	50.77	62.33	56.55
17	shan_unc	2012-04-28	48.13	62.03	55.09
18	SNU_SPL	2010-06-23	49.69	58.97	54.33
19	UIiibiKnee	2013-04-09	49.25	50.02	49.63
20	Quan Wang	2013-11-26	22.53	59.31	40.91
21	fractal	2016-09-27	2.46	59.94	31.20
22	sas_twente	2012-02-09	16.26	30.61	23.44
23	Local Regressors	2010-11-24	23.60	22.90	23.25
24	Dept. of Photogrammetry	2010-10-19	10.54	30.39	20.46

Detailed Results for Rank 1

Team: ZIB
Affiliation: Zuse Institute Berlin, Germany
Submitted on: 2017-11-27

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.32	0.55	85.2	0.37	0.57	76.4	15.7	-2.5	86.8	11.2	-2.7	89.7	84.5
2	0.40	0.62	82.6	0.52	0.80	66.8	14.9	-5.7	79.8	15.4	0.8	91.7	80.2
3	0.40	0.65	82.3	0.36	0.53	77.6	21.1	9.3	68.5	21.7	1.2	88.0	79.1
4	0.63	0.90	73.6	0.44	0.72	70.8	20.2	-1.1	88.0	21.5	-11.9	66.9	74.8
5	0.35	0.60	83.9	0.29	0.48	80.7	12.6	3.0	87.2	18.6	-9.5	72.9	81.2
6	0.40	0.68	81.9	0.34	0.54	77.9	17.0	12.1	64.0	20.6	-2.9	85.2	77.2
7	0.51	0.84	77.0	0.44	0.70	71.3	16.6	-6.5	77.2	12.8	10.8	72.9	74.6
8	0.44	0.75	79.8	0.30	0.52	79.6	12.9	-8.6	73.9	12.5	-9.4	75.8	77.3
9	0.48	0.83	77.9	0.33	0.57	77.4	18.4	-11.9	63.8	22.4	-5.6	79.1	74.5
10	0.58	1.05	72.6	0.38	0.66	74.0	16.4	-12.6	63.1	14.5	-11.3	71.1	70.2
11	0.42	0.76	80.1	0.43	0.77	70.2	14.2	0.1	93.0	14.6	1.7	90.3	83.4
12	0.29	0.54	86.1	0.28	0.45	81.8	16.0	1.0	90.2	14.7	4.0	85.5	85.9
13	0.57	0.96	74.1	0.45	0.73	70.5	21.2	13.5	58.7	21.2	11.7	67.5	67.7
14	0.38	0.64	82.8	0.31	0.50	79.8	19.9	15.7	54.4	15.7	13.7	65.8	70.7
15	0.28	0.46	87.5	0.35	0.61	76.0	18.0	4.5	81.1	20.9	-2.4	86.0	82.6
16	0.28	0.45	87.5	0.28	0.45	81.6	13.3	1.2	91.0	15.4	3.7	85.9	86.5
17	0.48	0.81	78.2	0.32	0.51	79.1	19.2	15.2	55.9	36.0	-28.2	34.2	61.9
18	0.28	0.48	87.1	0.29	0.49	80.6	13.2	-5.5	81.2	17.1	6.6	79.3	82.1
19	0.30	0.51	86.3	0.39	0.62	74.4	15.1	1.1	90.5	22.9	-12.3	65.5	79.2
20	0.45	0.74	79.9	0.33	0.55	78.0	17.6	-0.1	91.5	18.1	-13.5	65.2	78.6
21	0.28	0.48	87.2	0.28	0.46	81.6	15.5	-2.1	87.9	13.8	-11.4	71.3	82.0
22	0.41	0.62	82.5	0.38	0.62	75.1	18.2	1.0	89.0	11.9	-9.1	76.8	80.8
23	0.40	0.68	81.6	0.44	0.68	71.7	18.8	-2.1	86.3	29.3	18.8	49.9	72.4
24	0.36	0.61	83.6	0.31	0.51	79.6	15.7	-3.9	83.5	16.4	-12.5	68.1	78.7
25	0.43	0.72	80.7	0.42	0.69	72.2	20.8	2.5	84.5	29.4	14.7	57.8	73.8
26	0.39	0.63	82.6	0.29	0.52	79.9	11.3	-1.0	92.4	22.2	-16.9	56.7	77.9
27	0.37	0.60	83.5	0.40	0.68	73.2	27.3	-5.0	75.7	11.5	-1.3	92.4	81.2
28	0.82	1.75	57.4	0.43	0.65	72.7	26.2	0.8	85.9	18.5	-13.4	65.3	70.3
29	0.35	0.57	84.4	0.39	0.60	74.9	16.9	-6.7	76.6	17.3	3.6	85.2	80.3
30	0.36	0.57	84.2	0.31	0.51	79.4	22.1	-7.9	71.4	27.3	-10.8	66.5	75.4
31	0.67	1.08	70.1	0.47	0.73	69.5	23.1	-1.4	86.0	26.6	16.7	55.2	70.2
32	0.38	0.62	83.0	0.28	0.45	81.7	19.2	6.3	76.5	22.0	12.1	66.3	76.9
33	0.29	0.51	86.5	0.31	0.58	77.9	17.1	-3.8	83.1	18.8	-16.4	59.2	76.7
34	0.41	0.98	77.2	0.28	0.50	80.6	31.0	39.9	35.4	14.5	-2.4	88.8	70.5
35	0.41	0.72	81.0	0.37	0.62	75.2	18.8	13.0	61.0	19.5	-16.0	59.7	69.2
36	0.27	0.47	87.6	0.33	0.52	78.7	12.8	-4.7	83.2	12.1	5.7	83.4	83.2
37	0.81	1.63	59.3	0.58	0.93	61.9	22.9	16.7	50.5	32.8	34.1	35.6	51.8
38	0.29	0.50	86.7	0.33	0.55	77.9	10.5	2.0	90.4	15.2	5.0	83.4	84.6
39	0.42	0.73	80.4	0.89	1.85	32.8	21.6	11.9	62.3	35.4	-0.1	84.2	64.9
40	0.34	0.54	85.1	0.34	0.56	77.3	16.1	1.7	88.4	16.5	7.3	78.3	82.3
41	0.44	0.70	80.5	0.42	0.70	72.0	18.5	-17.3	51.4	10.0	2.7	90.3	73.5
42	0.51	0.81	77.5	0.43	0.69	71.7	24.1	14.1	56.1	30.8	5.9	74.8	70.0
43	0.42	0.65	81.7	0.30	0.49	80.0	22.1	-1.5	86.2	11.4	-8.7	77.6	81.4
44	0.44	0.68	81.0	0.43	0.69	71.9	37.2	-9.0	61.8	30.5	-29.8	36.6	62.8
45	0.25	0.44	88.3	0.21	0.37	85.6	22.0	12.2	61.4	18.0	7.6	77.1	78.1
46	0.38	0.59	83.5	0.26	0.44	82.5	23.9	9.6	66.4	17.4	-7.8	76.9	77.3
47	1.29	1.62	49.2	0.65	0.86	61.5	65.8	4.8	58.0	32.7	-4.1	77.4	61.5
48	0.32	0.53	85.7	0.35	0.58	76.6	16.9	-4.9	80.8	16.0	-7.2	78.7	80.5
49	0.43	0.69	80.9	0.34	0.56	77.2	21.9	20.2	42.9	23.1	20.3	49.6	62.6
50	0.28	0.48	87.0	0.24	0.42	83.5	14.0	2.6	87.3	18.9	-7.7	76.4	83.6
Avg	0.43	0.72	80.5	0.37	0.62	75.2	19.7	2.2	74.8	19.8	-1.5	72.4	75.7

Detailed Results for Rank 2

Team: AMC_MIRL
Affiliation: Biomedical Engineering Center / Asan Medical Center, Korea Republic of
Submitted on: 2017-03-20

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.33	0.69	83.0	0.36	0.56	76.8	19.4	0.7	89.2	18.3	-3.5	85.0	83.5
2	0.39	0.57	83.5	0.49	0.74	68.8	22.5	-19.5	44.3	18.4	-13.8	64.5	65.3
3	0.32	0.53	85.5	0.28	0.44	81.8	19.9	5.0	79.1	27.9	8.9	70.1	79.1
4	0.37	0.58	83.9	0.28	0.46	81.4	22.2	-8.6	69.6	17.2	-10.0	72.7	76.9
5	0.38	0.60	83.3	0.27	0.45	82.1	16.8	-9.0	71.2	21.7	-9.3	72.0	77.1
6	0.32	0.51	86.0	0.29	0.51	80.1	19.7	8.7	70.6	17.9	2.6	86.9	80.9
7	0.42	0.68	81.4	0.44	0.71	71.2	23.5	-14.7	55.0	15.2	9.3	74.9	70.6
8	0.42	0.69	81.1	0.27	0.45	82.0	22.9	-17.6	48.4	16.9	-13.5	65.8	69.3
9	0.46	1.50	68.9	0.34	0.69	74.8	22.9	-17.7	48.2	20.7	-3.7	83.6	68.9
10	0.49	0.87	77.2	0.31	0.56	78.5	21.7	-15.0	55.1	17.4	-15.1	62.4	68.3
11	0.43	0.89	78.0	0.31	0.58	77.9	20.7	8.6	70.3	21.9	-3.3	83.9	77.5
12	0.29	0.50	86.6	0.24	0.39	84.4	19.2	-3.6	82.7	21.6	13.9	62.8	79.1
13	0.55	0.91	75.3	0.43	0.67	72.2	30.5	21.6	35.6	34.1	7.0	71.1	63.6
14	0.32	0.51	85.8	0.27	0.43	82.4	25.0	21.2	39.3	16.3	12.8	67.5	68.8
15	0.24	0.41	89.2	0.28	0.52	80.1	20.8	7.3	73.3	18.6	10.5	71.1	78.4
16	0.30	0.47	86.8	0.20	0.33	86.9	24.1	2.1	83.7	21.9	1.7	87.0	86.1
17	0.58	0.90	74.6	0.36	0.55	77.1	26.9	5.5	74.5	30.2	-11.3	64.3	72.6
18	0.26	0.42	88.6	0.27	0.44	82.2	17.0	-4.9	80.5	21.0	10.0	70.9	80.6
19	0.28	0.47	87.4	0.36	0.59	76.1	18.4	3.5	83.3	22.6	-5.2	79.7	81.6
20	0.52	1.25	71.1	0.27	0.44	82.1	20.7	-0.7	88.7	22.3	-6.8	76.7	79.6
21	0.28	0.45	87.5	0.30	0.50	80.0	23.7	-9.7	66.3	20.3	-17.9	55.6	72.4
22	0.49	0.74	79.0	0.29	0.49	80.6	20.7	-0.5	89.2	15.7	-10.7	71.7	80.1
23	0.41	0.82	79.5	0.41	0.65	73.3	20.0	-3.5	82.5	34.4	40.9	34.9	67.5
24	0.34	0.54	85.1	0.29	0.47	80.8	19.9	7.8	72.7	16.5	-1.6	89.6	82.0
25	0.43	0.68	81.0	0.41	0.64	73.6	25.7	4.2	78.1	37.0	22.5	39.0	67.9
26	0.36	0.57	84.1	0.29	0.50	80.2	18.0	-12.1	63.6	23.9	-18.9	51.9	69.9
27	0.31	0.49	86.3	0.34	0.58	77.0	27.1	-5.1	75.5	24.3	-9.8	69.9	77.2
28	0.81	2.21	51.1	0.31	0.51	79.3	28.5	4.6	75.9	18.6	-8.9	74.1	70.1
29	0.34	0.52	85.4	0.34	0.54	77.9	23.0	-16.6	50.7	21.3	-0.4	89.9	76.0
30	0.31	0.49	86.4	0.29	0.49	80.4	24.2	-10.7	63.8	26.5	5.0	78.3	77.2
31	0.58	0.87	75.1	0.75	1.57	43.3	29.3	-6.3	71.6	29.4	2.1	82.9	68.2
32	0.35	0.55	84.6	0.28	0.43	82.0	20.4	10.1	67.1	21.5	9.1	72.5	76.5
33	0.37	0.54	84.4	0.36	0.55	77.2	22.5	-3.9	80.4	23.4	-18.4	53.2	73.8
34	0.41	0.98	77.1	0.21	0.37	85.5	29.1	29.4	36.3	17.3	5.0	82.4	70.3
35	0.35	0.56	84.6	0.32	0.55	78.3	20.8	0.1	90.0	21.6	-6.9	76.7	82.4
36	0.27	0.45	87.9	0.26	0.45	82.3	12.1	-4.5	83.9	13.7	1.9	90.2	86.1
37	0.91	2.04	51.4	1.09	2.53	15.1	20.5	15.3	55.0	33.9	33.7	35.1	39.2
38	0.26	0.42	88.3	0.26	0.42	82.9	15.1	-0.4	91.9	18.3	-1.4	89.2	88.1
39	0.42	0.68	81.3	1.64	3.59	0.0	33.6	-6.4	69.3	29.0	15.3	56.8	51.9
40	0.31	0.48	86.6	0.31	0.52	79.1	17.3	4.5	81.4	25.9	23.3	42.4	72.4
41	0.51	0.74	78.5	0.35	0.55	77.2	27.2	-26.3	37.2	21.2	6.0	78.8	67.9
42	0.45	0.66	81.0	0.40	0.63	74.2	29.0	2.4	80.8	23.0	15.3	59.6	73.9
43	0.34	0.52	85.3	0.27	0.41	82.9	26.1	1.4	84.5	19.6	-17.8	56.0	77.2
44	0.44	0.63	81.6	0.41	0.67	72.8	37.4	-0.3	81.7	19.5	-13.6	64.4	75.1
45	0.24	0.40	89.2	0.20	0.34	86.6	22.6	16.2	52.0	27.0	20.6	47.2	68.7
46	0.33	0.49	86.0	0.26	0.44	82.3	26.6	6.4	72.8	17.5	-1.7	89.0	82.5
47	1.07	1.34	57.8	0.57	0.75	66.1	62.3	-3.9	61.6	26.6	1.1	86.1	67.9
48	0.27	0.46	87.7	0.34	0.53	78.2	16.9	0.1	91.8	19.5	-8.3	75.0	83.2
49	0.43	0.65	81.6	0.31	0.69	75.7	25.7	11.2	62.0	22.7	15.6	59.0	69.6
50	0.28	0.46	87.4	0.23	0.39	84.6	20.0	-13.6	59.2	20.4	-1.0	89.1	80.1
Avg	0.41	0.71	81.2	0.37	0.64	75.4	23.6	-0.7	69.4	22.2	1.2	70.3	74.1

Detailed Results for Rank 3

Team: Imorphics
Affiliation: Imorphics Ltd, United Kingdom
Submitted on: 2011-01-27

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.30	0.53	86.0	0.30	0.51	79.9	11.7	-6.0	80.6	13.8	-5.6	82.8	82.3
2	0.44	0.68	80.9	0.35	0.58	76.7	22.9	-16.8	50.3	18.9	-15.3	61.4	67.3
3	0.33	0.55	85.1	0.23	0.39	84.4	18.4	7.5	73.9	23.6	5.2	79.2	80.6
4	0.46	0.71	80.1	0.38	0.59	75.5	33.3	-13.3	53.6	45.9	-35.1	29.8	59.8
5	0.33	0.61	84.1	0.33	0.62	76.6	15.7	0.6	91.2	19.1	-5.4	80.9	83.2
6	0.51	1.03	74.5	0.36	0.71	73.6	24.2	-1.4	85.5	19.6	-4.4	82.6	79.0
7	0.44	0.73	80.1	0.52	0.98	62.9	23.6	-17.9	47.5	15.9	0.9	91.3	70.4
8	0.51	0.94	75.6	0.34	0.65	75.6	27.0	-21.4	37.7	21.2	-15.3	60.3	62.3
9	0.50	0.92	76.1	0.38	0.65	74.1	31.0	-15.3	50.0	35.8	-17.5	49.6	62.5
10	0.60	1.08	71.8	0.39	0.71	72.9	27.5	-23.1	37.1	34.3	-28.3	34.9	54.2
11	0.42	0.81	79.3	0.36	0.74	72.9	16.1	-6.0	78.6	17.4	1.4	89.5	80.1
12	0.24	0.46	88.2	0.23	0.42	83.8	19.3	-8.7	70.7	18.8	3.2	85.3	82.0
13	0.68	1.30	67.0	0.61	1.25	54.6	31.9	21.5	35.3	30.5	17.1	52.6	52.4
14	0.34	0.54	85.1	0.32	0.59	77.3	25.6	10.3	64.2	17.1	6.3	80.0	76.6
15	0.23	0.41	89.2	0.27	0.50	81.1	18.2	3.6	83.0	18.0	-5.9	80.4	83.4
16	0.28	0.53	86.4	0.26	0.50	81.3	16.8	-9.4	70.3	14.8	2.2	89.1	81.8
17	0.74	1.23	66.6	0.36	0.67	74.4	33.0	-0.7	82.8	38.6	-29.7	33.0	64.2
18	0.30	0.54	85.9	0.43	0.78	69.9	18.3	-9.0	70.6	19.0	5.0	81.8	77.0
19	0.26	0.49	87.4	0.32	0.59	77.4	15.3	-2.6	86.8	24.6	-12.5	64.3	79.0
20	0.41	0.71	81.1	0.33	0.64	76.0	17.7	-2.4	86.0	21.1	-6.8	77.2	80.1
21	0.28	0.46	87.5	0.32	0.54	78.4	25.4	-15.9	51.2	21.2	-20.0	50.9	67.0
22	0.38	0.59	83.4	0.44	0.77	69.8	24.4	-12.8	58.9	16.6	-13.2	66.4	69.6
23	0.42	0.67	81.5	0.62	1.11	56.9	23.0	-3.7	80.6	39.8	43.3	32.5	62.9
24	0.42	0.74	80.4	0.35	0.62	75.9	20.8	-10.4	66.2	18.1	-10.0	72.1	73.6
25	0.63	1.40	66.5	0.66	1.25	52.9	24.5	-1.5	85.1	28.1	-2.7	82.2	71.7
26	0.41	0.73	80.9	0.30	0.60	77.9	17.4	-11.6	64.9	19.8	-15.2	61.0	71.2
27	0.41	0.65	81.8	0.38	0.70	73.3	44.4	-18.3	36.8	24.1	-12.9	63.8	63.9
28	0.59	1.63	64.1	0.37	0.58	76.0	21.8	0.8	87.9	30.7	-25.3	36.5	66.1
29	0.37	0.62	83.3	0.34	0.57	77.1	24.6	-17.4	48.1	31.0	-13.1	60.4	67.2
30	0.36	0.63	83.3	0.52	1.14	59.8	22.9	-13.1	58.9	30.7	-6.7	73.3	68.8
31	0.55	0.88	75.7	0.43	0.71	71.4	29.1	-3.3	78.7	37.0	14.7	54.6	70.1
32	0.40	0.67	81.9	0.28	0.47	81.0	27.6	0.4	86.2	23.4	15.7	58.5	76.9
33	0.28	0.51	86.6	0.29	0.55	79.1	21.3	-12.3	61.4	19.0	-12.6	66.7	73.5
34	0.36	0.99	78.3	0.24	0.44	83.1	31.3	30.3	35.3	13.8	6.0	82.1	69.7
35	0.39	0.70	81.6	0.38	0.78	71.5	19.9	6.4	75.7	19.5	-11.8	68.0	74.2
36	0.27	0.47	87.6	0.28	0.50	80.7	14.7	-7.8	75.0	10.7	-5.0	85.3	82.1
37	0.62	1.07	71.5	0.77	1.39	46.3	23.2	4.5	78.7	40.6	34.1	32.1	57.1
38	0.36	0.67	82.7	0.28	0.50	80.5	15.1	-5.4	80.4	16.2	0.7	91.4	83.8
39	0.49	0.93	76.1	0.77	1.32	48.0	26.5	0.7	85.9	26.0	20.7	47.5	64.4
40	0.27	0.48	87.3	0.36	0.73	73.3	14.3	-7.7	75.5	16.6	-4.0	84.7	80.2
41	0.48	0.77	78.9	0.37	0.64	74.7	23.0	-21.6	39.2	16.7	-2.3	88.1	70.2
42	0.43	0.66	81.3	0.30	0.47	80.4	24.9	11.7	61.1	25.8	11.3	66.1	72.3
43	0.36	0.59	84.0	0.33	0.54	78.2	27.9	-0.7	85.2	18.9	-16.0	60.0	76.8
44	0.38	0.59	83.5	0.42	0.75	71.0	26.5	-4.4	77.5	20.5	-2.6	85.9	79.4
45	0.24	0.48	87.9	0.21	0.40	84.8	26.8	-5.2	75.4	23.9	16.7	56.4	76.1
46	0.39	0.66	82.3	0.30	0.51	80.0	26.2	-4.3	77.7	24.8	-19.0	51.4	72.8
47	1.20	1.47	53.3	0.58	0.77	65.3	66.8	-4.3	58.7	34.4	-14.8	55.5	58.2
48	0.31	0.55	85.6	0.43	0.81	69.4	17.6	-6.2	77.5	18.0	-6.7	78.9	77.8
49	0.36	0.59	83.8	0.24	0.40	84.0	21.4	11.4	63.7	17.6	17.1	58.4	72.5
50	0.25	0.46	88.0	0.30	0.57	78.6	16.2	-9.1	71.2	19.7	-3.7	83.9	80.4
Avg	0.42	0.74	80.4	0.38	0.68	73.6	23.9	-4.8	67.9	23.4	-3.6	66.8	72.2

Detailed Results for Rank 4

Team: ZIB
Affiliation: Zuse Institute Berlin, Germany
Submitted on: 2010-11-09

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.53	0.79	77.3	0.52	0.81	66.6	18.5	-4.6	80.7	22.8	-13.1	63.9	72.1
2	0.46	0.67	80.6	0.47	0.65	71.5	26.4	-17.9	46.1	18.4	-12.1	67.9	66.5
3	0.63	0.90	73.7	0.42	0.65	73.1	25.1	14.2	55.3	19.9	-4.0	83.3	71.4
4	0.53	0.76	77.7	0.42	0.59	74.3	32.9	0.3	83.8	20.9	-11.0	69.0	76.2
5	0.48	0.73	79.3	0.39	0.59	75.2	20.8	16.9	51.1	22.9	-12.6	64.9	67.6
6	0.69	1.07	69.9	0.41	0.67	72.8	33.4	36.5	34.3	27.5	-10.3	67.6	61.1
7	0.49	0.79	78.0	0.52	0.75	67.7	21.7	-3.1	82.6	18.5	13.3	65.5	73.5
8	0.75	1.27	65.7	0.46	0.70	70.8	21.9	-13.3	58.9	26.7	-18.0	52.6	62.0
9	0.59	0.89	74.7	0.44	0.69	71.4	27.4	-13.7	55.3	27.0	-15.0	58.3	65.0
10	0.59	0.95	73.7	0.43	0.68	72.2	19.4	-13.2	60.4	30.2	-28.9	36.7	60.7
11	0.53	0.84	76.6	0.44	0.76	70.1	19.5	-2.6	84.7	29.1	-7.4	72.5	76.0
12	0.41	0.68	81.4	0.36	0.52	77.7	17.7	3.6	83.5	22.4	16.5	57.4	75.0
13	0.75	1.21	66.7	0.58	0.91	62.4	36.3	12.5	54.1	36.2	44.4	34.1	54.3
14	0.58	0.89	74.8	0.45	0.70	71.2	26.1	9.3	66.3	14.9	7.0	79.6	73.0
15	0.48	0.70	79.8	0.46	0.74	69.8	20.5	5.4	77.8	25.4	7.2	74.5	75.5
16	0.47	0.74	79.4	0.35	0.51	78.2	20.2	8.4	71.1	23.3	-3.0	83.7	78.1
17	0.54	0.89	75.7	0.41	0.61	74.0	27.9	21.0	38.2	24.8	-16.8	55.8	60.9
18	0.50	0.75	78.6	0.37	0.56	76.6	22.5	4.0	80.1	24.6	1.3	86.7	80.5
19	0.53	0.83	76.8	0.53	0.86	65.0	22.8	14.9	54.8	25.7	-14.4	60.1	64.2
20	0.66	0.92	72.7	0.47	0.72	69.9	26.7	7.2	70.9	38.4	-35.0	33.1	61.6
21	0.45	0.71	80.1	0.36	0.59	76.1	24.3	4.6	77.9	18.2	-4.9	82.3	79.1
22	0.51	0.82	77.4	0.37	0.60	75.7	25.2	6.1	73.9	13.2	-2.7	88.9	79.0
23	0.58	0.85	75.5	0.62	0.97	59.9	28.8	17.8	45.3	36.6	3.8	76.4	64.3
24	0.49	0.75	78.8	0.43	0.68	72.1	24.0	1.5	85.3	16.3	-1.4	90.1	81.6
25	0.59	0.87	74.9	0.60	1.05	58.8	20.7	0.6	88.8	20.0	5.7	79.8	75.6
26	0.61	0.92	73.8	0.42	0.68	72.5	18.3	-3.5	83.4	23.0	14.4	61.3	72.8
27	0.59	0.84	75.4	0.50	0.73	68.8	36.4	-8.9	62.3	31.9	-14.6	57.1	65.9
28	0.68	1.15	69.0	0.43	0.70	71.6	27.4	3.9	78.1	16.3	-6.9	79.1	74.5
29	0.53	0.83	76.8	0.43	0.67	72.3	17.6	-1.1	89.2	26.5	10.4	67.7	76.5
30	0.65	0.96	72.3	0.45	0.73	70.3	27.1	13.5	55.9	38.1	-22.2	39.1	59.4
31	0.62	0.94	73.4	0.43	0.66	72.3	32.4	7.7	67.0	27.9	0.8	86.1	74.7
32	0.48	0.71	79.6	0.44	0.63	72.7	31.9	7.0	68.8	30.0	18.9	49.3	67.6
33	0.47	0.74	79.4	0.43	0.69	72.1	20.9	-9.2	68.8	25.0	0.5	88.0	77.1
34	0.65	1.27	68.0	0.35	0.53	77.5	39.4	56.8	31.5	17.4	9.5	73.5	62.6
35	0.57	0.92	74.6	0.61	1.06	58.2	25.6	7.8	69.9	29.3	-25.2	37.2	60.0
36	0.51	0.76	78.2	0.38	0.58	75.6	15.2	-2.7	86.7	21.8	-12.0	66.6	76.8
37	0.79	1.43	62.7	0.58	0.99	60.8	25.2	6.5	73.1	30.8	17.5	51.7	62.1
38	0.48	0.73	79.3	0.36	0.58	76.3	17.6	4.4	81.7	19.4	8.6	74.3	77.9
39	0.64	1.01	72.0	0.97	1.79	31.7	37.5	4.0	73.2	45.3	-15.4	49.5	56.6
40	0.47	0.71	79.9	0.44	0.67	71.8	18.1	1.3	88.4	24.8	16.3	56.8	74.2
41	0.65	0.97	72.3	0.49	0.77	68.2	23.7	-14.5	55.2	20.8	-8.8	73.3	67.3
42	0.53	0.76	77.8	0.55	0.77	66.4	33.3	33.3	34.3	41.4	9.6	62.7	60.3
43	0.56	0.85	75.8	0.51	0.76	67.8	28.4	2.0	81.9	19.9	-9.3	72.9	74.6
44	0.71	1.19	67.9	0.63	1.01	58.9	32.4	-7.8	66.6	39.2	-38.0	32.8	56.5
45	0.46	0.69	80.4	0.34	0.52	78.3	26.5	6.5	72.6	23.5	17.6	54.7	71.5
46	0.53	0.82	76.9	0.46	0.76	69.4	33.6	4.2	74.5	27.3	-15.8	56.7	69.4
47	1.08	1.36	57.5	0.73	0.98	56.2	62.2	9.3	49.2	33.0	-0.9	83.8	61.7
48	0.55	0.80	76.8	0.49	0.78	68.2	23.3	7.0	72.9	27.8	-15.2	57.6	68.9
49	0.47	0.73	79.5	0.39	0.55	76.0	34.4	33.5	33.8	27.3	17.7	52.9	60.6
50	0.52	0.79	77.6	0.33	0.51	79.0	19.5	13.5	59.6	17.3	-1.3	89.8	76.5
Avg	0.57	0.88	75.1	0.47	0.73	69.7	26.4	5.8	66.8	25.8	-3.1	65.2	69.2

Detailed Results for Rank 5

Team: UPMC_IBML
Affiliation: UPMC, United States
Submitted on: 2013-12-17

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.45	0.76	79.5	0.41	0.68	72.7	21.8	-3.6	81.4	22.7	-13.0	64.2	74.5
2	0.71	1.06	69.6	0.77	1.43	45.6	31.7	-28.2	35.1	26.3	-22.5	43.8	48.5
3	0.58	0.89	74.9	0.48	0.94	65.1	25.0	-4.1	78.8	27.9	12.1	63.7	70.7
4	0.57	0.88	75.3	0.41	0.65	73.1	25.5	-3.6	79.6	17.9	-7.0	78.3	76.6
5	0.59	0.98	73.5	0.48	0.83	67.2	25.3	-14.3	54.9	26.5	-14.0	60.5	64.0
6	0.68	1.16	68.8	0.54	0.90	63.8	27.0	2.9	80.5	22.4	-4.4	81.5	73.6
7	0.60	0.89	74.4	0.66	1.06	56.8	24.9	-12.5	59.3	21.6	7.7	75.2	66.4
8	0.77	1.14	67.1	0.45	0.71	70.7	30.6	-26.1	35.6	28.7	-20.8	46.1	54.9
9	0.59	0.91	74.4	0.49	0.84	66.9	27.4	-17.1	47.6	25.4	5.3	78.3	66.8
10	0.69	1.11	69.3	0.47	0.84	67.6	25.6	-20.3	40.9	19.1	-15.2	61.4	59.8
11	0.66	1.11	70.1	0.50	0.91	65.1	18.6	-4.0	82.0	25.4	-2.9	83.1	75.1
12	0.39	0.67	82.0	0.37	0.60	75.6	23.5	-4.8	77.8	41.9	0.4	80.9	79.1
13	0.67	1.14	69.4	0.61	1.07	58.2	35.9	18.6	40.1	28.8	10.6	66.2	58.5
14	0.59	0.98	73.3	0.49	0.76	68.7	27.7	14.1	54.4	17.2	5.5	81.5	69.5
15	0.38	0.60	83.3	0.41	0.71	72.1	23.3	8.7	68.8	25.1	6.0	77.0	75.3
16	0.37	0.58	83.7	0.38	0.65	74.4	23.9	11.3	62.6	26.9	12.0	64.3	71.2
17	0.82	1.23	64.8	0.54	0.83	65.3	33.3	-1.2	81.6	32.0	-18.5	49.3	65.3
18	0.48	0.74	79.3	0.43	0.67	72.2	25.3	-14.3	54.9	21.6	-3.8	83.0	72.3
19	0.68	1.53	63.7	0.45	0.81	68.5	22.0	4.5	79.2	22.7	-12.6	65.0	69.1
20	0.70	1.11	69.1	0.41	0.70	72.1	20.2	3.1	83.4	32.8	-12.0	61.8	71.6
21	0.36	0.59	83.8	0.36	0.60	75.8	25.9	-11.5	61.2	29.4	-26.6	37.1	64.5
22	0.86	1.72	57.1	0.46	0.82	68.2	21.3	-0.9	87.9	20.8	-14.5	62.1	68.8
23	0.62	0.99	72.6	0.62	0.99	59.5	28.5	-4.6	75.9	45.6	26.9	29.9	59.5
24	0.75	1.67	60.0	0.58	0.92	62.4	23.4	-0.5	87.9	28.2	-6.7	74.3	71.1
25	0.57	0.86	75.4	0.55	0.90	63.6	25.5	-0.8	86.1	37.5	16.4	51.0	69.0
26	0.95	1.88	52.8	0.35	0.55	77.4	23.9	-18.4	46.2	26.4	-22.9	43.0	54.8
27	0.55	0.92	75.1	0.55	0.88	64.0	29.8	-11.3	59.9	25.4	-19.1	51.0	62.5
28	0.80	1.77	57.6	0.47	0.72	69.8	26.7	5.5	74.8	28.9	-20.6	46.5	62.2
29	0.68	1.08	70.0	0.50	0.78	67.6	35.8	-31.0	33.2	34.8	-10.1	64.7	58.9
30	0.59	1.02	72.8	0.48	0.88	66.2	28.8	-17.6	45.8	41.3	-10.0	62.0	61.7
31	1.02	1.47	57.1	0.76	1.19	50.8	39.0	-32.1	31.7	29.5	3.2	80.7	55.1
32	0.62	0.96	73.1	0.39	0.58	75.5	25.6	7.1	71.6	29.7	4.2	78.6	74.7
33	0.48	0.79	78.4	0.43	0.72	71.1	22.5	-6.2	75.1	31.8	-9.8	66.5	72.8
34	0.71	1.38	65.1	0.45	0.74	70.2	36.8	44.6	32.7	24.2	-1.5	86.4	63.6
35	0.59	0.95	73.8	0.55	0.95	62.5	26.5	-3.9	78.5	21.5	-11.9	66.9	70.4
36	0.40	0.65	82.1	0.44	0.79	69.4	20.0	-12.6	61.4	20.3	-9.3	72.5	71.4
37	0.91	1.51	59.0	1.18	2.54	12.0	30.8	0.3	84.8	39.8	26.8	32.5	47.1
38	0.52	0.98	74.9	0.34	0.59	76.8	17.0	-8.0	73.4	20.7	-2.1	86.7	78.0
39	0.60	0.97	73.2	1.97	3.50	0.0	31.9	1.3	81.9	29.0	15.8	55.9	52.8
40	0.51	0.80	77.6	0.53	0.84	65.6	27.0	-11.8	60.0	39.3	23.2	36.7	60.0
41	0.84	1.28	63.8	0.54	0.85	65.0	33.0	-31.9	34.5	13.2	-6.3	81.7	61.2
42	0.73	1.15	67.9	0.51	0.86	65.8	47.9	-20.4	30.3	30.9	1.8	82.9	61.7
43	0.76	1.21	66.4	0.52	0.82	66.4	29.6	-0.6	84.7	20.5	-14.9	61.4	69.7
44	0.64	1.02	71.7	0.53	0.83	65.7	35.7	5.9	69.6	25.6	-21.0	47.1	63.5
45	0.37	0.63	83.0	0.35	0.55	77.2	29.1	6.0	72.5	38.5	12.6	58.0	72.7
46	0.53	0.90	75.8	0.35	0.56	77.2	28.5	-1.1	84.0	25.1	-1.5	86.1	80.8
47	1.15	1.48	54.3	0.67	0.93	59.3	68.0	-10.5	43.7	33.6	-10.2	65.0	55.6
48	0.38	0.59	83.4	0.57	0.99	61.1	24.2	-12.7	59.2	24.0	-13.1	63.4	66.8
49	0.58	0.94	74.2	0.37	0.59	75.8	25.1	12.1	60.2	26.8	3.1	82.0	73.0
50	0.54	0.95	74.8	0.43	0.83	68.9	28.0	-20.1	40.2	22.6	1.8	86.5	67.6
Avg	0.63	1.05	71.4	0.53	0.90	65.1	28.3	-5.5	63.3	27.6	-3.7	65.3	66.3

Detailed Results for Rank 6

Team: SNU_SPL
Affiliation: Seoul National University, Korea Republic of
Submitted on: 2011-06-09

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.40	0.67	81.8	0.52	0.81	66.5	20.9	-0.9	88.1	27.4	4.1	79.8	79.0
2	0.65	0.91	73.0	0.51	0.77	67.8	23.7	-15.4	53.1	17.1	-7.8	77.0	67.7
3	0.65	1.02	71.6	0.45	0.70	71.1	33.7	17.9	42.8	38.4	26.5	33.1	54.7
4	0.59	0.87	74.8	0.38	0.61	75.1	27.8	3.2	79.5	22.1	-17.3	55.9	71.3
5	1.25	1.96	45.2	0.43	0.66	72.6	33.3	2.1	79.5	21.6	9.0	72.7	67.5
6	0.84	1.43	61.7	0.55	0.90	63.8	31.8	14.5	51.4	22.8	12.9	64.3	60.3
7	0.70	1.00	70.7	0.61	1.08	57.9	22.8	-8.4	69.7	21.8	0.1	90.2	72.1
8	0.74	1.03	69.5	0.49	0.79	67.9	26.0	-20.0	41.5	31.7	5.0	76.2	63.8
9	0.83	1.20	65.1	0.62	0.88	61.7	25.9	-18.3	45.5	42.5	19.9	41.9	53.5
10	0.83	1.31	63.5	0.52	0.86	65.6	31.2	-22.6	35.4	26.3	15.7	57.3	55.4
11	0.72	1.22	67.2	0.53	0.98	62.6	24.6	-0.0	88.3	31.6	7.4	71.4	72.4
12	0.48	0.81	78.2	0.39	0.63	74.4	31.9	-2.7	78.7	35.5	27.1	34.4	66.4
13	0.93	1.48	59.0	0.61	1.06	58.4	42.8	30.7	29.9	30.4	34.2	36.6	46.0
14	0.62	0.98	72.7	0.57	0.83	64.4	31.5	1.7	81.3	24.2	24.8	40.2	64.6
15	0.45	0.66	81.0	0.41	0.71	72.2	26.7	12.7	58.1	22.5	4.6	80.9	73.1
16	0.56	0.86	75.7	0.39	0.65	73.8	27.2	10.3	63.4	32.8	27.0	35.6	62.1
17	0.82	1.22	65.0	0.52	0.83	66.1	31.8	24.8	35.1	24.4	18.7	52.1	54.5
18	0.48	0.76	78.8	0.46	0.72	70.4	26.9	3.5	79.3	21.4	9.6	71.4	75.0
19	0.49	0.80	78.2	0.43	0.75	70.5	27.7	10.5	62.8	28.9	15.7	56.1	66.9
20	0.69	1.09	69.6	0.56	0.90	63.3	28.1	-11.7	59.8	32.2	5.4	75.1	66.9
21	0.51	0.86	76.9	0.45	0.77	69.4	23.7	0.4	87.8	27.5	0.4	87.1	80.3
22	1.07	1.97	49.1	0.47	0.71	70.1	24.5	-9.3	66.9	24.9	3.0	83.1	67.3
23	0.57	0.91	74.8	0.71	1.18	52.7	27.3	-2.4	81.6	44.9	55.3	30.2	59.8
24	0.71	1.22	67.4	0.47	0.76	69.2	23.8	10.3	64.9	24.4	7.6	74.2	68.9
25	0.74	1.28	65.9	0.69	1.13	54.3	30.6	3.7	77.0	42.3	19.2	43.2	60.1
26	0.89	1.26	62.8	0.46	0.76	69.5	22.0	9.0	68.8	26.4	2.8	82.9	71.0
27	0.63	0.97	72.6	0.49	0.79	68.0	31.7	-4.6	74.5	20.1	-1.1	89.0	76.0
28	0.96	1.79	53.8	0.53	0.83	65.7	32.3	14.7	50.7	22.6	-8.5	73.2	60.9
29	0.58	0.82	75.8	0.43	0.71	71.4	25.0	-8.0	69.7	29.0	19.4	48.8	66.4
30	0.54	0.88	75.9	0.66	1.27	52.2	33.4	2.6	78.4	53.7	-27.4	26.4	58.2
31	1.18	1.82	48.7	0.58	0.88	63.1	35.4	8.5	63.6	25.5	23.9	41.3	54.2
32	0.80	1.27	64.7	0.44	0.66	71.9	26.3	18.0	45.8	28.9	37.5	37.3	54.9
33	0.59	0.89	74.8	0.54	0.83	65.3	37.8	1.1	79.7	35.1	-1.1	82.3	75.5
34	0.56	1.02	73.4	0.46	0.74	69.8	33.6	36.7	34.2	27.5	25.9	37.9	53.8
35	0.65	0.94	72.7	0.56	0.99	61.3	29.0	16.3	48.6	23.6	2.9	83.8	66.6
36	0.44	0.72	80.2	0.52	0.96	63.2	25.7	-5.4	75.4	18.6	-0.2	91.4	77.5
37	0.98	1.52	57.3	0.85	1.46	42.2	31.0	9.3	64.0	41.2	45.6	31.9	48.8
38	0.55	0.95	74.7	0.42	0.71	71.7	24.7	10.4	64.3	27.2	12.5	63.2	68.5
39	0.89	1.33	61.9	1.27	2.39	9.6	33.3	9.1	63.4	46.7	1.0	77.6	53.1
40	0.45	0.72	80.0	0.51	0.81	66.9	25.2	9.8	65.5	38.1	46.5	33.2	61.4
41	0.78	1.14	66.9	0.59	0.90	62.5	23.3	-17.5	48.4	24.3	8.9	71.6	62.4
42	0.69	0.94	71.7	0.53	0.84	65.5	41.7	19.4	35.6	28.5	23.3	41.2	53.5
43	0.55	0.82	76.4	0.63	0.96	59.6	30.5	13.7	53.9	29.1	-12.0	63.3	63.3
44	0.73	1.10	68.8	0.64	1.02	58.3	42.6	-1.9	75.5	44.6	-25.5	30.4	58.2
45	0.46	0.67	80.6	0.34	0.54	78.0	27.2	13.7	55.6	38.4	35.5	33.1	61.8
46	0.54	0.84	76.5	0.43	0.72	71.2	33.5	6.8	68.4	26.1	0.7	87.1	75.8
47	1.32	1.63	48.5	0.67	0.94	59.0	67.4	0.9	66.3	27.0	4.3	79.5	63.3
48	0.43	0.69	81.0	0.52	0.98	62.8	23.7	-1.0	86.5	19.3	9.8	72.1	75.6
49	0.79	1.14	66.9	0.38	0.59	75.3	30.3	24.6	35.7	27.2	29.5	38.0	54.0
50	0.68	1.11	69.5	0.36	0.57	76.5	25.3	-0.9	86.1	31.5	13.5	59.3	72.8
Avg	0.70	1.09	69.4	0.53	0.87	64.8	30.0	4.4	63.2	29.6	11.9	59.9	64.3

Detailed Results for Rank 7

Team: Biomediq
Affiliation: Biomediq, Denmark
Submitted on: 2015-23-03

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.70	1.47	63.9	0.43	0.80	69.5	16.9	-0.3	91.4	18.4	-12.9	66.4	72.8
2	0.62	1.00	72.4	0.71	1.20	52.1	30.8	-25.8	35.5	20.8	-6.4	78.2	59.5
3	0.58	1.06	72.5	0.50	1.12	60.6	20.9	5.7	76.9	27.8	1.6	84.5	73.6
4	0.72	1.22	67.2	0.62	0.93	60.8	33.5	-21.0	35.7	32.5	-25.4	35.7	49.8
5	0.59	1.07	72.1	0.39	0.70	72.9	18.5	-7.9	73.0	25.8	-13.6	61.6	69.9
6	0.68	1.26	67.5	0.50	0.95	64.2	21.0	0.4	89.3	22.1	-8.8	72.7	73.4
7	0.83	1.43	61.7	0.56	0.92	62.9	20.7	-9.6	68.1	19.7	10.4	70.7	65.9
8	0.71	1.22	67.3	0.37	0.66	74.4	25.4	-16.4	50.2	22.4	-16.1	58.2	62.5
9	0.59	1.00	73.1	0.51	1.15	59.7	28.7	-21.0	37.9	32.5	-25.3	35.7	51.6
10	0.69	1.14	69.0	0.53	1.01	61.8	25.5	-17.6	47.3	25.5	-9.0	70.9	62.2
11	0.86	1.61	58.5	0.56	1.09	59.3	16.5	-1.5	88.9	22.3	-9.5	71.3	69.5
12	0.62	1.15	70.4	0.34	0.62	76.0	27.2	-9.8	64.5	28.8	-7.2	73.0	71.0
13	0.90	1.91	53.5	0.60	0.95	60.9	31.6	25.4	35.1	29.9	2.9	81.0	57.6
14	0.59	1.04	72.5	0.46	0.80	68.6	22.3	9.6	67.2	16.5	4.1	84.5	73.2
15	0.49	0.97	75.8	0.63	1.20	54.9	23.8	-4.0	79.6	19.7	-4.8	81.7	73.0
16	1.05	2.34	44.0	0.32	0.54	78.7	29.9	-5.7	72.8	28.3	3.8	79.9	68.9
17	1.28	2.04	43.5	0.77	1.29	48.5	31.8	0.8	83.2	30.7	-8.8	69.0	61.0
18	0.41	0.78	80.2	0.40	0.66	73.4	19.4	-1.6	87.3	18.6	10.9	70.2	77.7
19	0.60	1.24	69.4	0.36	0.67	74.5	16.8	3.9	83.0	23.3	-12.3	65.4	73.1
20	0.61	1.01	72.5	0.56	1.05	60.2	21.6	-4.8	78.8	22.2	-19.8	51.0	65.6
21	0.73	1.58	61.9	0.47	0.94	65.3	26.1	-15.7	51.4	26.4	-13.2	62.1	60.2
22	1.48	2.82	28.1	0.45	0.82	68.5	22.5	-10.4	65.3	16.6	-12.9	67.1	57.3
23	1.04	2.20	46.3	0.59	0.94	61.5	26.2	1.5	84.1	40.2	23.1	36.4	57.1
24	1.08	2.03	47.8	0.37	0.64	74.7	19.3	0.7	89.3	21.8	3.4	83.6	73.8
25	0.63	1.14	70.2	0.57	1.03	60.4	24.7	9.6	66.2	36.2	14.4	55.6	63.1
26	0.80	1.43	62.4	0.59	1.35	53.0	17.6	-9.9	68.8	24.7	-14.7	59.9	61.0
27	0.61	1.06	71.8	0.74	1.28	49.4	33.6	-14.4	50.8	20.7	-6.6	77.9	62.5
28	0.97	1.86	52.7	0.53	0.92	64.0	30.3	13.2	55.1	36.3	-29.9	34.0	51.5
29	0.53	0.86	76.3	0.55	0.90	63.8	31.0	-18.5	42.5	29.5	-3.8	79.5	65.5
30	0.45	0.85	78.1	0.50	1.01	63.1	26.5	-11.3	61.3	35.9	-6.6	71.1	68.4
31	1.20	1.90	47.2	1.07	2.27	18.5	28.7	1.9	82.1	29.8	9.4	68.2	54.0
32	0.66	1.08	70.3	0.40	0.61	74.3	24.6	11.5	61.9	23.1	9.5	70.9	69.4
33	0.60	1.36	67.7	0.35	0.69	74.3	27.0	-11.9	59.8	29.1	-24.7	38.1	60.0
34	0.61	1.27	68.7	0.43	0.73	71.1	30.7	31.8	35.6	22.8	-6.8	76.5	63.0
35	0.55	0.98	74.2	0.69	1.40	48.7	24.7	-6.6	73.0	28.5	-25.6	37.5	58.4
36	0.55	1.13	72.0	0.36	0.66	74.5	17.2	-11.4	65.6	14.6	-1.3	90.9	75.8
37	1.82	3.54	10.7	1.33	2.82	7.3	26.5	16.9	48.4	31.4	31.5	36.2	25.7
38	0.45	0.75	79.6	0.33	0.60	77.0	14.9	2.1	88.1	19.7	1.5	88.3	83.2
39	1.18	2.43	40.0	1.58	3.20	0.0	27.3	4.3	77.3	27.1	12.7	62.8	45.0
40	0.58	1.19	70.5	0.41	0.71	71.9	21.1	-4.8	78.9	29.4	18.4	50.5	67.9
41	1.11	1.91	49.0	0.50	0.85	66.3	24.7	-23.0	38.4	20.4	-8.6	74.0	56.9
42	0.68	1.09	69.9	0.53	0.86	65.1	29.7	13.8	54.1	29.0	-0.5	86.3	68.8
43	0.81	1.59	59.9	0.64	1.42	49.7	25.8	1.5	84.3	20.5	-15.2	60.7	63.6
44	0.85	1.64	58.5	0.54	0.91	63.6	39.5	-10.9	56.3	27.4	-16.6	55.1	58.4
45	0.58	1.37	68.1	0.32	0.63	76.6	27.2	14.8	53.1	22.0	1.5	87.4	71.3
46	0.68	1.36	66.1	0.34	0.62	76.1	30.0	1.7	81.9	33.4	-1.8	81.7	76.5
47	1.31	1.70	47.7	0.77	1.01	54.2	67.9	-5.1	56.3	30.1	-8.6	69.7	57.0
48	0.65	1.34	66.9	0.58	1.06	59.1	17.9	-3.0	84.5	17.3	-9.0	74.5	71.3
49	0.59	1.00	73.2	0.41	0.71	72.1	25.2	16.7	49.4	20.7	12.9	65.4	65.0
50	0.52	0.94	75.4	0.39	0.70	72.9	21.6	-12.0	62.0	33.2	5.8	73.9	71.1
Avg	0.77	1.43	63.2	0.55	1.01	61.8	25.9	-2.6	65.4	25.7	-4.2	66.7	64.3

Detailed Results for Rank 8

Team: UPMC_IBML
Affiliation: UPMC, United States
Submitted on: 2013-05-17

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.46	0.76	79.2	0.45	0.74	70.1	23.6	-1.6	85.3	28.1	-11.6	64.6	74.8
2	0.81	1.18	65.7	0.81	1.43	44.1	36.8	-34.6	32.7	29.5	-23.9	39.6	45.5
3	0.61	0.92	73.7	0.53	1.02	62.0	29.4	-7.3	69.4	37.5	7.6	68.5	68.4
4	0.60	0.92	74.0	0.46	0.71	70.5	27.5	-14.6	53.2	15.8	-2.6	87.9	71.4
5	0.67	1.08	70.3	0.54	0.89	64.2	30.3	-16.3	48.1	36.8	-23.5	37.1	54.9
6	0.67	1.09	70.0	0.59	0.94	61.6	27.9	-2.5	81.1	25.7	-6.4	76.0	72.2
7	0.68	1.00	71.1	0.66	1.01	57.9	28.0	-19.9	40.8	27.3	6.6	74.9	61.2
8	0.81	1.17	66.1	0.46	0.73	69.9	33.3	-29.7	34.4	26.6	-13.2	62.1	58.1
9	0.63	0.96	72.9	0.49	0.80	67.8	31.1	-24.0	35.4	33.9	-1.0	83.2	64.8
10	0.74	1.16	67.7	0.48	0.85	67.1	29.2	-22.3	36.3	18.6	-8.9	74.2	61.3
11	0.67	1.09	70.1	0.52	0.93	63.9	21.6	-4.1	80.4	28.3	-7.2	73.2	71.9
12	0.43	0.72	80.4	0.41	0.65	73.3	24.9	-2.9	81.5	51.0	-22.2	33.5	67.2
13	0.68	1.10	69.6	0.60	1.04	59.1	37.6	13.0	52.3	32.4	2.2	81.3	65.6
14	0.63	1.03	71.8	0.53	0.81	66.2	27.5	10.1	63.8	21.7	3.4	83.6	71.4
15	0.40	0.62	82.5	0.47	0.76	69.1	25.6	5.4	75.4	36.1	-6.3	71.7	74.7
16	0.37	0.59	83.6	0.39	0.64	74.1	25.1	-2.6	82.2	33.6	5.4	74.5	78.6
17	0.86	1.25	63.7	0.57	0.88	63.6	32.1	-9.8	62.3	41.0	-28.6	32.0	55.4
18	0.50	0.77	78.2	0.46	0.70	70.8	29.3	-18.8	42.8	29.7	-7.3	72.4	66.1
19	0.70	1.52	63.3	0.48	0.84	67.3	25.3	0.8	86.2	34.6	-17.5	50.0	66.7
20	0.72	1.11	68.8	0.43	0.72	71.3	22.1	0.8	87.8	31.7	-11.1	64.1	73.0
21	0.39	0.61	83.0	0.38	0.62	75.0	28.8	-16.2	49.1	38.2	-30.7	33.2	60.1
22	0.80	1.46	62.0	0.48	0.81	67.8	23.0	-4.8	78.1	27.0	-11.6	65.1	68.3
23	0.65	1.03	71.4	0.63	1.01	58.7	31.0	-10.5	61.2	45.9	24.0	32.1	55.9
24	0.72	1.53	62.8	0.58	0.91	62.4	24.5	3.0	81.5	33.9	-8.6	68.0	68.7
25	0.59	0.91	74.3	0.59	0.95	61.2	26.9	-4.1	77.9	42.6	15.8	49.9	65.8
26	1.08	2.04	47.7	0.39	0.60	75.1	29.1	-21.9	36.3	28.8	-22.2	43.3	50.6
27	0.54	0.84	76.4	0.57	0.91	62.6	32.3	-14.8	50.5	23.2	-20.8	48.4	59.5
28	0.83	1.80	56.5	0.48	0.74	69.3	26.0	1.8	83.7	27.2	-23.2	42.1	62.9
29	0.70	1.09	69.4	0.75	1.42	46.4	42.1	-39.8	30.2	51.9	-22.1	33.2	44.8
30	0.61	1.03	72.2	0.42	0.67	72.3	34.5	-23.2	33.8	53.0	-22.6	31.8	52.5
31	1.10	1.67	52.5	0.68	1.01	57.3	40.7	-33.0	30.9	33.3	16.2	53.2	48.5
32	0.64	0.99	72.1	0.43	0.62	73.5	26.2	9.4	65.9	32.5	-5.3	75.2	71.7
33	0.49	0.80	78.0	0.46	0.76	69.4	26.9	-8.0	68.8	38.2	-19.3	44.9	65.3
34	0.69	1.34	66.1	0.46	0.72	70.4	33.3	34.6	34.4	30.7	2.5	81.5	63.1
35	0.63	0.98	72.5	0.57	0.98	61.3	30.7	-12.8	56.0	27.5	-16.5	55.1	61.2
36	0.40	0.64	82.3	0.49	0.83	67.1	24.5	-16.0	51.5	32.4	-12.8	60.4	65.3
37	0.87	1.42	61.2	1.34	2.83	7.1	31.9	-2.6	78.9	44.7	15.1	50.3	49.4
38	0.50	0.84	77.2	0.38	0.65	74.2	18.1	-5.3	79.3	26.3	-5.2	78.1	77.2
39	0.66	1.02	71.2	1.86	3.15	0.0	33.5	-15.5	48.5	31.4	22.4	41.8	40.4
40	0.49	0.78	78.4	0.52	0.80	66.6	26.9	-12.1	59.5	44.5	8.0	64.6	67.3
41	0.80	1.19	65.9	0.60	0.92	61.5	34.4	-31.3	33.9	20.5	-1.7	87.6	62.2
42	0.73	1.09	68.7	0.53	0.84	65.5	46.4	-20.4	30.9	37.8	-7.5	68.5	58.4
43	0.78	1.21	66.0	0.55	0.86	64.3	30.9	-4.3	75.5	26.0	-9.4	69.9	68.9
44	0.67	1.05	70.7	0.56	0.88	63.5	37.3	-4.3	72.6	31.5	-24.5	37.4	61.1
45	0.41	0.69	81.5	0.41	0.64	73.5	30.5	0.8	83.7	49.7	5.5	67.1	76.5
46	0.60	1.02	72.6	0.36	0.56	76.7	29.5	-9.1	65.1	32.6	1.6	82.6	74.2
47	1.18	1.52	52.9	0.70	0.96	57.7	69.4	-10.7	42.6	34.5	-13.1	58.9	53.0
48	0.40	0.61	82.6	0.61	1.04	58.9	26.9	-11.7	60.3	27.7	-8.4	71.2	68.2
49	0.63	0.99	72.3	0.41	0.63	73.8	26.3	9.2	66.4	29.1	3.9	79.4	73.0
50	0.59	0.95	73.9	0.48	0.89	66.1	34.5	-25.3	33.8	34.2	0.4	84.2	64.5
Avg	0.66	1.06	70.7	0.56	0.93	63.5	30.5	-9.6	59.0	33.1	-6.7	61.3	63.6

Detailed Results for Rank 9

Team: shan_unc
Affiliation: UNC Chapel Hill, United States
Submitted on: 2013-08-13

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.69	1.06	70.2	0.56	0.80	65.5	17.1	1.0	89.7	19.7	-4.3	82.9	77.0
2	0.68	0.99	71.4	0.73	1.07	54.4	27.7	-24.9	37.0	28.8	-26.1	37.3	50.0
3	0.64	1.01	71.8	0.69	0.96	58.1	21.5	20.0	43.5	28.6	35.7	37.4	52.7
4	0.47	0.75	79.3	0.49	0.71	69.6	25.8	-0.3	87.1	26.8	-8.4	71.6	76.9
5	0.95	1.50	58.1	0.52	0.79	66.8	22.3	0.2	89.0	17.4	1.9	88.6	75.7
6	0.66	1.04	71.0	0.51	0.93	64.2	21.2	16.7	51.4	19.4	14.0	63.8	62.6
7	0.71	1.09	69.2	0.73	1.26	50.3	24.1	-16.0	51.6	18.8	11.7	68.6	59.9
8	0.73	1.15	68.0	0.51	0.85	65.9	23.8	-16.4	50.8	20.6	-6.2	78.6	65.8
9	0.59	0.92	74.3	0.63	0.97	59.4	25.5	-13.9	55.8	26.2	18.0	52.7	60.6
10	0.67	1.11	69.8	0.44	0.74	70.6	27.7	-22.6	37.0	20.6	-15.6	60.1	59.4
11	0.93	1.52	58.4	0.53	0.89	64.3	16.3	7.6	74.7	25.4	10.0	69.0	66.6
12	0.47	0.88	77.4	0.46	0.67	71.4	21.2	-0.3	89.3	26.4	29.4	38.4	69.1
13	0.85	1.32	63.0	0.94	1.54	37.8	32.9	37.8	34.5	34.1	35.5	35.0	42.6
14	0.67	1.05	70.6	0.47	0.66	71.2	24.6	12.9	58.5	18.4	6.6	78.8	69.8
15	0.58	0.88	74.8	0.49	0.75	68.7	22.1	15.1	54.7	21.4	24.1	42.7	60.2
16	0.78	1.36	63.8	0.38	0.55	76.4	22.7	-6.0	75.6	21.8	7.4	75.7	72.9
17	0.99	1.46	57.9	0.64	0.99	59.0	27.9	2.5	81.1	23.9	7.2	75.2	68.3
18	0.60	0.93	73.8	0.48	0.74	69.2	18.7	9.5	69.3	24.4	27.8	39.3	62.9
19	0.64	1.12	70.4	0.55	0.84	64.9	22.7	20.3	42.4	19.5	6.1	79.3	64.3
20	0.72	1.07	69.3	0.60	0.96	60.8	18.6	5.4	78.8	25.6	-9.4	70.0	69.7
21	0.55	0.89	75.4	0.47	0.70	70.4	21.5	-5.3	77.6	14.1	4.4	85.1	77.1
22	1.61	3.05	22.0	0.48	0.71	69.9	24.7	-6.4	73.6	15.9	-6.6	79.8	61.3
23	1.03	1.61	55.0	0.84	1.30	46.0	21.7	9.7	67.3	43.4	70.0	30.9	49.8
24	1.21	2.18	43.0	0.57	0.83	64.5	21.6	16.4	51.8	19.3	20.4	51.0	52.6
25	0.71	1.14	68.5	0.73	1.23	51.0	22.8	9.2	67.9	28.7	33.9	37.4	56.2
26	0.83	1.25	64.5	0.63	1.10	56.8	24.5	-19.1	44.2	21.9	3.6	83.1	62.2
27	0.66	1.05	70.9	0.69	1.05	56.0	33.7	-7.1	67.7	27.9	-18.5	51.0	61.4
28	0.94	1.85	53.4	0.55	0.81	65.4	28.2	14.4	53.5	29.5	-21.8	43.7	54.0
29	0.58	0.89	74.8	0.72	1.00	56.2	27.6	-17.4	46.9	26.4	11.8	65.0	60.7
30	0.55	0.89	75.5	0.69	1.24	52.0	23.2	-2.8	82.6	29.5	20.2	47.0	64.3
31	1.36	2.20	39.4	0.61	1.01	59.4	24.8	7.5	70.9	34.5	35.1	34.8	51.1
32	0.64	1.10	70.4	0.47	0.68	70.6	25.6	25.5	38.0	26.0	27.7	38.5	54.4
33	0.51	0.77	78.0	0.58	0.83	64.1	22.3	3.3	81.9	23.2	18.4	53.3	69.3
34	0.56	1.11	72.2	0.48	0.73	69.6	30.5	34.6	35.7	24.4	31.4	39.3	54.2
35	0.60	0.92	74.0	0.76	1.28	49.1	21.0	1.7	86.2	20.8	-3.3	84.3	73.4
36	0.50	0.76	78.4	0.54	0.80	66.1	12.1	1.4	91.1	12.6	5.8	82.9	79.6
37	1.11	1.73	51.5	1.01	1.73	31.5	25.6	18.1	46.1	42.0	59.8	31.5	40.2
38	0.49	0.77	78.6	0.38	0.62	74.9	14.6	3.6	84.9	18.5	12.4	67.3	76.4
39	0.95	1.56	57.3	1.09	1.80	27.4	33.5	-14.0	51.8	31.6	17.8	50.7	46.8
40	0.79	1.16	66.6	0.61	0.81	63.6	20.4	8.9	69.9	39.4	61.5	32.7	58.2
41	1.32	2.17	40.7	0.62	0.94	60.7	29.5	-28.2	36.1	13.7	-1.1	91.8	57.3
42	0.77	1.15	67.2	0.57	0.85	64.0	25.3	13.2	57.5	27.8	30.3	37.8	56.6
43	0.80	1.23	65.3	0.61	0.89	62.0	24.7	11.2	62.5	11.9	-0.5	93.9	70.9
44	0.75	1.13	67.7	0.60	0.93	61.5	28.8	-2.3	81.2	16.8	-6.8	79.2	72.4
45	0.52	0.83	77.0	0.49	0.70	69.9	26.5	19.0	43.7	32.7	44.2	35.6	56.5
46	0.63	0.91	73.5	0.47	0.71	70.2	27.3	-3.1	80.0	18.7	4.4	83.1	76.7
47	1.25	1.63	49.9	0.82	1.08	51.2	65.9	-3.9	60.0	30.4	-1.4	83.8	61.2
48	0.49	0.75	78.9	0.51	0.82	66.5	21.0	9.7	67.6	18.1	4.4	83.2	74.1
49	0.74	1.11	68.4	0.39	0.57	75.7	24.8	22.2	38.4	28.4	32.2	37.5	55.0
50	0.59	0.89	74.7	0.43	0.66	72.3	18.8	-9.0	70.4	25.8	20.6	47.8	66.3
Avg	0.76	1.22	66.3	0.59	0.92	61.7	24.7	3.2	62.8	24.4	13.5	60.2	62.7

Detailed Results for Rank 10

Team: AMC_MIRL
Affiliation: Biomedical Engineering Center / Asan Medical Center, Korea Republic of
Submitted on: 2016-07-26. See paper here.

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.45	0.72	79.9	0.43	0.69	71.7	24.9	-10.4	64.3	31.4	-25.1	36.4	63.1
2	0.71	1.04	69.9	1.49	3.48	2.3	33.6	-30.0	34.2	22.8	-12.8	64.5	42.7
3	0.59	0.89	74.6	0.52	0.99	62.8	29.0	-0.5	85.2	38.3	-0.3	82.5	76.3
4	0.59	0.88	74.9	0.43	0.66	72.4	30.2	-11.1	60.2	16.4	-0.2	92.3	74.9
5	0.80	1.57	60.5	0.55	1.08	59.9	29.7	-16.5	47.9	31.8	-22.7	41.0	52.3
6	0.87	1.63	58.0	0.55	0.87	64.1	29.2	4.0	77.0	29.3	-13.0	61.3	65.1
7	0.72	1.08	69.1	0.59	0.87	62.9	26.5	-6.0	73.7	20.4	2.8	85.6	72.8
8	0.92	1.64	56.9	0.39	0.60	75.1	32.7	-27.1	34.6	22.2	-6.0	78.4	61.2
9	0.62	0.94	73.3	0.46	0.75	69.6	26.7	-12.5	58.5	31.6	-4.2	77.8	69.8
10	0.67	1.05	70.7	0.61	1.56	47.7	27.9	-20.4	39.6	25.1	-18.9	51.5	52.4
11	0.68	1.10	69.8	0.52	0.91	64.5	24.3	-7.7	70.7	35.3	-25.8	34.5	59.9
12	0.46	0.76	79.4	0.41	0.65	73.2	29.1	-13.7	54.6	48.0	8.3	62.5	67.4
13	0.65	1.07	70.7	0.83	1.61	39.7	35.8	13.1	52.9	38.8	-5.1	72.8	59.0
14	0.54	0.86	76.1	0.49	0.74	68.7	27.8	9.6	64.7	17.3	-1.5	89.4	74.7
15	0.44	0.68	80.8	0.85	1.63	38.8	29.3	-4.1	76.9	49.4	-42.4	28.2	56.2
16	0.39	0.59	83.2	0.35	0.54	77.4	26.0	-3.2	80.3	27.7	7.0	73.8	78.7
17	0.81	1.19	65.8	0.54	0.83	65.3	32.2	-5.4	72.4	41.3	-27.3	31.8	58.8
18	0.51	0.77	78.1	0.47	0.72	70.0	28.0	-13.6	55.3	26.9	-9.1	70.1	68.4
19	0.58	1.13	71.4	0.45	0.76	69.9	28.0	-2.3	81.4	36.6	-21.4	41.4	66.0
20	0.73	1.09	68.8	0.43	0.73	70.9	27.0	0.4	86.3	33.3	-12.9	59.7	71.4
21	0.41	0.63	82.0	0.40	0.67	73.1	32.8	-22.2	34.6	35.9	-28.8	34.2	56.0
22	0.52	0.80	77.6	0.42	0.67	72.6	23.3	2.2	84.0	31.7	-24.8	36.8	67.8
23	0.71	1.30	66.3	0.59	0.93	61.6	32.1	-15.5	49.1	45.1	20.4	39.7	54.2
24	0.53	0.86	76.3	0.52	0.80	66.6	26.4	-6.1	73.5	47.6	-38.1	29.0	61.4
25	0.65	0.96	72.4	0.55	0.86	64.4	32.8	-14.7	50.6	45.4	17.3	45.6	58.3
26	1.29	2.74	33.3	0.38	0.59	75.6	24.6	-13.6	57.0	32.7	-28.0	35.6	50.4
27	0.51	0.79	77.9	0.55	0.90	63.8	32.9	-13.5	53.3	19.5	-2.5	86.4	70.4
28	0.91	1.94	52.7	0.45	0.69	71.3	32.9	19.3	39.9	22.2	-15.6	59.2	55.8
29	0.67	1.06	70.6	0.90	1.92	31.2	33.9	-26.8	34.1	40.3	-4.2	74.0	52.4
30	0.89	1.74	56.1	0.39	0.61	74.8	35.2	-17.3	43.5	55.9	-38.9	25.4	49.9
31	0.96	1.59	56.6	2.41	4.42	0.0	27.5	-13.8	55.2	33.7	11.8	61.8	43.4
32	0.67	0.99	71.6	0.41	0.59	74.4	28.9	7.1	69.9	37.7	-8.4	66.7	70.7
33	0.54	0.88	75.8	0.45	0.72	70.6	30.3	-16.3	48.0	46.1	-17.1	45.9	60.1
34	0.94	1.88	53.1	0.44	0.68	71.8	37.0	23.5	32.6	32.4	-4.5	76.8	58.6
35	0.63	0.95	72.9	0.53	0.89	64.7	33.8	-1.0	81.8	32.8	-12.5	60.7	70.1
36	0.43	0.67	81.3	0.48	0.81	67.6	24.6	-12.6	59.2	28.3	-12.1	63.6	68.0
37	0.85	1.43	61.3	0.82	1.43	44.1	34.5	15.8	47.1	41.8	16.7	48.5	50.2
38	0.57	1.19	70.8	0.37	0.61	75.4	18.9	-5.0	79.5	28.6	-7.8	71.9	74.4
39	0.74	1.35	64.8	1.97	4.00	0.0	31.8	-19.7	39.5	40.6	-0.5	81.2	46.4
40	0.47	0.72	79.7	0.52	0.79	66.6	27.3	-9.3	65.6	47.9	-9.5	60.1	68.0
41	0.92	1.57	57.9	0.55	0.84	64.8	31.0	-26.2	35.4	19.4	-2.7	86.0	61.0
42	0.82	1.27	64.4	0.52	0.84	65.9	47.3	-32.1	27.8	32.9	10.0	65.7	56.0
43	0.75	1.28	65.6	0.50	0.78	67.8	27.4	5.1	75.3	28.4	-23.3	41.3	62.5
44	0.69	1.04	70.5	0.56	0.89	63.5	41.3	-10.0	57.4	41.6	-33.6	31.7	55.7
45	0.44	0.73	80.1	0.42	0.64	73.2	37.4	-1.9	78.1	60.0	-30.5	23.6	63.7
46	0.50	0.80	77.8	0.38	0.59	75.6	28.9	-3.8	77.6	30.8	7.9	70.9	75.5
47	1.13	1.46	54.9	0.67	0.92	59.4	69.5	-14.9	32.9	32.5	-11.1	63.6	52.7
48	0.62	1.41	66.7	0.59	0.98	60.7	27.5	-11.1	61.3	28.7	-16.6	54.4	60.8
49	0.65	0.98	72.1	0.41	0.64	73.4	27.2	-4.4	77.1	36.1	-24.5	35.5	64.5
50	0.59	0.94	74.0	0.46	0.86	67.3	29.1	-12.9	56.4	38.5	2.3	78.5	69.0
Avg	0.67	1.13	69.4	0.60	1.04	61.8	30.9	-8.2	59.0	34.4	-10.8	57.8	62.0

Detailed Results for Rank 11

Team: UIiibiKnee
Affiliation: University of Iowa, United States
Submitted on: 2010-10-19

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.54	0.81	76.9	0.56	0.95	62.3	21.8	2.1	84.9	26.6	-12.0	64.4	72.1
2	0.68	0.97	71.5	0.78	1.25	49.0	37.9	-36.7	32.2	20.2	-14.0	63.4	54.0
3	0.65	1.07	70.7	0.55	0.87	64.3	25.0	12.3	59.8	37.6	14.7	54.2	62.2
4	0.67	1.34	66.5	0.56	0.96	62.2	24.4	-5.6	75.6	24.2	-21.7	46.2	62.6
5	0.66	1.03	71.2	0.59	0.95	61.4	23.7	-3.1	81.8	33.5	-5.1	75.1	72.4
6	0.63	1.09	71.0	0.69	1.22	52.4	25.9	4.7	77.0	17.9	2.2	87.8	72.0
7	0.60	0.96	73.5	0.79	1.32	47.1	25.7	-15.7	51.6	24.8	16.2	57.0	57.3
8	0.67	1.01	71.4	0.80	1.28	47.8	29.5	-25.5	36.1	34.8	-23.8	37.5	48.2
9	0.68	1.04	70.7	0.81	1.42	44.6	30.8	-24.4	35.5	35.5	-4.3	75.9	56.7
10	0.78	1.20	66.2	0.65	1.06	57.1	35.4	-31.7	33.4	22.0	-17.5	55.5	53.1
11	0.62	1.01	72.2	0.74	1.17	51.7	20.2	6.8	74.8	32.7	-2.3	81.0	69.9
12	0.77	1.44	62.9	0.56	0.91	63.3	24.1	-3.1	81.4	37.7	16.1	51.5	64.8
13	0.76	1.19	66.8	0.98	1.61	35.0	34.7	20.4	36.5	28.8	23.6	40.5	44.7
14	0.53	0.82	76.9	0.58	1.12	58.0	26.6	3.2	80.1	17.9	15.1	62.1	69.3
15	0.46	0.66	80.7	0.60	0.93	61.5	24.1	18.5	45.8	26.3	0.8	86.8	68.7
16	0.50	0.79	78.0	0.48	0.73	69.2	32.0	-4.2	75.2	41.5	11.7	58.5	70.2
17	0.97	1.66	55.4	0.72	1.09	54.2	30.4	18.6	42.6	22.9	6.0	78.0	57.6
18	0.43	0.65	81.5	0.41	0.57	74.9	22.4	6.9	73.6	21.2	18.1	54.8	71.2
19	0.48	0.72	79.6	0.56	1.00	61.3	22.5	10.8	64.5	28.4	-3.8	80.0	71.3
20	0.65	0.98	72.1	0.58	0.89	62.9	26.4	-5.3	75.4	24.7	-2.4	84.3	73.7
21	0.53	0.75	77.9	0.61	1.01	59.4	28.9	-15.8	49.9	30.0	-14.3	58.4	61.4
22	0.67	1.21	68.4	0.49	0.77	68.2	22.4	-0.9	87.3	24.2	-6.7	76.0	75.0
23	0.66	0.96	72.1	0.96	1.40	40.1	23.4	2.4	83.5	42.7	42.3	31.2	56.7
24	0.51	0.79	77.7	0.45	0.68	71.5	23.2	16.9	50.0	28.4	1.8	83.9	70.7
25	0.68	1.10	69.8	0.82	1.35	45.6	21.1	-0.7	88.4	40.2	28.6	32.3	59.0
26	0.86	1.30	63.0	0.58	0.94	61.9	20.0	-6.2	76.2	26.4	-10.1	68.4	67.4
27	0.70	1.00	70.7	0.67	1.07	56.1	40.5	-19.3	36.3	18.4	-12.0	68.0	57.8
28	1.31	2.78	32.2	0.72	1.31	49.5	33.8	-9.5	62.0	26.1	-21.5	45.8	47.4
29	0.67	0.99	71.5	0.82	1.28	47.1	36.0	-29.4	33.1	41.2	9.2	63.6	53.8
30	0.71	1.07	69.5	0.66	1.17	54.4	29.1	1.0	83.9	49.0	-5.0	68.4	69.1
31	1.03	1.56	55.6	0.76	1.08	53.2	35.8	-12.0	55.4	30.6	13.3	60.0	56.1
32	0.61	1.21	69.7	0.61	0.87	62.4	26.2	21.7	37.7	24.0	16.1	57.5	56.8
33	1.08	2.16	46.1	0.43	0.69	71.8	32.9	-9.4	62.8	33.4	-10.4	64.7	61.3
34	0.71	1.31	66.0	0.65	1.08	56.7	34.4	33.1	33.8	25.9	3.9	80.9	59.3
35	0.60	0.87	74.7	0.82	1.34	45.9	39.6	-22.9	31.4	29.9	-19.4	48.3	50.1
36	0.50	0.74	78.7	0.49	0.80	67.6	18.8	-7.4	74.1	18.1	-3.4	85.4	76.4
37	1.00	1.67	54.6	1.07	1.73	29.6	26.6	10.0	64.4	37.3	38.8	33.6	45.5
38	0.73	1.15	67.9	0.51	0.79	67.3	16.9	4.9	80.7	21.0	8.7	73.5	72.3
39	0.93	1.50	58.7	1.53	2.62	1.0	33.6	-5.1	72.4	28.6	7.0	73.5	51.4
40	0.64	1.05	71.3	0.54	0.79	66.4	24.2	6.4	73.8	48.6	48.6	28.6	60.0
41	0.82	1.17	65.6	0.67	1.05	56.8	32.3	-30.1	34.8	22.8	-1.6	86.9	61.0
42	1.00	1.62	55.5	0.69	1.06	55.7	40.3	-23.2	31.1	27.4	13.2	61.8	51.0
43	0.62	0.94	73.4	0.49	0.73	69.1	26.5	2.1	82.6	17.1	-9.6	73.4	74.6
44	0.68	1.02	71.0	0.92	1.73	34.6	41.1	-9.8	58.0	30.3	-17.2	52.6	54.0
45	0.51	0.74	78.5	0.48	0.80	67.9	30.4	17.7	44.7	35.2	21.9	41.1	58.0
46	0.68	1.07	70.3	0.53	0.81	66.1	36.6	2.6	76.8	37.1	6.2	71.4	71.1
47	1.41	1.87	43.0	0.76	1.02	54.4	69.8	-20.1	20.7	30.0	-12.9	61.2	44.8
48	0.61	1.01	72.6	0.62	0.93	60.9	22.2	2.5	83.7	21.6	-2.1	86.2	75.9
49	0.97	1.57	56.9	0.47	0.67	70.8	34.1	31.0	34.0	27.8	16.5	55.0	54.2
50	1.05	2.00	48.9	0.45	0.63	72.5	28.1	-8.8	66.4	40.4	4.7	72.8	65.2
Avg	0.72	1.17	67.7	0.66	1.07	56.5	29.5	-2.6	59.7	29.5	3.0	63.2	61.8

Detailed Results for Rank 12

Team: shan_unc
Affiliation: UNC Chapel Hill, United States
Submitted on: 2012-08-03

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.72	1.10	68.8	0.57	0.83	64.5	18.5	-7.0	75.0	29.4	-20.1	47.2	63.9
2	0.75	1.07	68.7	0.88	1.58	38.8	37.0	-34.0	32.6	43.6	-42.0	30.8	42.7
3	0.75	1.27	65.8	0.75	1.27	49.4	24.4	19.1	44.4	31.3	16.5	53.4	53.3
4	0.63	0.97	72.7	0.50	0.73	68.7	31.1	-16.3	47.7	42.5	-42.2	31.3	55.1
5	0.88	1.32	62.3	0.52	0.81	66.4	23.9	0.2	88.4	32.8	-17.3	51.2	67.1
6	0.75	1.17	67.3	0.52	0.90	64.6	25.7	0.5	86.7	17.0	0.6	91.3	77.5
7	0.68	1.02	70.8	0.77	1.30	48.5	27.9	-20.8	38.7	25.4	-3.6	81.6	59.9
8	0.75	1.12	68.0	0.55	0.98	61.9	31.4	-26.9	35.2	34.4	-25.1	35.0	50.0
9	0.69	1.05	70.1	0.62	0.96	60.2	39.8	-30.6	31.3	37.3	-6.0	71.7	58.3
10	0.77	1.23	65.9	0.48	0.82	67.6	37.1	-33.5	32.6	34.1	-31.2	35.0	50.3
11	0.92	1.46	59.3	0.58	1.00	60.4	19.4	-1.6	87.3	28.4	2.3	83.0	72.5
12	0.52	0.97	75.0	0.44	0.66	72.0	22.5	-3.6	81.1	36.0	7.0	70.3	74.6
13	0.96	1.44	58.7	0.95	1.60	36.2	32.3	24.1	34.8	32.1	20.8	44.5	43.6
14	0.76	1.26	65.8	0.50	0.72	69.1	24.9	-0.8	86.4	22.1	-14.1	62.3	70.9
15	0.58	0.91	74.4	2.33	6.48	0.0	22.1	14.4	56.3	21.0	17.6	55.8	46.6
16	0.58	0.97	73.8	0.37	0.57	76.2	29.0	-9.1	65.3	32.4	-8.4	69.1	71.1
17	1.10	1.58	53.9	0.70	1.14	53.9	31.7	11.9	57.5	27.4	-2.4	83.2	62.1
18	0.69	1.22	67.8	0.58	1.05	59.5	24.2	-2.0	83.9	23.2	2.9	84.0	73.8
19	0.61	1.04	72.1	0.55	0.84	65.0	24.6	11.9	60.9	20.2	-5.1	80.9	69.7
20	0.74	1.09	68.5	0.64	1.06	57.4	23.6	-5.9	75.3	33.2	-15.4	54.9	64.0
21	0.54	0.88	75.9	0.47	1.00	64.2	29.0	-11.6	59.5	20.7	-5.4	80.2	69.9
22	1.60	3.00	22.9	0.48	0.72	69.7	29.8	-14.8	51.8	25.1	-20.7	47.8	48.1
23	0.92	1.34	61.0	0.91	1.43	41.2	24.5	-0.8	86.7	43.3	48.5	31.0	55.0
24	1.21	2.10	44.0	0.58	0.85	63.8	22.9	10.4	65.3	20.4	2.8	85.5	64.7
25	0.77	1.20	66.3	0.77	1.30	48.4	32.4	-7.4	67.7	35.0	8.6	67.6	62.5
26	0.87	1.47	60.3	0.62	1.13	56.7	25.7	-15.5	52.1	26.1	-2.6	83.3	63.1
27	0.67	1.06	70.4	1.31	2.12	14.0	36.4	-15.0	48.2	38.9	-34.9	32.9	41.4
28	1.13	2.36	42.1	0.57	0.84	64.3	35.8	-5.7	70.1	40.6	-38.2	32.1	52.1
29	0.62	0.93	73.4	0.68	1.24	52.4	36.4	-29.1	32.9	33.3	1.5	82.4	60.3
30	0.61	1.01	72.5	0.71	1.26	50.9	27.9	-9.5	64.9	34.1	5.5	74.1	65.6
31	1.39	2.09	40.3	0.64	1.00	58.7	30.3	2.6	79.8	31.7	8.1	69.9	62.2
32	0.77	1.30	64.9	0.47	0.68	70.7	28.6	28.0	36.6	24.6	18.6	52.3	56.1
33	0.50	0.74	78.6	0.55	0.78	66.1	29.1	-13.0	56.2	28.4	-0.8	86.0	71.7
34	0.50	0.93	76.0	0.53	0.82	66.1	30.6	29.3	35.6	26.5	19.0	50.5	57.1
35	0.66	1.04	70.9	0.80	1.39	45.3	26.6	-2.1	82.7	26.9	-9.9	68.6	66.9
36	0.51	0.83	77.1	0.52	0.78	67.1	20.3	-3.0	83.5	26.0	-15.8	57.2	71.2
37	1.32	2.21	40.1	1.25	2.13	15.5	32.0	-0.1	84.8	36.4	29.4	34.0	43.6
38	0.55	0.98	74.1	0.37	0.62	75.2	16.3	-0.3	91.6	19.5	-4.3	82.9	80.9
39	0.70	1.09	69.4	1.11	1.85	25.9	37.7	-20.4	35.1	34.7	18.4	48.2	44.7
40	0.80	1.20	65.8	0.61	0.82	63.3	25.2	-2.3	82.7	49.4	20.5	37.6	62.4
41	1.14	1.70	51.3	0.60	0.94	61.3	30.6	-28.6	35.6	18.2	-7.9	76.2	56.1
42	0.73	1.04	69.5	0.68	1.00	57.5	27.3	3.4	79.4	34.0	8.5	68.1	68.6
43	0.80	1.25	64.9	0.65	0.97	58.9	27.3	-1.8	83.0	23.0	-18.4	53.4	65.1
44	0.83	1.26	64.3	0.64	1.03	57.8	33.6	-13.8	52.1	28.9	-20.7	46.2	55.1
45	0.51	0.83	77.2	0.46	0.68	71.1	29.0	11.0	60.9	34.2	18.1	49.0	64.6
46	0.63	0.96	72.8	0.45	0.71	70.9	31.2	-7.1	68.8	27.4	-14.1	59.9	68.1
47	1.25	1.59	50.5	0.79	1.04	52.9	67.4	-12.9	38.4	36.8	-10.2	63.5	51.3
48	0.56	1.05	72.9	0.56	0.92	62.9	20.2	4.0	81.3	22.3	-11.3	67.8	71.2
49	0.69	1.07	69.9	0.39	0.60	75.1	25.3	20.7	40.2	28.8	8.4	70.7	63.9
50	0.58	0.88	75.1	0.45	0.68	71.3	24.8	-11.1	62.7	30.0	9.8	67.4	69.1
Avg	0.78	1.25	65.3	0.67	1.13	57.2	28.9	-4.5	61.4	30.2	-3.1	60.9	61.2

Detailed Results for Rank 13

Team: SRIB-HME
Affiliation: Samsung RnD Institute Bangalore, India
Submitted on: 2018-08-20

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.48	1.14	73.4	0.69	1.70	42.4	20.2	4.0	81.3	17.1	-3.0	86.5	70.9
2	0.76	1.63	60.4	1.08	2.53	15.3	21.0	-10.3	66.3	18.6	-5.8	80.4	55.6
3	0.51	0.97	75.3	0.49	1.20	59.2	20.9	9.1	69.1	31.1	34.3	36.3	60.0
4	0.55	1.21	70.8	0.65	1.63	45.1	24.3	12.5	59.7	15.3	8.4	76.7	63.1
5	0.62	1.12	70.7	0.46	1.01	64.1	20.6	-9.8	67.5	20.8	4.5	81.9	71.1
6	0.44	0.69	80.8	0.37	0.63	74.8	21.5	12.4	61.2	24.1	20.7	48.3	66.3
7	0.66	1.29	67.4	0.92	2.50	20.4	24.9	-2.0	83.8	25.5	27.1	38.8	52.6
8	0.63	1.29	68.1	0.74	1.72	40.5	22.8	-13.4	58.3	24.8	-8.8	71.7	59.7
9	0.66	1.36	66.3	0.76	1.88	36.4	25.8	-13.6	56.3	26.4	21.3	46.1	51.3
10	0.90	1.81	55.0	0.97	2.45	18.9	22.7	-12.0	61.4	13.6	-1.0	92.0	56.8
11	0.82	1.64	58.9	0.98	2.45	18.5	20.1	5.0	78.9	24.9	10.2	68.9	56.3
12	0.49	0.90	76.5	0.44	1.02	64.5	22.6	-11.7	62.4	25.1	1.9	85.3	72.2
13	0.75	1.34	64.8	0.71	1.37	48.7	29.6	13.2	55.5	30.6	26.7	36.5	51.4
14	0.51	1.06	74.0	0.57	1.27	55.5	26.5	18.4	44.9	27.4	37.3	38.0	53.1
15	0.48	1.02	75.1	0.75	1.72	40.1	27.9	15.3	51.6	26.0	15.6	57.6	56.1
16	0.55	1.21	71.0	0.65	1.76	42.5	26.2	19.9	41.5	24.1	20.7	48.3	50.8
17	0.88	1.46	60.3	0.64	1.25	53.4	29.5	11.0	60.6	32.7	1.6	82.5	64.2
18	0.53	0.96	75.0	0.50	1.17	59.5	25.5	-6.5	72.9	26.0	25.5	38.5	61.5
19	0.47	1.11	74.1	0.63	1.49	48.8	19.5	0.7	89.1	23.9	-5.7	78.1	72.5
20	0.86	1.82	55.6	0.68	1.72	42.4	20.9	4.1	80.8	20.9	2.5	85.9	66.2
21	0.58	1.41	67.5	0.81	2.07	30.7	25.5	-7.3	71.2	20.0	-11.7	68.0	59.3
22	0.71	1.26	66.9	0.53	1.24	57.1	27.0	2.7	81.0	16.7	-2.6	87.6	73.1
23	0.58	1.23	70.0	0.74	1.59	43.4	27.1	-3.8	78.4	36.6	37.6	33.9	56.4
24	0.57	1.06	72.6	0.53	1.23	57.5	20.7	8.7	70.1	20.6	9.4	72.4	68.1
25	0.58	1.25	69.8	0.71	1.62	43.5	23.0	1.8	85.0	32.9	26.6	35.5	58.4
26	0.92	2.07	50.7	0.68	1.56	45.7	19.0	-5.4	78.5	21.7	8.7	73.2	62.0
27	0.51	0.75	78.3	0.75	1.37	47.6	33.2	6.3	69.8	26.4	-3.6	81.2	69.2
28	1.34	2.98	28.8	0.72	1.80	39.4	32.7	17.0	45.3	19.5	2.2	87.0	50.1
29	0.74	1.57	61.7	0.77	1.84	37.1	24.8	-8.4	68.9	23.8	3.9	81.7	62.4
30	0.50	0.92	76.1	0.50	0.99	63.4	25.7	-14.5	54.3	31.6	-0.1	85.9	69.9
31	1.27	2.14	42.3	0.81	1.56	41.4	29.0	-1.9	82.1	30.9	18.9	48.8	53.6
32	0.64	1.16	69.7	0.55	1.21	57.2	28.1	4.6	76.2	31.3	21.3	43.9	61.8
33	0.53	1.00	74.3	0.50	0.96	64.0	27.3	-15.6	51.1	24.6	-15.9	57.6	61.8
34	0.51	0.86	76.8	0.59	1.44	51.2	35.2	39.3	33.4	22.1	18.1	54.5	54.0
35	0.53	1.21	71.3	0.61	1.48	49.8	20.7	5.0	78.6	21.0	0.4	89.9	72.4
36	0.51	1.32	70.3	0.76	1.93	35.5	19.2	-7.0	74.8	17.1	6.8	78.9	64.9
37	1.31	3.35	24.2	1.39	3.02	5.6	22.9	4.5	78.9	33.1	40.7	35.4	36.0
38	0.59	1.39	67.6	0.81	2.12	29.9	19.7	0.9	88.7	19.9	16.4	58.8	61.2
39	0.85	2.17	50.9	2.33	4.70	0.0	32.5	2.5	78.9	39.7	11.1	60.4	47.6
40	0.46	0.83	78.3	0.55	0.99	61.9	20.3	5.0	78.8	31.6	37.9	36.1	63.8
41	0.82	1.38	62.7	0.70	1.61	44.1	25.3	-22.4	38.1	19.8	17.0	57.6	50.6
42	0.63	1.12	70.6	0.76	1.64	41.6	31.6	9.4	63.3	31.0	30.5	36.4	53.0
43	0.60	1.04	72.3	0.53	1.23	57.3	25.7	-0.2	87.4	13.2	-4.9	84.5	75.4
44	0.62	1.33	67.8	0.64	1.54	47.4	26.8	-4.8	76.4	17.2	2.1	88.3	70.0
45	0.43	0.92	77.7	0.46	1.13	61.8	28.2	16.2	49.3	30.3	33.5	36.7	56.4
46	0.47	0.90	77.0	0.42	0.96	66.5	27.1	13.2	56.6	20.0	14.6	62.3	65.6
47	1.36	1.81	45.1	0.93	1.64	35.9	65.5	1.9	64.9	31.2	6.3	73.8	54.9
48	0.53	1.25	70.7	0.71	1.64	43.1	20.8	-4.9	78.9	21.1	1.7	87.4	70.0
49	0.65	1.31	67.4	0.63	1.45	49.5	27.5	9.6	64.9	33.6	36.2	35.2	54.3
50	0.55	1.10	72.5	0.58	1.39	52.6	22.5	-9.7	67.0	24.3	12.2	65.1	64.3
Avg	0.67	1.34	66.5	0.71	1.63	45.1	25.8	1.8	67.5	24.8	12.2	63.5	60.6

Detailed Results for Rank 14

Team: BioMedIA
Affiliation: Imperial College London, United Kingdom
Submitted on: 2013-07-22

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.75	1.56	61.7	0.73	1.40	47.5	21.9	-4.0	80.3	23.2	-15.8	58.4	62.0
2	0.68	1.31	66.9	1.29	2.59	8.7	24.0	-16.8	49.9	24.9	-17.7	53.9	44.8
3	1.00	2.05	49.2	2.80	5.46	0.0	23.1	6.4	74.4	32.8	23.8	38.3	40.5
4	0.69	1.44	64.7	0.54	1.29	55.8	31.5	-4.2	75.4	33.5	-25.2	35.3	57.8
5	0.95	1.74	54.7	0.44	0.93	66.5	21.0	-3.1	82.8	23.7	-15.4	59.0	65.8
6	0.77	1.48	62.4	0.77	1.78	38.2	28.7	12.0	58.6	20.2	0.5	90.0	62.3
7	0.71	1.34	65.6	0.68	1.38	49.3	24.4	-10.9	63.3	20.0	-0.2	90.8	67.2
8	0.61	1.18	70.1	0.48	1.24	58.9	22.3	-16.3	51.7	32.3	-27.0	35.8	54.1
9	0.73	1.44	63.7	0.80	1.72	38.5	35.8	-29.5	33.2	39.3	-14.2	54.5	47.5
10	0.86	1.58	59.0	0.60	1.50	49.5	31.8	-26.7	35.0	39.5	-33.6	32.6	44.0
11	1.09	2.29	43.9	0.52	1.26	57.0	20.8	-2.6	84.2	25.4	-11.3	66.4	62.9
12	0.63	1.23	69.1	0.43	0.95	66.3	20.1	-6.9	74.5	26.9	3.5	81.2	72.8
13	0.75	1.29	65.6	1.12	2.17	18.9	32.4	30.1	34.8	39.2	22.6	37.9	39.3
14	0.56	1.09	72.4	0.52	1.16	59.2	25.1	8.5	68.5	16.2	8.8	75.4	68.9
15	1.28	2.48	37.2	2.02	4.74	0.0	29.7	-6.3	71.4	17.8	-6.5	79.3	47.0
16	0.76	1.87	57.0	0.61	1.58	47.7	19.8	6.7	75.1	27.4	2.3	83.4	65.8
17	1.09	1.85	50.2	0.74	1.42	46.6	35.8	11.6	56.3	32.0	0.3	85.2	59.6
18	0.41	0.81	79.7	0.36	0.70	73.7	19.2	4.3	80.9	33.0	1.7	82.1	79.1
19	0.85	1.76	56.6	0.51	1.03	62.0	22.4	11.3	63.2	22.5	-12.2	65.9	61.9
20	0.76	1.79	58.3	0.73	1.85	38.1	24.9	-11.0	62.8	25.2	-10.0	69.0	57.0
21	0.51	1.02	74.4	0.64	1.49	48.5	21.0	-6.0	76.2	24.9	-13.9	61.5	65.1
22	1.84	3.71	10.3	0.45	0.96	65.7	25.9	-7.0	71.5	17.7	-13.9	64.7	53.1
23	1.35	2.60	34.1	0.61	1.26	54.2	26.8	-10.4	63.3	35.7	33.3	34.3	46.5
24	0.96	1.99	51.1	0.41	0.89	68.3	21.7	8.4	70.3	17.3	2.9	86.7	69.1
25	0.81	1.52	61.0	0.73	1.52	44.9	28.9	-10.4	62.4	29.2	-0.7	85.7	63.5
26	3.07	6.50	0.0	0.93	2.11	26.3	21.4	-7.9	71.7	22.7	-7.6	74.9	43.2
27	0.61	1.18	70.1	2.61	5.32	0.0	37.5	-2.9	75.7	29.3	-15.8	55.7	50.4
28	0.80	1.60	60.1	0.68	1.44	48.2	33.7	5.3	72.0	32.4	-28.7	35.7	54.0
29	0.84	1.72	57.5	0.71	1.51	46.0	23.3	-2.2	84.0	25.5	8.0	73.0	65.1
30	0.73	1.41	64.2	0.85	2.10	29.1	33.7	-4.9	72.9	33.9	-8.8	67.7	58.5
31	1.43	2.54	33.3	5.09	8.82	0.0	31.4	-2.3	79.9	36.9	3.9	76.0	47.3
32	0.86	1.81	55.7	0.44	1.00	65.0	23.1	11.0	63.6	32.5	7.5	70.8	63.8
33	0.67	1.25	67.8	0.57	1.05	59.8	21.4	-5.4	77.5	28.5	-14.2	59.3	66.1
34	0.55	1.24	70.5	0.50	1.31	56.7	33.4	34.4	34.3	22.5	-2.3	85.5	61.7
35	0.64	1.28	68.0	0.75	1.53	44.0	29.8	-7.9	67.7	28.8	-21.5	44.6	56.0
36	0.57	1.27	69.8	0.47	0.94	65.3	17.8	-4.1	82.1	19.5	-9.5	72.6	72.4
37	1.34	2.48	35.9	0.87	1.87	33.3	25.6	1.7	84.0	32.4	16.9	52.2	51.3
38	0.56	1.24	70.4	0.43	1.09	63.5	16.6	-1.6	88.4	22.0	-2.0	86.4	77.2
39	0.98	1.95	51.3	2.00	4.20	0.0	30.9	-2.3	80.1	41.3	-3.6	74.8	51.5
40	0.55	1.04	73.4	0.62	1.21	54.8	23.1	16.2	51.7	32.1	37.3	35.9	53.9
41	1.46	2.77	29.2	0.60	1.34	52.9	25.3	-22.7	38.1	20.0	0.0	91.2	52.8
42	0.61	1.15	70.5	0.65	1.57	46.5	30.7	15.3	50.2	38.7	-1.9	79.2	61.6
43	0.78	1.51	61.7	0.56	1.14	58.2	25.7	8.3	68.7	18.7	-10.2	71.5	65.0
44	0.73	1.42	64.1	0.69	1.39	49.1	37.6	-23.3	32.3	38.8	-33.4	32.9	44.6
45	0.51	1.02	74.5	0.41	0.96	67.0	32.8	24.2	34.6	27.8	18.8	50.5	56.6
46	0.51	1.03	74.4	0.42	0.96	66.3	29.6	-3.5	77.9	27.5	-15.7	56.8	68.9
47	1.35	1.86	44.5	0.86	1.55	40.1	67.9	-7.3	51.3	39.2	-18.6	45.8	45.4
48	0.63	1.38	66.9	0.71	1.46	46.8	18.6	-2.7	85.0	22.3	-10.3	69.8	67.1
49	1.03	2.22	46.2	0.63	1.64	45.8	25.9	17.4	47.5	26.4	12.7	63.2	50.7
50	0.55	1.03	73.6	0.52	1.44	53.2	23.5	-4.7	78.1	18.3	-2.6	86.7	72.9
Avg	0.88	1.73	57.8	0.86	1.82	45.6	27.2	-0.9	65.4	28.0	-4.4	64.4	58.3

Detailed Results for Rank 15

Team: UPMC_IBML
Affiliation: UPMC, United States
Submitted on: 2012-08-24

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.74	1.12	68.2	0.61	0.88	62.3	26.5	-5.6	74.6	24.9	-12.8	63.6	67.2
2	0.89	1.20	63.8	1.41	2.49	5.0	33.0	-20.9	36.2	29.1	-20.0	47.6	38.1
3	0.68	0.99	71.3	0.69	1.25	51.8	32.8	-7.8	66.4	31.0	14.1	58.4	62.0
4	0.87	1.30	62.8	0.69	0.99	57.2	39.2	3.3	74.0	29.7	-7.9	71.2	66.3
5	0.85	1.37	62.2	0.67	1.02	57.0	28.4	-13.7	55.0	34.4	-24.0	37.2	52.8
6	0.83	1.32	63.3	0.60	1.08	58.2	39.6	9.6	59.2	30.5	-3.7	79.4	65.0
7	1.07	1.63	53.7	0.97	1.59	35.9	34.0	-12.3	55.7	33.4	-8.1	69.2	53.6
8	0.90	1.40	60.8	1.48	2.06	9.6	36.6	-16.7	44.1	33.9	-12.3	60.8	43.8
9	0.93	1.36	60.6	0.87	1.23	46.5	36.9	-9.1	61.6	35.8	1.6	81.2	62.5
10	0.77	1.13	67.3	0.65	0.97	58.9	29.9	-12.5	56.9	20.7	-2.7	85.5	67.2
11	1.12	1.81	50.2	0.67	1.05	56.8	29.0	1.2	83.7	32.1	19.5	47.2	59.5
12	0.65	0.94	72.6	0.48	0.67	70.5	46.1	-11.6	51.5	49.5	-7.9	62.6	64.3
13	1.04	1.52	56.1	0.94	1.47	39.4	43.4	26.5	29.6	39.3	7.6	67.6	48.2
14	0.65	1.02	71.6	0.63	0.87	61.8	36.0	10.5	58.7	28.4	4.1	79.4	67.9
15	0.77	1.20	66.3	0.72	1.29	49.9	37.3	9.5	60.6	36.6	10.9	62.2	59.7
16	0.49	0.71	79.4	0.57	1.08	59.0	34.1	13.4	53.0	31.5	4.6	77.1	67.1
17	1.10	1.53	54.5	0.77	1.23	49.6	51.0	6.9	60.0	42.5	-16.6	48.3	53.1
18	0.51	0.74	78.4	0.64	0.92	60.4	33.9	-22.4	34.1	27.2	-8.6	70.9	60.9
19	0.91	1.63	57.3	0.51	0.80	67.2	36.0	-8.3	63.9	28.6	-8.7	70.2	64.6
20	0.73	1.05	69.3	0.69	1.03	56.4	34.4	11.9	56.2	38.0	6.6	70.2	63.0
21	0.76	1.11	67.8	0.56	1.04	60.2	36.1	-12.3	54.6	29.6	-12.8	61.7	61.1
22	1.38	2.36	36.7	0.79	1.19	49.7	34.6	2.2	78.7	29.0	-12.8	61.8	56.7
23	1.22	1.88	47.0	1.18	1.68	27.2	49.3	-2.9	70.1	55.7	37.3	25.5	42.4
24	1.45	2.27	36.5	0.86	1.27	46.1	40.5	-5.1	69.2	35.3	-7.6	69.5	55.3
25	0.84	1.24	64.2	0.93	1.47	39.5	45.4	-11.2	52.8	44.5	38.1	30.4	46.7
26	1.11	1.77	50.8	0.81	1.25	47.9	29.9	-10.1	62.6	36.7	-24.8	34.6	49.0
27	0.79	1.19	66.1	1.07	1.54	33.5	44.8	-4.8	67.8	32.4	-25.1	35.9	50.8
28	0.95	1.98	51.4	0.55	0.81	65.4	41.5	21.1	31.7	28.9	-10.8	65.9	53.6
29	0.92	1.31	61.5	0.88	1.52	40.0	48.4	-38.8	27.3	41.1	-15.1	51.9	45.2
30	0.73	1.23	66.8	0.88	1.40	42.7	39.9	-20.4	34.1	45.8	-9.6	60.8	51.1
31	1.29	1.79	46.9	0.92	1.32	43.1	45.9	-26.0	28.4	33.3	7.8	69.8	47.1
32	0.70	1.06	69.9	0.57	0.80	65.1	35.3	7.2	66.8	32.5	13.0	59.9	65.4
33	0.56	0.80	76.7	0.54	0.83	65.4	39.4	-2.0	77.0	30.6	-7.4	71.9	72.7
34	1.10	1.62	53.1	1.82	2.76	0.0	49.5	53.5	26.7	59.4	-6.6	60.8	35.2
35	0.63	0.94	73.1	0.88	1.55	39.6	37.2	-1.4	79.3	29.8	-0.2	86.4	69.6
36	0.58	0.78	76.5	0.64	0.87	61.2	33.4	-11.6	57.6	29.2	-12.3	62.7	64.5
37	1.72	2.30	30.4	2.30	3.27	0.0	67.4	-36.4	18.3	51.8	1.5	74.2	30.7
38	0.73	1.28	66.0	0.52	0.77	67.3	36.6	-10.9	57.5	23.6	7.4	75.0	66.5
39	1.08	1.62	53.9	2.24	3.31	0.0	47.6	17.2	37.7	46.4	9.6	60.4	38.0
40	1.09	1.60	53.9	1.02	1.33	39.7	55.6	-25.4	23.9	55.8	6.9	61.7	44.8
41	0.99	1.52	57.1	0.62	0.93	60.7	33.1	-25.5	34.4	22.8	-0.6	88.7	60.2
42	0.97	1.48	58.0	1.01	1.47	37.0	58.1	-15.3	37.2	31.9	6.4	73.2	51.4
43	1.09	1.66	53.0	0.80	1.11	51.2	37.2	-1.2	79.8	33.2	-25.0	35.9	55.0
44	0.79	1.16	66.5	0.93	1.55	37.9	44.5	2.1	74.3	35.5	-5.5	73.4	63.0
45	0.52	0.77	77.9	0.48	0.69	70.1	38.9	20.5	34.3	51.0	2.1	73.4	63.9
46	0.65	1.12	70.0	0.55	0.83	65.1	39.2	11.5	54.9	33.8	-10.2	64.9	63.7
47	1.20	1.52	52.4	0.87	1.42	42.6	65.1	-1.1	67.0	34.4	-6.5	71.9	58.5
48	0.56	1.03	73.2	0.64	0.98	59.2	36.8	-15.9	45.8	30.3	-17.3	52.3	57.6
49	0.57	0.87	75.3	0.52	0.71	68.6	28.7	19.2	42.1	36.8	15.8	52.4	59.6
50	0.53	0.77	77.6	0.69	0.99	57.2	31.6	-8.6	65.2	33.7	8.8	67.6	66.9
Avg	0.88	1.34	62.0	0.85	1.29	47.9	39.8	-3.6	53.8	35.4	-2.4	62.9	56.7

Detailed Results for Rank 16

Team: BioMedIA
Affiliation: Imperial College London, United Kingdom
Submitted on: 2013-02-25

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.78	1.58	60.8	0.72	1.39	47.8	32.6	-3.2	77.3	25.6	-10.8	67.3	63.3
2	0.70	1.33	65.9	1.24	2.39	10.4	26.7	-14.9	53.1	24.6	-11.3	66.9	49.1
3	1.04	2.08	48.0	2.89	5.56	0.0	32.1	5.8	71.5	41.2	18.1	45.9	41.3
4	0.72	1.49	63.3	0.59	1.38	52.4	35.2	-3.1	76.3	32.3	-19.8	46.4	59.6
5	1.11	2.00	47.7	0.47	0.97	64.5	28.8	-2.0	81.9	30.7	-15.0	56.8	62.7
6	0.80	1.50	61.5	0.79	1.75	38.1	34.6	10.4	59.7	26.0	-0.2	88.3	61.9
7	0.72	1.29	66.1	0.74	1.48	45.5	36.9	-15.2	47.4	28.1	8.7	70.3	57.3
8	0.64	1.21	69.0	0.49	1.20	59.3	26.9	-16.4	49.3	34.6	-22.0	41.2	54.7
9	0.75	1.50	62.5	0.81	1.79	36.6	38.4	-30.3	32.0	40.1	-9.4	63.8	48.7
10	0.87	1.59	58.6	0.60	1.50	49.3	35.3	-24.0	33.4	40.6	-30.6	32.1	43.4
11	1.14	2.33	42.4	0.58	1.33	53.7	26.7	-1.6	83.8	34.9	-10.2	64.4	61.1
12	0.65	1.27	67.8	0.46	0.99	64.6	29.0	-6.4	71.7	38.5	10.0	63.1	66.8
13	0.79	1.32	64.3	1.19	2.26	15.0	36.9	24.3	32.7	40.3	29.8	32.2	36.0
14	0.59	1.11	71.4	0.57	1.20	56.7	31.8	12.2	56.7	30.5	11.3	64.2	62.3
15	1.30	2.51	36.3	2.07	4.84	0.0	34.1	0.1	83.7	30.9	-2.7	81.1	50.3
16	0.79	1.91	55.8	0.70	1.80	40.1	30.7	6.3	71.0	36.4	11.8	60.6	56.9
17	1.17	1.95	47.1	0.80	1.50	43.2	42.0	8.7	60.1	33.4	-2.2	81.0	57.9
18	0.44	0.84	78.7	0.40	0.74	72.0	27.6	-1.8	82.9	37.4	-0.9	81.8	78.9
19	0.91	1.82	54.7	0.50	1.02	62.7	35.6	6.7	67.7	31.0	-14.7	57.1	60.6
20	0.80	1.85	56.6	0.74	1.83	38.1	33.3	-14.5	50.8	34.1	-8.4	68.3	53.4
21	0.51	1.01	74.5	0.64	1.50	48.1	29.6	-7.0	69.9	30.7	-15.4	55.8	62.1
22	1.71	3.59	13.2	0.51	1.01	62.7	31.1	-8.7	65.2	26.9	-15.6	57.1	49.6
23	1.37	2.61	33.3	0.64	1.30	52.6	32.6	-6.0	70.8	49.8	32.1	28.1	46.2
24	0.91	1.85	54.2	0.43	0.90	67.3	29.5	5.7	72.9	28.7	6.7	74.1	67.1
25	0.82	1.53	60.5	0.75	1.52	44.4	34.9	-11.3	57.5	40.2	3.3	75.9	59.6
26	3.88	8.12	0.0	0.98	2.19	22.9	25.6	-3.2	80.5	31.5	-8.2	69.8	43.3
27	0.64	1.19	69.3	2.70	5.50	0.0	41.9	0.9	78.3	26.1	-10.0	68.6	54.1
28	0.79	1.56	60.8	0.68	1.44	48.1	39.7	3.9	72.2	36.9	-29.2	33.8	53.7
29	0.86	1.77	56.4	0.81	1.70	38.8	25.7	0.6	86.5	31.8	12.6	61.0	60.7
30	0.71	1.35	65.5	0.79	1.85	36.1	38.9	-5.0	70.1	45.3	-6.7	66.7	59.6
31	1.45	2.53	32.8	6.10	10.16	0.0	32.8	2.1	79.8	38.3	5.5	72.2	46.2
32	0.86	1.78	56.2	0.47	1.03	63.7	28.1	14.7	52.7	36.7	6.3	71.3	61.0
33	0.68	1.26	67.4	0.55	1.04	60.7	29.2	-2.3	80.8	37.7	-11.7	60.3	67.3
34	0.59	1.28	69.1	0.55	1.40	53.2	38.1	38.8	32.1	28.9	8.3	70.8	56.3
35	0.65	1.29	67.6	0.72	1.50	45.7	36.3	2.0	78.4	33.5	-20.9	43.8	58.9
36	0.59	1.29	69.0	0.45	0.86	67.5	28.0	-7.7	69.0	20.8	-3.6	83.7	72.3
37	1.32	2.41	37.4	0.80	1.57	41.6	32.6	3.6	76.5	42.0	23.0	36.0	47.9
38	0.58	1.29	69.1	0.48	1.11	61.5	26.2	-4.6	77.0	30.7	3.0	80.6	72.0
39	1.08	2.07	47.2	2.08	4.28	0.0	35.4	-5.5	70.7	42.8	-2.0	77.3	48.8
40	0.55	1.06	73.0	0.68	1.29	51.4	31.0	16.4	47.5	41.6	44.7	31.7	50.9
41	1.49	2.77	28.5	0.62	1.32	52.5	31.2	-23.3	35.3	31.3	-1.7	82.9	49.8
42	0.64	1.16	69.7	0.66	1.48	48.2	34.0	21.5	34.2	41.3	0.1	81.7	58.4
43	0.82	1.56	60.3	0.57	1.13	58.2	33.2	13.4	53.4	24.8	-11.9	65.4	59.3
44	0.76	1.48	62.6	0.69	1.38	49.0	39.6	-18.8	37.8	42.2	-30.0	31.4	45.2
45	0.52	1.02	74.3	0.45	1.02	64.5	38.0	26.9	32.2	44.9	24.3	32.1	50.8
46	0.53	1.05	73.6	0.45	1.01	64.7	33.4	5.7	71.2	29.7	-10.3	66.5	69.0
47	1.34	1.85	44.7	0.85	1.53	40.7	67.1	-2.8	62.0	39.9	-20.6	41.6	47.3
48	0.63	1.39	66.6	0.75	1.50	44.8	23.3	0.3	88.5	26.9	-8.3	71.7	67.9
49	1.18	2.58	37.9	0.69	1.78	40.7	32.2	14.2	52.0	31.6	16.6	53.2	45.9
50	0.57	1.05	72.8	0.57	1.50	50.5	34.7	-5.8	70.3	28.9	0.1	87.0	70.2
Avg	0.92	1.78	56.9	0.91	1.87	44.6	33.4	-0.0	63.4	34.3	-1.8	61.3	56.6

Detailed Results for Rank 17

Team: shan_unc
Affiliation: UNC Chapel Hill, United States
Submitted on: 2012-04-28

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	1.21	2.02	45.1	0.58	0.91	62.6	23.1	-4.2	79.5	27.9	-16.7	54.6	60.5
2	1.08	1.65	53.4	1.10	2.01	22.8	29.3	-20.4	39.1	36.3	-33.6	34.0	37.3
3	1.03	1.67	54.0	1.20	2.49	11.7	27.7	20.6	39.4	33.2	20.5	44.7	37.4
4	1.33	2.13	41.1	0.99	1.96	27.6	33.0	1.8	80.2	31.4	-30.9	36.2	46.3
5	1.31	1.87	45.1	0.74	1.28	49.6	26.1	2.3	82.4	30.3	-7.0	72.8	62.5
6	1.15	1.77	50.1	0.92	1.57	37.7	28.6	9.7	64.1	20.0	9.8	71.7	55.9
7	1.01	1.48	57.3	0.75	1.23	50.3	28.3	-13.4	55.7	19.1	-1.7	88.2	62.9
8	1.17	1.70	50.7	0.64	1.10	56.6	27.2	-19.2	42.7	27.8	-17.8	52.4	50.6
9	1.02	1.56	56.0	0.53	0.95	63.2	31.7	-12.2	56.8	35.4	2.7	79.1	63.8
10	1.09	1.70	52.3	0.62	1.05	58.1	36.7	-28.2	32.8	28.4	-23.9	40.1	45.8
11	1.28	1.95	44.7	0.63	1.07	57.4	25.0	-0.5	87.1	29.7	4.1	78.9	67.0
12	0.96	1.69	55.3	0.49	0.78	68.0	22.8	4.3	79.3	27.8	16.1	55.8	64.6
13	1.38	2.02	41.5	1.63	2.96	0.0	41.3	22.2	30.6	32.2	19.8	46.5	29.7
14	1.13	1.68	51.9	0.52	0.79	67.0	31.7	10.5	60.7	16.8	1.5	89.6	67.3
15	1.12	1.83	49.9	0.99	1.98	27.0	25.6	17.5	47.5	24.9	3.4	82.3	51.7
16	0.78	1.57	61.0	0.48	0.77	68.6	21.9	2.2	84.7	30.5	-7.6	71.4	71.5
17	1.49	2.13	37.7	0.69	1.09	55.2	37.1	23.2	32.6	26.5	6.3	75.9	50.3
18	1.04	1.71	53.3	0.58	0.99	60.8	24.8	8.4	69.0	20.5	10.0	71.2	63.6
19	0.87	1.44	60.9	0.76	1.37	47.2	26.3	20.1	41.1	26.2	-0.2	88.0	59.3
20	1.10	1.87	49.8	0.74	1.21	51.2	27.0	1.2	84.5	30.3	-16.6	53.7	59.8
21	0.80	1.57	60.4	0.47	0.96	64.8	26.6	-3.1	80.4	19.2	-2.1	87.4	73.2
22	2.25	3.72	1.5	0.73	1.62	42.9	27.4	-1.6	83.5	25.5	-19.7	49.6	44.4
23	1.26	1.97	44.8	0.99	1.43	38.3	26.7	-5.6	74.5	38.2	47.9	33.2	47.7
24	1.94	3.06	14.7	0.53	0.83	65.8	26.4	15.1	52.7	26.4	2.5	83.3	54.1
25	0.92	1.32	61.4	0.73	1.27	50.1	29.4	2.1	81.2	36.9	11.6	60.8	63.4
26	6.75	11.56	0.0	2.07	3.68	0.0	41.5	-16.8	41.5	53.1	-34.1	26.6	17.0
27	0.93	1.46	59.3	2.01	3.79	0.0	41.2	-1.9	76.3	27.1	-21.0	46.5	45.5
28	1.61	2.98	22.9	0.82	1.50	42.3	50.5	-17.4	36.0	33.9	-29.5	35.1	34.1
29	0.76	1.27	65.4	0.70	1.21	52.4	29.3	-22.8	36.2	34.0	14.0	57.2	52.8
30	0.95	1.55	57.4	0.83	1.52	41.6	27.7	-7.1	70.6	44.9	-0.3	79.5	62.3
31	1.97	2.72	18.9	3.21	5.79	0.0	39.4	-5.6	68.6	28.0	7.4	72.9	40.1
32	1.17	1.82	49.0	0.64	1.18	54.8	32.8	30.2	34.6	19.8	10.7	70.0	52.1
33	0.71	1.15	68.4	0.48	0.87	66.6	30.4	-4.0	76.5	26.9	5.1	78.1	72.4
34	0.76	1.22	66.1	0.80	1.33	46.5	38.4	35.9	32.0	26.5	15.6	57.4	50.5
35	0.89	1.43	60.6	0.80	1.47	43.7	20.4	7.4	73.3	29.1	-11.8	63.7	60.3
36	0.80	1.46	62.0	0.51	0.87	65.5	18.7	1.9	86.8	22.0	-5.2	80.0	73.6
37	1.74	2.98	20.2	1.79	3.22	0.0	30.8	15.8	49.0	36.6	41.8	33.9	25.8
38	0.91	1.61	57.6	0.45	0.80	68.9	19.5	4.7	80.1	19.1	3.1	85.4	73.0
39	1.20	1.94	46.6	1.89	3.43	0.0	39.3	-8.1	62.7	35.8	-16.0	52.6	40.5
40	0.86	1.29	63.0	0.65	0.90	60.5	26.9	-2.0	82.8	37.4	43.4	33.5	60.0
41	1.44	2.15	38.3	0.65	1.08	56.7	26.4	-20.5	40.2	24.6	-3.1	83.0	54.5
42	0.93	1.33	61.1	0.78	1.15	50.9	28.9	9.2	65.2	29.3	17.7	52.0	57.3
43	1.07	1.58	54.3	0.51	0.83	66.4	31.2	8.5	65.6	20.2	-7.6	76.0	65.6
44	0.98	1.54	57.0	0.59	1.04	59.4	26.9	0.7	85.9	34.6	-27.0	34.8	59.3
45	0.77	1.40	63.5	0.49	0.84	66.8	31.3	20.3	38.4	33.6	27.6	35.2	51.0
46	0.89	1.44	60.2	0.43	0.72	71.1	28.2	8.5	67.1	28.4	-2.8	82.0	70.1
47	1.30	1.72	47.4	0.73	1.00	56.0	64.3	-2.8	63.3	30.5	-3.4	79.9	61.6
48	0.97	1.81	53.3	0.66	1.08	56.5	20.7	9.3	68.8	20.8	-3.3	84.3	65.7
49	1.23	1.89	46.5	0.54	0.80	66.2	32.2	28.2	34.9	29.0	17.3	53.0	50.1
50	0.81	1.27	64.6	0.62	1.08	57.7	23.3	-5.1	77.4	36.9	4.8	74.3	68.5
Avg	1.24	1.99	49.2	0.85	1.50	47.1	30.2	2.4	61.5	29.3	0.4	62.6	55.1

Detailed Results for Rank 18

Team: SNU_SPL
Affiliation: Seoul National University, Korea Republic of
Submitted on: 2010-06-23

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.70	1.20	67.8	0.72	1.44	46.9	20.4	10.4	66.3	41.3	-12.2	57.6	59.6
2	0.86	1.71	57.2	1.22	2.41	10.8	28.8	-19.4	41.5	27.9	-23.7	40.8	37.6
3	0.72	1.11	68.7	0.46	0.70	70.6	26.1	13.3	56.9	44.5	26.3	30.4	56.6
4	0.86	1.65	57.9	0.46	0.68	71.1	27.2	14.8	52.9	21.3	-10.7	69.5	62.9
5	1.85	3.27	13.6	0.58	0.92	62.1	29.3	13.6	54.8	36.1	-1.8	80.5	52.8
6	1.00	1.60	55.8	0.52	0.80	66.7	28.6	19.0	42.6	26.3	4.0	80.5	61.4
7	1.46	5.51	18.5	0.67	1.06	56.2	30.0	-9.4	64.3	32.7	-1.6	82.5	55.4
8	1.28	4.95	22.5	0.57	1.00	61.1	29.8	-16.2	48.5	37.8	-21.2	41.2	43.3
9	1.36	3.57	20.6	0.52	0.82	66.3	30.1	-17.6	45.1	36.6	8.7	66.5	49.6
10	1.21	2.15	43.5	0.56	0.91	63.3	40.3	-18.6	38.0	28.8	-17.2	53.2	49.5
11	1.52	3.01	24.5	0.66	1.30	51.6	26.4	6.9	71.6	35.2	2.2	80.0	56.9
12	0.74	1.39	64.1	0.39	0.58	75.4	29.4	9.6	63.9	35.4	11.3	62.0	66.4
13	1.03	1.77	52.5	0.64	1.13	55.8	43.0	33.2	29.8	34.1	25.7	35.0	43.3
14	0.82	1.28	64.1	0.66	1.23	53.3	37.2	14.1	49.8	21.4	-1.5	87.6	63.7
15	0.63	1.14	70.4	0.48	0.79	68.1	26.5	24.3	37.5	29.1	6.8	73.7	62.4
16	1.16	3.07	31.4	0.72	1.56	44.4	34.9	21.7	33.6	39.6	6.6	69.5	44.7
17	1.58	2.49	30.6	0.58	0.86	63.7	34.5	32.6	33.8	25.3	1.2	86.4	53.6
18	1.35	2.47	35.8	0.47	0.72	70.0	30.6	12.7	56.2	26.6	6.2	76.0	59.5
19	0.85	1.54	59.8	0.47	0.82	67.9	29.0	19.5	41.3	29.2	-2.4	82.3	62.8
20	1.34	2.27	38.8	0.54	0.96	62.6	25.6	5.4	75.4	35.3	-6.1	72.4	62.3
21	0.48	0.74	79.2	0.97	2.34	20.0	30.3	2.6	79.7	31.9	-8.2	69.6	62.1
22	2.21	4.35	2.4	0.54	0.80	66.1	25.7	6.0	74.1	30.9	-3.6	79.2	55.4
23	1.11	2.30	43.4	0.61	0.94	60.9	29.5	4.1	76.8	48.7	52.2	28.6	52.4
24	0.78	1.52	61.5	0.51	0.76	67.7	30.2	17.6	45.1	34.5	5.7	73.6	62.0
25	0.66	1.04	70.9	0.63	1.10	56.7	26.3	0.0	87.6	34.5	0.5	83.9	74.8
26	1.59	4.87	15.6	0.65	1.22	53.5	23.9	12.0	61.0	34.4	-6.9	71.3	50.4
27	1.28	2.48	37.1	0.56	0.87	64.0	36.4	1.9	78.5	24.6	-10.7	68.0	61.9
28	1.91	4.28	8.9	0.62	1.09	57.3	38.5	11.9	54.4	38.0	-28.1	33.3	38.5
29	0.70	1.14	68.7	1.31	2.63	7.9	25.4	-6.4	73.2	39.2	0.8	81.1	57.7
30	1.42	2.38	35.6	0.50	0.87	65.7	30.5	5.0	74.1	51.8	-9.0	59.4	58.7
31	1.53	2.50	31.5	0.76	1.33	48.0	28.7	5.4	74.0	23.7	4.8	80.1	58.4
32	1.51	2.80	27.7	0.41	0.58	74.7	33.2	29.6	34.4	26.5	23.6	41.5	44.6
33	1.22	2.12	43.6	0.58	0.86	63.3	38.9	12.3	53.3	45.9	-2.9	74.1	58.6
34	1.13	4.52	25.6	0.54	1.04	60.9	39.6	50.0	31.4	33.1	28.4	35.4	38.3
35	0.84	1.36	62.7	0.50	0.73	68.6	35.2	7.5	66.1	37.4	-20.7	42.4	60.0
36	0.66	1.28	67.5	0.47	0.75	69.4	19.0	-0.2	90.6	24.1	-4.1	81.2	77.2
37	1.14	1.91	48.3	1.48	3.15	2.6	32.9	33.3	34.5	38.3	43.1	33.2	29.6
38	0.96	2.09	49.7	0.42	0.69	72.2	29.3	10.2	62.5	23.8	1.3	86.9	67.9
39	1.43	2.95	27.2	2.10	4.20	0.0	36.3	14.7	49.0	44.1	-9.9	61.0	34.3
40	0.78	1.45	62.7	0.61	0.91	61.5	26.6	13.5	56.1	50.8	36.2	27.6	52.0
41	1.21	1.95	46.3	0.84	1.58	40.1	33.7	-23.5	34.1	39.2	-28.7	32.7	38.3
42	1.21	2.44	39.4	0.78	1.62	41.2	39.8	10.0	58.2	34.8	5.8	73.2	53.0
43	0.89	1.40	60.9	0.73	1.24	50.6	32.8	16.0	47.6	26.0	-9.9	68.9	57.0
44	1.10	1.82	50.4	0.63	1.07	57.7	42.1	-12.5	51.4	41.9	-36.3	31.6	47.8
45	0.65	1.21	68.8	0.64	1.21	54.3	35.0	30.1	33.6	46.2	29.5	29.7	46.6
46	1.34	2.25	39.2	0.39	0.57	75.5	38.5	22.5	31.9	39.2	3.3	76.3	55.7
47	1.28	1.76	47.4	0.82	1.33	46.0	70.0	-4.5	56.6	29.2	-9.9	67.6	54.4
48	0.91	1.77	55.3	0.60	1.01	59.8	23.8	4.4	78.6	25.0	-9.8	69.6	65.8
49	1.56	2.94	24.6	0.97	2.32	20.5	33.5	34.9	34.2	36.9	4.9	74.0	38.3
50	1.30	2.33	38.7	0.62	1.23	54.6	27.4	7.4	70.1	42.5	1.7	78.0	60.3
Avg	1.14	2.30	44.8	0.67	1.22	54.6	32.0	9.7	55.1	34.4	0.9	62.8	54.3

Detailed Results for Rank 19

Team: UIiibiKnee
Affiliation: University of Iowa, United States
Submitted on: 2013-04-09

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	0.83	1.26	64.1	0.73	1.39	47.8	23.2	22.7	39.1	22.8	-13.1	63.9	53.7
2	0.87	1.32	62.5	1.33	2.05	14.6	28.5	-15.8	50.1	46.4	-46.0	29.6	39.2
3	0.80	1.18	66.1	0.86	1.46	42.1	32.4	38.8	34.8	20.5	8.7	73.8	54.2
4	1.08	1.76	51.7	1.10	1.84	26.4	74.0	-64.9	15.2	85.6	-84.3	12.3	26.4
5	0.65	1.04	71.3	0.56	0.94	62.4	31.7	15.2	49.8	25.1	-16.2	56.9	60.1
6	0.87	1.47	60.4	0.79	1.39	45.7	31.9	27.1	35.0	35.2	6.4	71.8	53.3
7	0.71	1.12	68.8	0.88	1.38	42.9	33.3	4.0	75.0	28.9	6.6	74.2	65.2
8	0.73	1.12	68.4	0.77	1.21	50.1	33.6	-13.0	54.2	30.7	-15.9	54.9	56.9
9	0.80	1.25	65.0	0.74	1.25	50.1	39.2	-13.5	50.4	36.8	-15.1	53.8	54.8
10	1.13	1.85	49.4	0.86	1.59	39.2	33.4	-11.0	58.9	34.8	-26.2	34.7	45.5
11	0.70	1.07	69.8	0.75	1.17	51.7	30.5	36.0	35.7	23.2	2.8	84.3	60.4
12	1.68	3.22	18.0	0.76	1.20	50.5	29.5	11.6	59.3	31.6	5.8	74.5	50.6
13	0.74	1.11	68.2	0.72	1.27	50.5	46.1	50.2	28.3	42.8	13.6	54.2	50.3
14	0.76	1.18	66.8	0.85	1.87	33.7	38.9	34.1	31.7	26.2	5.0	78.6	52.7
15	0.54	0.77	77.5	0.68	1.15	54.2	36.0	38.1	33.1	40.1	-23.9	35.0	49.9
16	1.10	2.06	46.9	0.98	1.54	36.5	33.0	15.0	49.8	29.4	-9.9	67.5	50.2
17	1.93	3.07	14.7	0.88	1.35	43.6	47.9	-16.1	40.3	47.8	-24.7	30.1	32.2
18	0.63	0.96	72.9	0.45	0.66	72.0	30.4	34.5	35.7	32.7	4.6	76.4	64.2
19	0.64	0.93	72.9	0.62	1.03	58.6	32.3	43.1	34.8	23.9	-13.2	63.3	57.4
20	4.92	8.37	0.0	0.66	1.01	57.7	64.2	-48.3	19.8	35.3	-2.2	80.1	39.4
21	0.90	1.63	57.3	1.17	1.76	26.0	28.1	9.4	64.9	22.9	-9.5	71.1	54.9
22	1.24	2.18	42.2	0.77	1.29	48.3	33.0	16.0	47.4	25.2	-22.2	44.8	45.7
23	0.78	1.17	66.6	0.87	1.38	43.4	35.5	31.3	33.3	40.4	37.5	32.2	43.9
24	0.88	1.48	60.0	0.60	0.96	60.9	33.6	36.9	34.2	21.0	-7.8	75.2	57.6
25	0.99	1.64	55.4	0.88	1.52	40.3	24.5	25.3	38.5	31.5	15.9	54.5	47.2
26	1.05	1.51	56.1	0.71	1.07	55.0	44.9	-40.9	28.9	78.1	-77.5	15.6	38.9
27	1.02	1.89	51.2	0.93	1.41	40.8	38.5	7.5	64.5	27.7	-19.2	49.7	51.5
28	2.12	4.55	4.3	1.09	1.80	27.6	37.5	18.6	39.4	34.2	-11.2	62.7	33.5
29	1.08	1.99	48.4	1.24	1.95	19.7	28.0	-9.3	65.4	39.6	-10.9	61.0	48.6
30	0.93	1.34	60.9	0.68	1.10	55.2	32.8	33.2	34.6	28.8	0.4	86.5	59.3
31	1.31	1.96	44.0	1.02	1.87	28.3	45.8	2.4	72.9	53.3	-9.7	57.4	50.6
32	0.74	1.34	65.0	0.48	0.74	69.2	36.8	46.5	32.7	39.9	6.2	70.1	59.2
33	1.72	3.56	12.8	0.80	1.14	50.7	28.7	31.1	36.5	23.5	-5.0	79.8	45.0
34	0.76	1.35	64.5	0.94	1.86	31.1	47.8	75.2	27.5	26.9	2.7	82.8	51.5
35	0.82	1.32	63.5	1.19	1.90	22.4	34.1	11.5	57.5	44.0	-33.3	30.6	43.5
36	0.97	1.67	55.4	0.76	1.41	46.5	23.1	24.3	39.1	23.1	-3.9	82.1	55.8
37	0.91	1.54	58.4	1.14	1.83	25.4	34.7	30.8	33.7	39.4	28.3	32.7	37.5
38	1.10	1.85	50.1	0.70	1.05	55.7	26.1	30.0	37.7	33.7	3.2	78.8	55.6
39	1.17	1.80	49.2	2.12	3.33	0.0	66.1	-57.8	18.9	75.5	-73.0	16.8	21.2
40	0.71	1.06	69.8	0.56	0.81	65.3	33.7	41.4	34.2	34.2	44.6	35.0	51.0
41	0.91	1.42	60.2	0.71	1.12	54.0	20.8	-9.3	68.8	21.4	-13.0	64.8	61.9
42	1.11	1.67	52.4	0.64	1.01	58.5	45.7	14.9	44.0	33.1	1.1	83.3	59.6
43	0.76	1.28	65.5	0.51	0.75	68.0	28.3	12.9	56.7	26.5	-17.6	53.4	60.9
44	0.89	1.33	62.0	0.94	1.37	41.3	38.7	26.8	31.8	41.4	-37.3	31.8	41.7
45	0.82	1.09	67.0	0.44	0.74	70.5	35.1	42.2	33.5	24.5	-2.9	83.3	63.6
46	1.29	2.24	40.3	0.91	1.33	43.2	49.4	-15.0	42.2	46.1	-41.6	29.7	38.8
47	1.56	1.94	38.9	1.08	1.58	32.2	63.8	33.7	20.0	35.7	-13.0	58.4	37.4
48	0.70	1.10	69.2	0.76	1.30	48.5	27.4	23.2	37.1	24.8	-10.3	68.7	55.9
49	1.71	3.20	17.6	0.82	1.30	46.8	33.8	35.7	34.1	29.4	13.9	59.5	39.5
50	1.30	2.41	37.8	0.96	1.48	38.5	32.5	2.2	79.6	31.1	-14.2	58.2	53.5
Avg	1.09	1.81	53.6	0.85	1.38	44.9	36.8	14.4	42.4	35.1	-10.3	57.6	49.6

Detailed Results for Rank 20

Team: Quan Wang
Affiliation: Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, United States
Submitted on: 2013-11-26

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	1.24	2.04	44.3	0.99	2.39	18.4	24.8	15.6	52.2	16.2	-0.5	91.9	51.7
2	1.43	2.71	30.7	1.72	3.12	0.0	27.0	-22.0	37.3	25.2	-19.4	50.4	29.6
3	1.55	2.92	25.0	1.91	3.45	0.0	21.8	12.4	61.1	29.2	-0.4	86.4	43.1
4	2.99	5.49	0.0	3.61	6.72	0.0	27.9	2.9	80.1	15.5	9.5	74.3	38.6
5	2.37	4.84	0.0	2.62	5.27	0.0	21.7	7.1	73.4	28.0	-2.5	82.8	39.0
6	0.96	1.54	57.5	2.13	4.00	0.0	24.5	5.6	75.5	26.4	-9.6	69.4	50.6
7	0.97	1.53	57.3	0.82	1.26	47.4	25.2	7.9	70.0	20.8	19.5	52.1	56.7
8	1.04	1.75	52.8	0.93	2.14	25.8	23.6	-16.7	50.3	19.2	-14.1	63.6	48.1
9	1.07	1.82	51.0	1.41	3.31	4.9	29.1	-20.0	40.1	29.2	13.9	59.6	38.9
10	1.57	2.92	24.8	0.56	0.91	63.2	31.0	-22.2	35.4	17.1	-8.1	76.4	49.9
11	2.24	3.95	1.8	1.44	2.86	3.8	25.5	10.4	64.0	22.4	5.2	79.8	37.3
12	3.25	6.87	0.0	2.24	4.25	0.0	24.1	-1.2	85.9	32.6	20.8	44.4	32.6
13	1.04	1.60	54.7	2.07	3.50	0.0	33.3	30.6	34.4	35.4	14.4	55.8	36.2
14	1.18	2.03	45.6	0.78	1.74	38.9	26.1	20.3	40.8	20.3	23.3	44.8	42.5
15	2.82	5.39	0.0	2.27	4.45	0.0	25.4	1.4	84.9	20.5	1.0	89.1	43.5
16	4.33	8.42	0.0	2.01	4.08	0.0	34.3	1.1	81.4	26.6	3.4	81.4	40.7
17	2.30	3.79	0.3	2.24	3.56	0.0	33.4	5.5	71.6	45.2	-23.7	33.1	26.3
18	1.10	2.19	45.2	1.06	1.87	27.0	19.8	1.7	86.8	22.5	12.0	66.2	56.3
19	2.44	4.97	0.0	1.37	3.09	6.0	28.6	28.4	36.6	22.2	1.6	87.1	32.4
20	1.73	3.01	19.8	0.74	1.21	50.9	33.7	-16.6	45.7	25.2	-21.1	47.1	40.9
21	0.73	2.46	49.3	0.38	0.69	73.4	22.9	-3.9	80.3	24.4	-10.8	67.7	67.7
22	3.55	5.91	0.0	1.64	3.21	0.0	26.2	-13.7	55.9	16.3	-4.8	83.3	34.8
23	1.63	2.76	25.8	1.98	3.79	0.0	34.7	-14.2	50.8	39.0	26.9	32.8	27.4
24	3.33	5.90	0.0	1.05	2.47	16.3	24.5	26.6	38.5	22.2	8.8	72.7	31.9
25	0.91	1.69	56.3	0.87	1.47	41.5	23.1	4.0	79.8	34.6	30.2	34.8	53.1
26	3.49	6.54	0.0	2.18	3.86	0.0	24.6	7.7	70.6	25.6	-4.0	80.8	37.8
27	1.99	4.20	7.2	2.63	4.76	0.0	41.3	-30.1	30.6	25.3	-21.0	47.1	21.2
28	1.91	2.97	16.7	0.87	1.39	43.3	44.4	-9.6	56.9	28.0	-17.5	53.0	42.5
29	1.18	2.06	45.3	1.25	2.44	10.0	31.7	-17.4	44.8	32.0	11.3	63.4	40.9
30	1.03	1.75	53.0	1.56	2.70	0.1	33.3	-18.2	42.3	41.4	-7.1	67.8	40.8
31	3.95	6.21	0.0	6.94	10.98	0.0	51.1	-44.4	26.0	34.1	0.1	84.8	27.7
32	1.37	2.38	36.8	1.08	1.90	25.7	26.7	19.7	41.9	31.0	20.6	45.6	37.5
33	1.09	2.47	41.4	0.73	3.64	26.6	33.3	-7.4	67.1	28.0	-21.0	46.0	45.3
34	0.70	1.28	66.7	1.04	1.91	26.8	35.0	38.7	33.6	21.6	18.0	54.8	45.5
35	0.94	1.48	58.8	0.75	1.28	49.2	40.4	-26.3	31.0	31.5	-28.8	36.1	43.8
36	1.81	3.93	11.1	1.26	2.68	9.5	16.6	-3.7	83.6	20.1	8.1	75.0	44.8
37	1.82	3.36	13.0	1.81	3.19	0.0	27.9	-7.5	69.4	36.0	31.5	34.2	29.1
38	2.81	6.60	0.0	0.86	1.53	40.5	17.7	9.7	69.2	20.4	14.9	61.5	42.8
39	1.41	2.35	36.3	3.40	5.66	0.0	36.4	-13.9	50.8	31.2	-1.4	83.6	42.6
40	1.93	3.71	8.4	1.87	3.34	0.0	26.3	6.0	73.8	35.9	51.2	34.2	29.1
41	1.92	3.35	10.9	0.94	2.18	24.3	27.5	-23.8	37.1	20.0	-3.3	84.6	39.2
42	1.37	2.35	37.1	1.39	2.17	10.2	55.5	-44.7	23.9	28.9	-13.3	60.9	33.0
43	1.62	2.66	27.3	1.43	2.22	8.0	37.3	-18.4	39.8	21.8	-16.9	56.8	33.0
44	1.14	1.91	48.2	1.07	2.52	15.7	48.3	-29.7	27.3	38.8	-37.5	32.9	31.0
45	1.07	2.66	39.1	0.53	1.00	62.1	28.8	13.5	55.3	35.4	40.0	34.4	47.7
46	1.96	4.91	7.9	0.35	0.61	76.2	32.7	7.2	67.9	31.0	-2.0	82.4	58.6
47	1.11	1.49	54.9	0.72	1.00	56.1	64.9	-17.5	29.1	26.5	-1.0	86.3	56.6
48	2.01	4.13	6.7	1.78	3.19	0.0	21.6	-0.8	87.9	20.5	-2.6	85.8	45.1
49	2.80	5.03	0.0	0.92	1.75	34.0	30.1	30.2	35.9	26.5	19.4	49.8	29.9
50	1.10	1.99	47.9	1.57	2.87	0.0	27.5	3.8	78.2	29.5	-5.9	75.3	50.4
Avg	1.83	3.41	26.3	1.56	2.91	18.7	30.7	-2.5	55.7	27.1	2.1	62.9	40.9

Detailed Results for Rank 21

Team: fractal
Affiliation: Fractal Analytics Inc, India
Submitted on: 2016-09-27

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	6.36	14.28	0.0	0.96	3.66	19.3	27.2	9.0	66.4	21.5	-2.9	84.8	42.6
2	6.20	13.84	0.0	2.36	5.47	0.0	28.5	-9.7	64.0	23.7	-3.3	83.1	36.8
3	6.79	15.07	0.0	1.87	7.29	0.0	25.5	13.1	57.6	35.0	17.7	49.6	26.8
4	11.35	19.41	0.0	8.75	16.42	0.0	32.1	17.1	45.3	19.4	7.2	77.1	30.6
5	12.05	20.21	0.0	5.70	12.76	0.0	29.2	5.7	73.1	29.1	-1.9	83.3	39.1
6	8.48	14.02	0.0	4.68	10.89	0.0	38.7	20.6	34.1	26.2	11.6	65.4	24.9
7	8.23	16.74	0.0	1.90	7.89	0.0	28.9	2.0	81.7	21.8	11.1	68.3	37.5
8	8.13	15.76	0.0	1.88	7.22	0.0	28.7	-2.3	81.2	18.3	-4.1	83.9	41.3
9	7.95	16.35	0.0	3.26	9.76	0.0	31.9	-1.5	81.5	31.8	16.4	53.5	33.8
10	7.51	16.90	0.0	1.41	4.58	4.8	29.3	-7.7	68.3	23.0	0.5	88.9	40.5
11	7.86	16.72	0.0	2.29	8.04	0.0	25.1	12.3	59.8	26.6	10.3	67.8	31.9
12	6.48	14.63	0.0	2.86	7.57	0.0	26.4	5.2	75.6	27.8	6.8	74.3	37.5
13	10.90	18.93	0.0	4.71	12.61	0.0	43.8	40.6	29.4	29.9	11.8	63.4	23.2
14	7.35	16.35	0.0	2.02	6.68	0.0	35.9	33.3	33.1	24.4	25.5	39.3	18.1
15	7.61	15.16	0.0	3.37	6.66	0.0	40.5	26.1	31.0	29.0	7.3	72.8	25.9
16	14.34	23.88	0.0	5.32	14.18	0.0	34.1	16.0	46.9	28.2	-1.8	84.1	32.7
17	11.52	19.95	0.0	7.02	15.30	0.0	37.3	22.9	32.5	33.7	2.1	80.9	28.3
18	7.61	16.34	0.0	1.24	5.98	10.3	28.2	5.7	73.7	27.6	20.7	46.7	32.7
19	9.21	16.05	0.0	4.09	11.11	0.0	28.0	18.4	44.2	29.7	-2.9	81.2	31.3
20	7.89	16.24	0.0	1.69	5.81	0.0	36.9	16.8	43.8	25.6	-6.1	76.7	30.1
21	13.05	23.47	0.0	4.70	11.37	0.0	34.8	-5.4	71.2	24.2	-15.8	58.0	32.3
22	9.36	16.86	0.0	11.50	21.32	0.0	32.7	10.9	59.5	21.5	-8.9	73.0	33.1
23	8.83	15.61	0.0	3.19	9.63	0.0	37.9	11.9	54.6	43.2	51.4	31.0	21.4
24	7.97	17.14	0.0	2.80	9.56	0.0	32.3	23.4	34.8	27.3	-1.1	85.9	30.2
25	6.02	13.93	0.0	0.62	1.82	42.5	24.0	13.5	57.5	44.9	40.6	30.2	32.5
26	10.93	18.21	0.0	5.62	12.16	0.0	29.9	-0.7	84.4	30.1	-4.1	78.7	40.8
27	9.80	17.60	0.0	2.83	8.66	0.0	41.5	3.6	72.2	18.8	2.4	86.9	39.8
28	6.78	14.86	0.0	0.59	1.28	54.6	39.8	28.4	31.3	24.3	-6.0	77.3	40.8
29	12.30	21.91	0.0	3.60	10.37	0.0	28.1	-6.4	72.0	31.5	15.3	55.9	32.0
30	5.98	13.30	0.0	1.05	5.75	16.2	26.6	7.4	70.4	32.1	-1.7	82.4	42.3
31	10.81	18.00	0.0	10.39	20.37	0.0	38.4	5.5	69.2	34.6	25.9	34.8	26.0
32	9.20	17.82	0.0	3.33	12.06	0.0	37.0	20.2	35.8	25.5	7.4	74.1	27.5
33	6.09	13.62	0.0	0.89	4.10	21.5	32.7	2.7	78.5	28.0	-16.8	54.3	38.6
34	8.28	16.69	0.0	1.45	5.29	3.5	46.1	64.0	28.3	32.9	17.4	50.9	20.7
35	6.56	14.43	0.0	1.15	2.96	13.0	29.1	16.9	47.3	24.5	-9.1	71.2	32.9
36	8.05	17.16	0.0	1.80	7.53	0.0	21.6	3.6	81.5	23.0	10.8	68.5	37.5
37	7.53	16.42	0.0	1.41	3.13	4.9	31.4	25.5	35.2	40.2	41.1	32.3	18.1
38	7.21	15.64	0.0	2.07	5.63	0.0	27.8	14.4	53.7	27.0	14.0	60.3	28.5
39	7.94	15.88	0.0	4.42	10.99	0.0	42.5	19.4	35.1	29.3	18.5	50.4	21.4
40	11.45	20.47	0.0	7.28	19.10	0.0	29.1	17.4	46.0	31.9	28.8	35.9	20.5
41	6.74	14.51	0.0	1.42	6.78	4.5	28.2	-13.5	55.5	26.9	8.9	70.5	32.6
42	7.98	15.48	0.0	5.42	12.16	0.0	35.8	30.2	33.2	33.8	16.8	51.7	21.2
43	6.51	14.64	0.0	0.59	1.44	51.0	35.7	22.7	33.2	16.2	-6.9	79.2	40.9
44	7.91	17.08	0.0	2.26	6.49	0.0	26.2	-2.0	83.1	24.8	-14.5	60.2	35.8
45	9.19	17.35	0.0	3.04	10.81	0.0	40.3	39.8	31.1	32.6	22.3	41.3	18.1
46	6.81	14.89	0.0	2.83	8.11	0.0	29.7	16.1	48.8	29.6	8.2	70.7	29.9
47	9.12	17.05	0.0	2.80	8.69	0.0	64.1	15.7	33.6	29.6	3.4	80.3	28.5
48	8.21	17.06	0.0	1.61	5.67	0.0	28.0	11.2	61.0	25.1	5.3	78.3	34.8
49	8.84	16.97	0.0	2.93	8.65	0.0	34.1	30.3	34.0	32.7	29.8	35.6	17.4
50	9.41	17.94	0.0	3.22	10.71	0.0	29.6	-2.3	80.8	30.0	7.0	72.9	38.4
Avg	8.57	16.78	0.0	3.28	8.85	4.9	33.0	13.4	54.7	28.2	8.3	65.2	31.2

Detailed Results for Rank 22

Team: sas_twente
Affiliation: University of Twente, Netherlands
Submitted on: 2012-02-09

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	1.54	2.21	35.5	2.50	3.48	0.0	49.8	42.3	26.6	46.0	-6.6	66.6	32.2
2	2.40	3.29	3.2	2.01	3.79	0.0	53.2	-8.2	56.0	37.0	34.4	33.7	23.2
3	2.88	4.37	0.0	1.23	1.86	21.7	63.4	34.4	20.2	48.0	34.1	28.9	17.7
4	1.04	1.43	57.3	1.05	1.69	31.2	36.3	26.1	33.0	33.3	2.6	80.1	50.4
5	0.85	1.19	64.8	2.22	3.46	0.0	46.1	24.4	28.3	52.0	20.6	36.2	32.3
6	2.69	3.82	0.0	2.46	3.79	0.0	59.5	38.9	22.0	55.5	46.2	25.6	11.9
7	1.21	1.76	49.0	2.05	3.05	0.0	43.9	32.5	29.4	46.3	53.3	29.6	27.0
8	1.04	1.42	57.3	4.56	6.35	0.0	39.5	-2.3	76.1	55.7	-20.0	35.8	42.3
9	5.60	7.62	0.0	7.12	8.90	0.0	77.7	-28.3	13.5	88.8	11.0	39.1	13.2
10	2.02	3.25	10.3	6.66	8.49	0.0	50.0	7.2	60.0	49.6	-11.3	55.7	31.5
11	1.75	2.63	24.9	7.65	9.68	0.0	57.1	55.7	23.2	57.1	42.2	24.9	18.3
12	2.55	3.64	0.0	2.76	4.24	0.0	62.3	55.0	20.7	60.4	95.9	23.4	11.0
13	1.99	2.65	19.6	4.90	6.67	0.0	63.3	127.4	20.2	69.3	27.1	19.5	14.8
14	1.51	2.15	37.1	1.16	1.71	27.3	56.9	45.1	23.3	44.0	23.0	35.0	30.7
15	1.28	1.74	47.8	4.93	6.70	0.0	63.4	36.0	20.2	70.2	68.2	19.1	21.8
16	1.86	2.74	21.0	3.53	5.09	0.0	56.6	71.5	23.4	62.7	3.4	65.7	27.5
17	2.11	2.94	12.8	4.85	6.61	0.0	57.9	54.8	22.8	88.7	42.8	11.0	11.6
18	1.29	1.76	47.3	1.67	2.40	0.0	59.2	49.4	22.2	52.3	59.3	27.0	24.1
19	1.42	1.99	41.1	3.75	5.07	0.0	53.7	62.3	24.8	59.0	26.6	24.0	22.5
20	2.36	3.56	0.0	5.42	7.38	0.0	60.8	40.8	21.4	54.7	15.1	46.0	16.8
21	2.47	3.38	1.9	2.52	4.09	0.0	49.0	25.8	27.0	43.5	24.6	32.0	15.2
22	1.01	1.35	59.2	4.34	5.88	0.0	42.7	49.3	29.9	52.7	-2.2	72.5	40.4
23	1.23	1.56	51.3	8.24	10.54	0.0	56.2	55.7	23.6	90.0	76.0	10.4	21.3
24	0.97	1.32	60.5	4.77	6.11	0.0	55.6	85.5	23.9	97.6	-22.4	12.6	24.2
25	1.32	1.72	47.1	3.80	5.71	0.0	51.0	28.3	26.0	75.3	56.5	16.9	22.5
26	1.14	1.50	54.2	2.34	3.94	0.0	51.1	27.8	26.0	57.5	21.0	33.0	28.3
27	3.05	4.12	0.0	3.35	5.18	0.0	60.2	27.8	21.7	66.1	-13.5	44.2	16.5
28	1.65	2.76	25.3	3.64	5.07	0.0	56.0	80.0	23.7	43.7	-14.1	52.7	25.4
29	3.33	4.68	0.0	2.06	4.01	0.0	51.7	14.1	43.1	52.4	42.0	26.9	17.5
30	1.86	2.59	23.1	2.73	3.91	0.0	60.1	41.0	21.8	59.6	76.5	23.8	17.2
31	2.30	3.62	0.5	2.11	3.49	0.0	54.9	32.9	24.2	63.1	76.0	22.2	11.7
32	0.95	1.25	61.8	1.12	1.76	27.4	52.3	86.9	25.4	49.9	60.4	28.1	35.7
33	1.96	2.83	17.6	4.97	6.39	0.0	60.4	47.7	21.6	67.9	13.3	43.7	20.7
34	1.16	1.69	51.1	5.71	7.84	0.0	65.2	131.1	19.3	79.0	76.7	15.2	21.4
35	1.19	1.77	49.1	1.34	2.00	15.2	46.8	37.2	28.0	45.5	27.1	30.0	30.6
36	1.50	1.97	39.6	4.09	6.45	0.0	45.6	43.7	28.6	67.4	31.0	20.3	22.1
37	1.53	2.08	37.6	6.74	8.64	0.0	58.5	38.3	22.5	78.6	83.3	15.4	18.9
38	2.37	3.63	0.0	4.87	6.89	0.0	54.4	33.1	24.4	59.4	53.1	23.8	12.1
39	0.97	1.38	59.5	5.68	7.84	0.0	51.2	71.0	25.9	80.1	-6.2	52.4	34.5
40	3.14	4.30	0.0	4.71	6.52	0.0	86.2	39.8	9.5	95.5	-14.2	29.8	9.8
41	0.99	1.62	55.7	2.79	3.88	0.0	35.5	-12.6	54.2	50.4	17.9	42.3	38.1
42	1.20	1.74	49.5	2.91	4.28	0.0	61.4	59.6	21.1	45.8	9.6	60.8	32.9
43	1.85	2.35	26.7	3.62	4.70	0.0	54.0	48.4	24.6	46.7	-10.3	59.0	27.6
44	2.16	3.35	5.8	4.50	6.26	0.0	59.9	37.8	21.8	65.0	56.9	21.4	12.3
45	2.95	4.15	0.0	5.42	7.02	0.0	66.5	45.6	18.8	75.4	120.2	16.8	8.9
46	1.36	1.88	44.0	2.15	3.21	0.0	57.8	52.0	22.8	50.1	64.2	27.9	23.7
47	2.22	2.97	9.9	2.41	3.50	0.0	64.8	31.5	19.5	38.2	20.6	42.3	17.9
48	1.46	2.02	39.8	5.93	8.22	0.0	48.6	62.5	27.1	83.2	4.7	54.0	30.2
49	1.14	1.49	54.3	5.15	6.66	0.0	53.5	67.7	24.8	58.5	18.2	38.1	29.3
50	1.27	1.67	49.0	2.11	3.24	0.0	53.4	26.4	24.9	61.8	50.0	22.8	24.2
Avg	1.82	2.58	30.1	3.77	5.27	2.5	55.5	43.6	26.9	60.6	31.3	34.4	23.4

Detailed Results for Rank 23

Team: Local Regressors
Affiliation: University of Basel, Switzerland
Submitted on: 2010-11-24

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	1.39	1.98	42.0	1.49	2.14	7.8	63.3	-34.9	20.2	73.0	-43.6	17.9	22.0
2	1.34	2.09	41.5	4.45	6.29	0.0	64.8	-51.8	19.5	83.8	-61.1	13.1	18.5
3	0.92	1.36	60.9	1.36	2.18	10.8	53.1	-24.4	25.0	51.4	-10.5	56.5	38.3
4	1.37	1.93	43.1	1.65	2.29	2.4	54.7	-27.7	24.3	97.5	-50.5	7.1	19.2
5	1.23	1.71	49.2	1.44	1.92	13.7	50.7	-26.3	26.2	91.3	-36.8	9.8	24.7
6	1.10	1.65	53.0	1.35	2.05	14.3	63.0	-21.4	20.8	74.8	-41.4	17.1	26.3
7	1.31	1.94	44.2	1.39	2.02	13.3	61.9	-34.6	20.9	76.8	-26.5	16.2	23.6
8	1.66	2.36	30.7	1.26	1.99	18.3	61.8	-43.3	21.0	79.4	-48.6	15.0	21.3
9	1.40	2.00	41.5	2.12	3.03	0.0	69.2	-43.6	17.5	88.2	-39.4	11.2	17.5
10	1.60	2.54	29.4	1.70	2.54	0.0	67.9	-47.8	18.1	74.3	-52.5	17.3	16.2
11	1.46	2.21	37.1	1.30	1.99	16.9	56.3	-22.8	23.5	75.0	-18.9	29.5	26.8
12	1.18	1.53	53.0	1.57	2.10	6.3	64.6	-24.1	19.6	88.7	-16.4	28.4	26.8
13	1.13	1.73	51.2	3.40	5.69	0.0	62.0	1.8	66.6	87.6	-16.9	27.9	36.4
14	1.20	1.71	49.9	1.54	2.26	3.6	68.8	-23.6	17.6	84.5	-47.9	12.8	21.0
15	1.50	1.94	40.0	2.02	2.69	0.0	62.2	-15.1	35.9	82.8	-11.5	40.8	29.2
16	2.33	3.01	7.3	2.03	2.69	0.0	85.1	-14.2	27.3	88.0	-38.8	11.3	11.4
17	1.22	1.78	48.5	2.14	2.83	0.0	64.4	-13.4	38.6	83.9	-53.0	13.1	25.1
18	0.82	1.14	66.2	1.81	2.50	0.0	54.4	-31.0	24.4	67.0	-18.2	34.5	31.3
19	0.83	1.28	63.8	1.23	1.67	25.8	56.8	-15.3	37.9	58.0	-26.9	24.5	38.0
20	1.85	2.77	20.8	1.73	2.61	0.0	75.0	-33.7	14.7	86.0	-37.3	12.2	11.9
21	1.32	1.94	44.1	1.80	2.48	0.0	62.6	-32.1	20.6	73.0	-44.9	17.9	20.6
22	1.96	2.65	20.0	1.46	2.17	8.0	73.0	-31.6	15.7	87.3	-45.6	11.6	13.8
23	2.03	2.81	16.4	1.53	2.27	3.9	64.9	-28.9	19.5	95.1	-22.1	14.3	13.5
24	1.18	1.65	51.0	1.19	1.79	24.8	53.0	-21.8	25.1	76.3	-24.0	18.9	30.0
25	1.44	2.20	37.9	1.69	2.48	0.0	58.1	-40.2	22.7	87.3	-28.7	11.6	18.0
26	2.03	3.41	7.7	1.62	2.24	3.4	61.0	-35.0	21.3	80.9	-34.0	14.4	11.7
27	1.31	1.79	46.4	2.49	3.31	0.0	77.5	-27.5	13.6	93.5	-67.8	8.9	17.2
28	2.52	3.57	0.0	1.95	2.62	0.0	67.3	-20.6	20.7	91.0	-62.3	9.9	7.7
29	1.43	2.10	39.4	2.93	4.29	0.0	60.2	-42.0	21.7	93.2	-44.1	9.0	17.5
30	1.08	1.61	53.8	1.27	1.91	19.5	49.8	-25.6	26.6	63.1	-6.4	59.5	39.9
31	1.55	2.30	33.9	3.72	5.98	0.0	54.9	-28.6	24.2	94.7	-31.6	8.3	16.6
32	0.88	1.30	62.5	1.31	1.79	20.9	53.8	-9.6	52.4	70.7	-17.6	34.0	42.5
33	0.83	1.29	63.8	1.35	1.84	18.2	62.3	-17.1	31.3	71.7	-36.0	18.4	32.9
34	1.71	2.15	32.7	1.05	1.67	31.5	66.5	19.4	23.8	73.7	-7.3	53.1	35.3
35	1.80	2.61	24.2	2.05	2.87	0.0	77.2	-19.5	18.5	87.5	-55.0	11.5	13.5
36	0.92	1.31	61.7	1.08	1.53	33.3	55.2	-36.2	24.1	88.9	-49.0	10.9	32.5
37	1.61	2.17	34.5	1.83	2.77	0.0	66.9	-24.7	18.6	80.7	-14.6	35.6	22.2
38	1.47	2.90	27.2	1.46	2.07	10.0	53.1	-31.4	25.0	76.4	-34.7	16.4	19.7
39	2.89	4.21	0.0	4.13	6.22	0.0	82.2	-25.9	11.4	93.8	-25.1	8.9	5.1
40	1.29	1.80	46.7	1.57	2.13	5.6	78.5	-23.6	13.1	77.4	-5.0	56.0	30.4
41	2.09	3.10	10.9	1.88	2.62	0.0	62.3	-52.1	20.7	84.7	-48.7	12.7	11.1
42	1.58	2.17	35.1	1.91	2.70	0.0	74.1	-19.3	20.6	88.1	-39.8	11.2	16.7
43	1.35	1.89	44.0	1.29	1.74	22.4	58.7	-20.0	26.2	69.1	-49.3	19.6	28.1
44	1.24	1.89	46.5	1.61	2.31	1.8	70.1	-25.5	17.1	78.4	-42.7	15.5	20.2
45	1.08	1.61	53.8	1.39	1.80	17.9	52.9	-6.4	60.4	78.8	-16.8	32.0	41.0
46	2.03	2.57	19.8	2.07	2.48	0.0	73.8	-13.7	33.5	98.2	-18.0	21.1	18.6
47	1.92	2.71	20.1	2.25	3.23	0.0	76.6	-29.9	14.0	89.4	-63.8	10.7	11.2
48	1.20	1.70	50.1	1.48	1.99	11.1	54.1	-29.6	24.6	82.2	-39.0	13.8	24.9
49	1.24	1.80	47.7	1.41	2.06	11.9	55.5	-13.7	42.3	85.3	-32.0	12.5	28.6
50	1.18	1.62	51.5	1.21	1.66	26.6	63.7	-22.6	20.1	69.7	-11.6	46.3	36.1
Avg	1.46	2.11	39.1	1.82	2.61	8.1	63.6	-25.6	25.0	81.4	-34.3	20.8	23.3

Detailed Results for Rank 24

Team: Dept. of Photogrammetry
Affiliation: University of Bonn, Germany
Submitted on: 2010-10-19

	Femur bone			Tibia bone			Femur cartilage			Tibia cartilage
Test case	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	AvgD [mm]	RMSD [mm]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	VOE [%]	VD [%]	Scr	Total Scr
1	1.65	2.22	32.9	1.28	1.84	20.7	40.5	45.9	31.0	42.2	-5.1	71.4	39.0
2	1.51	2.25	35.4	2.20	2.97	0.0	44.5	-19.1	34.9	37.4	26.1	33.5	25.9
3	1.99	2.92	15.5	3.06	4.40	0.0	43.9	13.7	47.7	63.6	116.2	22.0	21.3
4	1.57	2.21	34.8	1.64	2.62	0.0	56.2	17.2	33.7	30.9	3.4	79.7	37.1
5	1.77	2.35	28.4	2.68	4.34	0.0	43.2	4.7	68.8	48.8	21.2	36.5	33.4
6	1.60	2.22	34.0	1.37	2.01	14.4	45.3	34.8	28.7	45.0	25.1	30.4	26.9
7	2.23	3.27	5.5	2.28	3.27	0.0	48.4	18.5	34.4	54.9	85.5	25.8	16.4
8	1.80	2.49	25.8	2.03	2.99	0.0	69.4	-56.1	17.4	57.9	104.2	24.5	16.9
9	2.56	3.57	0.0	2.69	3.92	0.0	55.6	-11.1	48.2	64.0	60.0	21.8	17.5
10	1.87	2.55	23.4	2.19	2.89	0.0	39.8	-35.0	31.3	55.1	74.7	25.8	20.1
11	2.18	2.94	11.2	1.65	2.27	2.7	58.3	11.0	47.1	61.3	118.1	23.0	21.0
12	2.10	3.62	4.8	2.08	3.36	0.0	57.0	28.1	23.2	61.3	57.2	23.0	12.7
13	1.96	2.69	19.6	1.84	2.83	0.0	63.5	146.9	20.2	90.6	-39.0	10.1	12.5
14	1.71	2.44	28.5	1.58	2.31	1.9	54.5	101.4	24.4	67.8	-50.0	20.1	18.7
15	2.33	3.40	1.8	2.23	3.11	0.0	60.8	-34.1	21.4	64.1	123.2	21.8	11.2
16	2.64	3.82	0.0	2.47	4.42	0.0	79.6	-16.6	24.1	65.3	34.5	21.2	11.3
17	1.92	2.56	22.2	2.07	3.03	0.0	53.0	52.1	25.1	55.4	4.7	66.3	28.4
18	1.76	2.70	23.9	2.35	4.07	0.0	51.8	82.7	25.7	78.4	-71.2	15.5	16.2
19	1.51	2.16	36.9	0.97	1.53	36.9	46.4	43.2	28.2	46.9	54.7	29.3	32.8
20	2.27	3.34	3.5	1.99	2.85	0.0	60.9	-4.8	60.4	50.6	44.9	27.7	22.9
21	1.19	1.81	48.7	2.49	4.43	0.0	54.7	23.5	24.3	67.2	-28.8	20.4	23.3
22	1.93	2.86	17.7	2.48	3.67	0.0	55.2	66.8	24.1	84.6	-78.0	12.8	13.6
23	2.08	2.98	12.9	3.09	4.42	0.0	50.2	-17.3	36.4	66.3	72.5	20.8	17.5
24	2.34	3.30	3.1	2.32	3.46	0.0	45.5	35.7	28.6	52.7	18.2	40.7	18.1
25	2.04	2.99	13.6	2.20	3.11	0.0	34.0	28.5	34.0	56.5	50.3	25.1	18.2
26	1.86	2.53	24.1	1.93	3.22	0.0	44.3	9.3	57.7	46.1	45.6	29.7	27.9
27	1.59	2.33	32.7	2.07	3.07	0.0	60.4	-19.0	27.6	51.3	86.6	27.4	21.9
28	4.03	5.97	0.0	1.92	2.68	0.0	65.3	0.2	68.9	43.2	37.1	31.0	25.0
29	1.18	1.78	49.4	2.97	4.50	0.0	57.2	31.2	23.1	68.7	30.5	19.8	23.1
30	2.09	3.01	12.3	1.57	2.57	0.0	52.1	16.0	38.5	68.0	21.3	27.8	19.6
31	3.54	4.97	0.0	1.85	3.05	0.0	58.9	-13.5	41.2	51.8	40.5	27.2	17.1
32	1.38	2.00	41.9	1.08	1.56	33.1	44.6	51.1	29.0	58.0	47.4	24.5	32.1
33	2.09	3.25	8.9	1.54	2.83	0.7	59.3	-12.8	42.4	59.7	83.1	23.7	18.9
34	1.64	2.38	30.7	1.98	2.80	0.0	58.1	-25.7	22.7	59.7	118.9	23.7	19.3
35	1.76	2.45	27.3	1.71	2.52	0.0	66.4	-45.3	18.8	44.1	11.6	57.6	25.9
36	1.48	2.54	32.1	1.35	2.02	14.8	42.2	53.8	30.2	71.9	-63.8	18.4	23.9
37	4.33	6.16	0.0	5.44	7.62	0.0	77.1	33.1	13.7	100.0	-100.0	6.0	4.9
38	2.46	3.72	0.0	1.74	2.55	0.0	53.6	-9.9	52.0	61.6	144.1	22.9	18.7
39	2.56	3.42	1.4	3.46	4.82	0.0	59.6	2.0	67.3	60.5	109.7	23.4	23.0
40	3.64	5.56	0.0	4.25	6.88	0.0	52.2	28.9	25.5	66.8	94.8	20.6	11.5
41	2.80	3.60	0.0	1.97	2.65	0.0	64.0	-57.6	19.9	61.4	102.5	23.0	10.7
42	2.40	3.41	1.5	2.99	4.14	0.0	74.2	-46.6	15.2	65.9	118.8	21.0	9.4
43	2.12	3.00	11.7	2.14	2.87	0.0	62.4	-18.3	28.4	50.4	12.5	52.9	23.3
44	1.73	2.54	26.5	1.95	2.98	0.0	61.4	62.4	21.2	86.4	-86.4	12.0	14.9
45	1.63	2.46	30.0	1.40	2.23	8.7	59.6	15.1	37.0	68.3	71.9	19.9	23.9
46	2.48	3.44	1.1	1.92	3.59	0.0	61.2	18.8	27.6	61.1	75.6	23.1	13.0
47	1.87	2.44	24.9	1.72	2.27	2.6	78.9	-56.2	12.9	60.2	102.4	23.5	16.0
48	1.60	2.37	31.8	1.11	1.65	30.0	44.3	13.3	48.5	49.5	17.8	42.8	38.3
49	2.42	3.42	1.5	3.50	5.17	0.0	57.6	30.5	22.9	78.0	14.0	38.0	15.6
50	2.07	2.90	14.2	3.16	4.73	0.0	55.3	53.9	24.0	91.3	-82.1	9.8	12.0
Avg	2.11	3.03	17.8	2.20	3.30	3.3	55.7	13.5	32.8	61.1	37.5	28.0	20.5